Blog Posts by Ian Dunt

  • The great eurosceptic raffle

    It was a winning British mixture of tradition, sarcasm and extraordinary silliness. Committee room ten was the scene for the private members' bill raffle this morning, in which backbenchers cross their fingers and hope they'll be selected to carry a bill forward to its near-inevitable demise in the Commons chamber.

    It was seriously good fun. Deputy speaker Lindsay Hoyle, whose reputation in parliament is rising by the day, played up to the occasion well. Beside him, David Natzler, clerk of legislation, shuffling some crunched up bits of paper around an ornate black box. It really was that simple: it was like The National Lottery Presents: The Great Reform Act of 1832.

    Perhaps we should use raffles for all political debates. It's as if politics was conducted by the Dice Man. Get a two and we'll integrate social care with the NHS. Get a four and we'll use baby's fingers as a new form of currency. It would liven Westminster up a bit.

    Natzler shuffled the bits of paper around. "Number 20,"

    Read More »from The great eurosceptic raffle
  • Everything you need to know about the Tory EU rebellion in five minutes

    In a day or two, Tory MPs will vote against their own Queen's Speech in order to attach a symbolic statement reiterating what their leader has already promised them. It's all very baffling. What exactly are they trying to achieve and how much damage will it cause David Cameron?

    What are Tory backbenchers doing?

    Leading Conservative eurosceptics have tabled an amendment to the motion welcoming the Queen's Speech. At the end of line five, they want to add the statement: "But respectfully regret that an EU referendum bill was not included in the Gracious Speech".

    The effort is led by one of parliament's most die-hard eurosceptics, John Baron, with able assistance by fellow right-wing troublemaker Peter Bone. Most of the other signatories are the usual suspects: bad tempered Tory backbenchers who are now quite used to rocking the boat. In fact, it's almost second nature. They include: Philip Hollobone, Philip Davies, Douglas Carswell, David Davis, Nick de Bois, Adam Afriyie, Zac Goldsmith,

    Read More »from Everything you need to know about the Tory EU rebellion in five minutes
  • Very quietly, Grayling is privatising the probation service

    What do you do with a public service which is enjoying considerable success and just won the British Quality Foundation Gold Award for Excellence? The answer is very simple: you scrap it and open it up to private competition.

    Justice secretary Chris Grayling is implementing the wholesale privatisation of the probation service.

    Quite why is anyone's guess. The probation service has managed to get reoffending rates down to 34.2% after a decade of steady year-on-year decline. It is a minor success story in a difficult area of public policy.

    Grayling has blamed the service for the persistently high reoffending rates of those in jail less than a year. The only trouble with this argument is that the probation service has no responsibility for this area and hasn't done for nearly three decades. The part of the system which isn't working is precisely the bit which the probation service does not control.

    To his credit, Grayling has been fairly explicit about his plans. The probation service

    Read More »from Very quietly, Grayling is privatising the probation service
  • Miliband should call Cameron’s EU bluff

    Keith Vaz isn't often right, but he's right today. "An in/out referendum before the next election would clear the air," he tweeted. "We could actually hold it on the day of the next general election."

    His view is presumably less influenced by his desire to "clear the air" than it is by basic political strategy, but his basic political strategy is a very good one.

    Labour's shadow Europe minister, Emma Reynolds, is in Vienna today outlining the party's policy on Europe. Miliband's in a bit of a bind. The Labour leader does actually believe he will be prime minister come 2015, and he doesn't intend to spend the entire time bickering over Europe. But nor does he want to end up on the wrong side of voters' opinions on the EU by opposing a referendum come election time. Tricky. Luckily for Miliband, Vaz has provided the least bad option: demand a vote in 2015.

    Today's intervention by Nigel Lawson shows quite how damaging David Cameron's EU referendum pledge will prove to be. No matter what

    Read More »from Miliband should call Cameron’s EU bluff
  • Local election analysis: What does the rise of Ukip mean?

    Ukip's performance in the local elections is extraordinary. Even at this early stage, the party has already beaten the (admittedly problematic) benchmark set by respected polling experts Rallings and Thrasher. It is doing very well indeed.

    First, a caveat: they are still not winning anything. Their South Shields by-election result is impressive, but nowhere near enough to get them an MP. They are not taking control of councils. Ukip suffer from the traditional problem of small parties in British politics: the first-past-the-post system means groups with spread-out support have a hard time breaking through. Come in second place and it just doesn't matter how many votes you got.

    But whichever way you look at it, Ukip's tally is undeniably impressive.


                                       [Live blog: All the latest from the remaining counts]

    They continue to take votes from their natural home – irritated Tory voters. Three quarters of the party's gains so far have come at the cost of the

    Read More »from Local election analysis: What does the rise of Ukip mean?
  • Drinking with the enemy: A day with the Ukip foot soldiers

    Photo: Getty Images"When I met Nigel Farage we both had our dicks out. Mind you, it was the gents' toilet. Here, that would make a bloody good headline."

