Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    New Laws Will Finally Make Copying CDs Legal

    An outdated law meaning millions of people are unknowingly copying music illegally is due to be swept away by the Government.

    Business Secretary Vince Cable has backed proposals to update what some have called the country's "archaic copyright laws".

    At the moment it is technically illegal to transfer content from CDs and DVDs onto a different format such as a computer or MP3 player.

    The Government is putting the wheels in motion to change this, allowing people to transfer content and make copies for their own and immediate family's personal use.

    However, at present millions of people are breaking the law, with many unaware they are doing it.

    Intellectual property lawyer for Mishcon De Reya Adam Morallee believes legislation is merely catching up with what is already being done.

    "It really does have to catch up and look at what's happening. The people who operate the fast sharing sites are miles ahead of the where the legislators are."

    These proposals are in response to a review of Intellectual Property legislation carried out in May. The government is expected to agree with much of the report.

    Sharing of copyrighted material over the internet will still be illegal.

    However some critics in the entertainment industry believe these proposals are merely altering an outdated law.

    What they are not doing is tackling the real and pressing problem posed by illegal downloading.

    Jonathan Shalit, chairman of Roar Global which represents artists, told Sky News he is worried about the repercussions for his clients.

    "The minute you say it is legal to copy something you're then legitimising it and where does the barrier or boundaries of immediate family end.

    "I think it has not been well thought through and a lack of respect remains for artists who create the original product."

    Online spoofs are also expected to receive legal protection.

    The makers of Newport State of Mind , a song which satirised singer Alicia Key's Empire version by moving it from New York to South Wales, was removed from YouTube recently after a legal battle.

    MJ Delaney, the director of the track, did not realise she had been breaking the law when she made the video and agrees with the changes.

    "EMI who took it down, they weren't a victim in any sense of what we've done.

    "By the time we'd done that video the song Empire State of Mind was pretty old. It was long gone out of the charts so if anything all we did was raise the profile of the song and remind everyone what a great song it was."

    It is hoped the moves will benefit the UK economy, in part because individuals will be able to legally back up their music, films and e-books, encouraging the development of new technology.

    It will clear the way for companies such as Google and Amazon to market online content storage systems for UK consumers, allowing them to create back-up files of their music and film libraries in a "cloud" on the internet, so they can be retrieved even if their own computer or MP3 player is stolen or lost.

     

    157 comments

    • James  •  9 months ago
      cds used to be about 16 pound, they were really screwing us over weren't they? I don't listen to new stuff really, so I don't have any guilt for 'sharing' older music. Hendrix doesn't need money anymore, and if it means one less ferrari in mick jagger's garage, I can live with that.
      • The Englishman 9 months ago
        Bang on the nai head mate.

        .
      • Nonames Nopackdrill 9 months ago
        Can't argue with your point about Hendrix or Jagger, (could add a couple of dozen others as well). Problem with your argument is that the Jaggers and Hendrix only represent a tiny fraction of the entire music scene and whilst 20,000 people illegally downloading the Stones latest album will be barely noticable it has serious consequences for the other 99% of artists, particularly the up-and-coming ones who are struggling. I'm not defending the profit margins of the big record companies but the fact is that without money to invest there will be fewer new artists being given recording contracts.
      • scott 9 months ago
        o boo bloody hoo £16 for a cd ....do the maths a 10 track album in physical format will now cost you lets say £7.99 even less sometimes you go to i-tunes and download it its gonna cost you 99p a track x 10 tracks thats 9.99 but if you buy the cd not only do you have it as a physical copy you have the art work ..whos getting ripped off ? i mean what is the problem paying for music ? i have a record collection of over 3000 records and nearly 2000 cd's not once grudged paying for any of them the artists do a job which is supplying you with music , its not their fault if they happen to write good music and people buy it .you would go out to work all week for nothing would you ? no ..so why should they !!
    • claire  •  9 months ago
      i wonder how many people knew it was illegal to copy a cd and put it on a computer or mp3 because i didn't by the same right making mix tapes must've been illegal and who didn't tape songs off the radio or MTV back in the day when CD's and tapes were expensive and you wanted the latest songs 15quid for a CD and a tenner for a cassette album weren't pocket money prices

      i can't stand it when people think it's ok to steal music from torrents and p2p's or rip music from legal streaming services just because they think the record companies are making buckets of money they forget about the rest of the chain manufacturers the distributors the wholesale the record stores (chain and independent) e.t.c who rely on people buying music when you steal music you don't just hurt the record labels and people don't seem to consider that
    • claire  •  9 months ago
      i wonder how many people knew it was illegal to copy a cd and put it on a computer or mp3 because i didn't by the same right making mix tapes must've been illegal and who didn't tape songs off the radio or MTV back in the day when CD's and tapes were expensive and you wanted the latest songs 15quid for a CD and a tenner for a cassette album weren't pocket money prices

      i can't stand it when people think it's ok to steal music from torrents and p2p's or rip music from legal streaming services just because they think the record companies are making buckets of money they forget about the rest of the chain manufacturers the distributors the wholesale the record stores (chain and independent) e.t.c who rely on people buying music when you steal music you don't just hurt the record labels and people don't seem to consider that
    • claire  •  9 months ago
      i wonder how many people knew it was illegal to copy a cd and put it on a computer or mp3 because i didn't by the same right making mix tapes must've been illegal and who didn't tape songs off the radio or MTV back in the day when CD's and tapes were expensive and you wanted the latest songs 15quid for a CD and a tenner for a cassette album weren't pocket money prices

      i can't stand it when people think it's ok to steal music from torrents and p2p's or rip music from legal streaming services just because they think the record companies are making buckets of money they forget about the rest of the chain manufacturers the distributors the wholesale the record stores (chain and independent) e.t.c who rely on people buying music when you steal music you don't just hurt the record labels and people don't seem to consider that
    • JahGussi  •  9 months ago
      Comments 1 - 20 of 158, I've pressed the arrows for Next - Last or Prev with no luck I can olny see the first 20 comments??

      Is Yahoo into Censorship as in suppression of speech or other public communication.

      How many of you own a backup car or house?
      So what do you do if your car or house got destroyed? use your backup copy?

      And this comment - It's not just teens, I've come across 40year olds who've spend weeks downloading
      mp3's they don't own.

      "Why do teens download music on p2p sites? Same reason my friends and I owned double cassette decks when we were teens because we couldn't afford to buy the albums and singles! "

      That's Stealing, if you ain't got the money for something then you should go without. Simple.
      Funny how they find the money to copy something.

      It's people who have become greedy, with hard drives full of mp3's, complete record collections
      that took people like me years of hard work to collect.

      I don't see the point of backing up anyway, If it took me 20years to build up a collection of music it will take another 20years just to back it up. Plus where will I find the time.
    • Who  •  9 months ago
      Personally If I were to download a cd I would have no problem in paying the same royalties to the artist as what they got from the sale of the CD

      But I would not be paying that. I dont know what they do actually receive in royalties, but I'll bet its nowhere near what record companies want to charge for downloading
    • ịcąгυѕ  •  9 months ago
      I remember when I was a teenager £15 for an album was not something I could afford, nor was my mum willing to pay without a lot of begging and pleading. And me and my friends would rely heavily on swapping our CD's around. Yes they have lowered the prices of CD's and singles, but it's too late. If they had made music more accessible and affordable then people wouldn't have to resort to swapping music or downloading. That was my only option as I couldn't afford an album back in the day.