    I'm talking to John, Ukip's organiser in Kingston, in a creaky and well-trodden watering hole in central London. It's the start of a self-imposed, masochistic mission of meeting Ukip foot soldiers face-to-face, in their natural environment (mostly the pub), and finding out if the party's as insane as it looks from the outside.

    I decided on the mission after meeting Diane James during the by-election in Eastleigh. As Ukip candidate, she narrowly lost out to the Lib Dems, but she was easily the most impressive figure on the ballot paper: eloquent, professional and oozing competent. For the first time, you could see a workable party machine starting to form under the purple blazers and beer goggles. The eurosceptic party was rolling out an impressive pavement operation, as if they'd learned a few lessons about local campaigning from the Lib Dems. It seemed

    Read More »from Drinking with the enemy: A day with the Ukip foot soldiers
  • The poll which reveals huge public support for multiculturalism

    As I've mentioned before, multiculturalism is not an ideology, it is merely a statement of fact. The most recent Lord Ashcroft poll suggests it is a particularly successful one.

    The survey of 1,035 minority voters completed earlier this week found nine in ten believed the UK was now multicultural and about that many believe it's a good thing. A representative poll of the general public conducted at the same time found 70% of voters believed it was a good thing. The only group with a majority opposing multiculturalism were Ukip voters. Seventy-one per cent of Tories support multiculturalism, as do 76% of Labour voters and 89% of Lib Dems.

    Ethnic minorities themselves believe the various groups in the UK get on very well with each other. The general population, probably under the influence of persistent tabloid headlines about the mythical breakdown of the British social fabric, tend to overestimate problems between minority groups.

    Particularly pertinent is the optimism with which

    Read More »from The poll which reveals huge public support for multiculturalism
  • The conspiracy to privatise the NHS

    You can usually dismiss Labour's hype pretty easily. If opposition is conducted in poetry and government in prose, then Ed Miliband's is of the sixth-form variety. But there is one area in which it is not exaggerating: The NHS is genuinely being privatised. Under our noses, it is effectively being dismantled.

    The NHS reforms enacted by Andrew Lansley and carried through by his teenage successor, Jeremy Hunt, will soon be fully enshrined in law following a Lords vote in six days time.

    The reforms enjoy no democratic legitimacy. They will be financially ruinous, create an atomised health service and embed perverse incentives in the NHS.

    They have been implemented in a cloak and dagger way which suggests ministers are well aware they would spark public outrage if they were properly understood. Lansley only announced them after the general election. Then he published the legislation without any of the secondary rules which would give them meaning. The entire two-year debate on NHS reform

    Read More »from The conspiracy to privatise the NHS
  • The political left responded to the news of Margaret Thatcher's death yesterday in a mostly subdued manner, although there were some isolated incidences of celebration.

    Some delegates at the National Union of Teachers (NUT) cheered the news, although they were told to desist by organisers.

    Respect MP George Galloway tweeted the Elvis Costello song title 'Tramp the Dirt Down', for which he was attacked by fellow Twitter users.

    He later wrote: "Thatcher described Nelson Mandela as a 'terrorist'. I was there. I saw her lips move. May she burn in the hellfires."

    High street wine merchant Oddbins in Crouch End tweeted: "If for any reason anyone feels like celebrating anything we have Tattinger available at £10 less than usual at 329. Just saying."

    A spokesperson for the company later said: "The tweet in question was made by a member of branch staff without the approval or knowledge of the company's management. The tweet was completely inappropriate and in the worst possible taste.

    "We would

    Read More »from Street parties or sombre reflection? The left responds to the death of Margaret Thatcher
  • How to renew Trident and still sleep at night

    When people think about the origin of nuclear weapons, they tend to quote Robert Oppenheimer, who quoted Hindu scripture after the Trinity test. "Now I am become Death," he said, "the destroyer of worlds."

    I always thought test director Kenneth Bainbridge had it better. He turned to Oppenheimer and said: "Now we are all sons of bitches."
    And we are. Until nuclear weapons are erased from the world, Bainbridge's observation will retain its accuracy. No person of right mind can countenance anything but a world free of them. But unfortunately we are a long way away from that.

    If you are in the middle of Mexican stand-off, you do not just put your gun down on the floor. That's a quick way to get shot. Instead, you get everyone to slowly lower their guns together.

    David Cameron's article this morning on renewing our nuclear deterrent managed to be simultaneously eloquent and brutal. The former qualities related to his arguments while the latter qualities related to his treatment of Nick

    Read More »from How to renew Trident and still sleep at night

Pagination

(179 Stories)