      I'm not about to re purchase my albums just to have a mp3 copy on my computer as CD's get scratched, ruined etc. I am entitled to have a back up of my purchased music to use for my own personal use. I'm not about to bust out the old portable CD player. Not happening.
    • Alan  •  9 months ago
      about time, maybe sony will stop being such idiots over bob dylan songs on you tube. the more people who hear or listen are more likely to want to see artists, sod the greedy companies, they have made billions from cheap plastic discs.
    • A Yahoo! User  •  9 months ago
      Where do these people live ??. They all know it's illegal but do not give a @#$% for such a stupid law in this era of transferable music / media , these firms have ripped everybody off for years .
      micky0121
    • EX2RGJ  •  9 months ago
      Does this mean Limewire can get going again, they are my family and friends.
    • John K  •  9 months ago
      Ok. So gov't will scrap the "Mechanical Copyrights" (recording or taping) law.. How about the mechanical copyright law - the PPL - that allows internet radio stations to broadcast, be scrappped?. The same law - as far as I can see - charges me for uploading a file of copyrighted music, which is stored , then rebroadcast on the net - to the 'public'. Surely, the same principle of the PPL law is applicable to home taping? The "public" could be granny, or a mate hundreds of miles away and up loaded on my computer, sent and he/she downloads. Why can't that law extended to net broadcasting for "non-profit" stations? The Performing Rights Society (tax) is resonable, but the PLL for the enthusiast & not-for-profit station is VERY espensive when having to be paid quarterly. Or is another bit of fleecing & control over the individual? Any comments of operators of present or proposed stations would be appreciated.
    • TheTornJester  •  9 months ago
      In all fairness the law is supposed to serve the people morally, not support greed. End of story.
    • Mr 'X'  •  9 months ago
      If it is an up and coming artist, who isn't successful, then sure- I'll pay for the CD. But for deceased singers, and multi-millionaires, why bother paying? They have too much money already, and the rest of us are suffering in the bad economy. Will I pay £10 to hear one or two good tunes? NO CHANCE!
      The internet is the last bastion of freedom for the people.
    • TheTornJester  •  9 months ago
      Guess what, people? I'm a pirate. Am I ashamed? No. Once the prices of Music, Movies, Video Games, PC Software & E-Books drop to an affordable price and they get rid of DRM (Dynamic Rights Management) I would be more inclined to buy the above mentioned merchandise. Until that day arrives I will continue to illegally download. If anyone thinks that is wrong then they seriously need to wake up to reality. Overpriced digital media is the result of tyrant pigs that sell it (i.e. Record Labels etc.). DRM for example only affect legal buyers but pirates can use Steam/DRM By-passers (for PC Games). This is one more reason as to why I became a pirate.

      Is it really fair to fill our prisons with innocent pirates, while murderers walk the streets, just because the tyrants want their pocket money? Any industry that deals in digital media, whatever that media may be, they need to change their ways to befit the creators of the content (i.e. Authors/Artists) as well as the Customers. If they don't more people will resort to piracy. These company's can spend what they want on DRM research but those smart Pirates can "Crack" it all the time. DRM is a waste of money, OUR money.

      Pirates aren't exactly evil people they are rebelling against corporate greed, and I don't blame us.
    • Bayo  •  9 months ago
      Is this not a way of encouragng piracy ?
    • Kev_UK  •  9 months ago
      I'm not into the boy bands, girl bands, (karaoke "artists") or rap, etc. I listen to radio caroline to hear the old stuff plus many new bands that play instruments, write own songs, etc. As a result i have bought many cd's. As far as i was aware it was legal to make one copy for your own use, as long as you had the original (not copied it to a mp3 player and sold the cd on ebay).
    • T EDWARDS  •  9 months ago
      I bought my first L.P. for 12/6d!!!
    • dod the digger  •  9 months ago
      HI folks i have been of world for last 30 years just returned last week and hay how things have changed. When I left the government was there to govern for the people. seems thats no longer the case. also remember the older generation where respected for the wisdom and experties they had gained with life experience,seems now they are shoved into proverbal sidings of life and totaly disrespected by all concerned including sucsesive goverments. this is all indicative of what is wrong with all aspects of life today and the music industry just hapens to be in the limelight at moment its all about greed manipulation and underhanded tactidks on all fronts to ripe of the public from start to finish.Still never mind i will be going off world again shortly so it wont bother me, have fun all, and remember we all get the government we deserve.
    • banksey  •  9 months ago
      Why don't the rich give themselves a holiday from their insatiable greed and calm down. They've still got enough money in the bank for a thousand lifetimes. Relax guys, you'll give yourself a heart attack. You'll never stop people from sharing, although I realise the concept of sharing must be strange and alien to your natures.
    • Julie  •  9 months ago
      Anyone old enough to remember back in the day when it was a popular past time to tape the "Top 40" off Radio 1 on a Sunday night?

      I used to make "mix tapes" and later on CDs from music I'd ripped onto the laptop - can you imagine how much so-called Illegal material we all must have seeing as many of us are in the habit of making copies of cds,dvds etc.

      Glad they have finally woken up to the fact that it's an out-dated law - at last!