Search

AFP

Did Griffin's Question Time debut help or hinder the BNP?

Fri Oct 23 01:10PM
BNP leader Nick Griffin sniggers during his debut appearance on the BBC's flagship political programme

So after all the protests and the heckling, was Thursday night's "Question Time" appearance a dream or a nightmare for British National Party (BNP) leader Nick Griffin?

Griffin cut a nervous figure on Thursday night, hands trembling and lips twitching as he faced a barrage of angry questions and heckles from a largely hostile studio audience.

All bar one related to the party and its policies, which include ending all immigration.

He looked awkward when pressed to define "indigenous British", the only group of people which the BNP believes belongs in Britain.

And his insistence that he could not explain why he had denied the Holocaust because European law would leave him open to prosecution if he did drew jeers of derision.

The debate on whether the BBC was right to invite him on will probably run and run.

The BNP said on Friday the BBC had changed the whole format of the show so it became "a complete, 100 percent attack on Nick".

Opponents of Griffin's appearance argue "Question Time" was not the right format for a forensic dissection of his policies.

Welsh Secretary Peter Hain has accused the BBC of legitimising "racist poison" while The Guardian said the BBC had gifted Griffin with a "golden opportunity" to persuade people to vote BNP.

But the show's true significance will probably only become clear in a matter of months or even years, rather than days.

The key test will be whether the BNP's recent success is a flash in the pan linked to recession and disillusionment with mainstream politicians, or if it is a longer-term phenomenon.

For the BNP and their political opponents, the real fight will not take place in a London television studio, but on the individual streets of working-class English towns and cities where the far-right party is gaining a foothold.

In this blog, journalists of global news wire AFP blog about the news they report and the challenges they face covering events from Baghdad to Beijing, the White House to Darfur. Katherine Haddon is a correspondent in AFP's London bureau.

Comments1 - 10 of 1641

  1. Griffin was lured into a carefully prepared killing ground and paid the penalty.

    roger3103 From roger3103 on Fri Oct 23 01:18PM

    Report abuse

  2. He held up well.

    cousinsclearance From cousinsclearance on Fri Oct 23 01:21PM

    Report abuse

  3. The losers were DAVID DIMBLEBY whose partial interference and constant refering to notes weakened his normal professional chairmanship...clearly the pressure was too much.Jack Straw looked and acted his age...the other panellists conducted themselves well...not your best effort Dimbleby!!

    beardbooks From beardbooks on Fri Oct 23 01:24PM

    Report abuse

  4. The losers were DAVID DIMBLEBY whose partial interference and constant refering to notes weakened his normal professional chairmanship...clearly the pressure was too much.Jack Straw looked and acted his age...the other panellists conducted themselves well...not your best effort Dimbleby!!...Robert

    beardbooks From beardbooks on Fri Oct 23 01:27PM

    Report abuse

  5. The only hatred on last nights show was directed against mr Griffin and the only Nazis were outside protesting against his freedom of speech. Double standard Britain. The main political parties should be ashamed that the only way to battle the BNP were personal attacks on its leader.

    striker442 From striker442 on Fri Oct 23 01:29PM

    Report abuse

  6. Only the fullness of time will answer the question regarding it will be a hinderance or help to the BNP. However I do wonder if any wavering BNP supporter watching, might have been swayed more towards them due to the fact that Nick Griffin may have came across as the underdog - with 95% of the audience and 100% of the panel against him - As in my opinion this caused him to adopt a far more defensive stance than he would have done if there had been a slightly more sympathetic audience.

    Me thinks that if he had have been allowed to be more opinionated he may well have been more likely to have built his own gallows.

    bonnie.shaun From bonnie.shaun on Fri Oct 23 01:31PM

    Report abuse

  7. Oh MY god,,if this was not one of the worst cases of bullying i have ever seen on tv. I may not totaly believe in mr griffins political views,,but it would of been so nice to of heard them...All we got was a pack of wolves circling him ready to pounce. Jack Straw was a disgrace to the show,,so to mr dimbleby whom i have always rated fair with his geusts,, but no they just wanted to get votes for themselves. little do they realise but their ganging up against mr griiffin has back fired,,shame on these so called do gooders,,not one rule for one,and another for you,,you should be ashamed BBC for not allowing a fair show and coments from all the panel....Oh yes finally,,during the show one member of the audience addressed mr nick griffin as DICK griffin,,disgusting..if nick had callled one of them such a name,,and the person knew what he was doing,,it was not a slip of the tongue,,he claimed he was a british born national,,well act like one

    swanseamotors From swanseamotors on Fri Oct 23 01:34PM

    Report abuse

  8. Talk about the violent BNP.....who were all the violent people demonstrating last night. Oh yes, I forgot, silly me, it's alright for them to be violent because they see themselves as right. Tut tut this country is in the state it's in because of violent protesters who will not listen to other people's opinion. We have to hear the views of the Muslim Parliament of Britain??? the Black police federation?? why can't we hear the views of all other parties. I may not agree with the views of the others and I certainly don't agree with the present Goverment and their policies but I don't go on the street and riot or beat up my neighbour because he doesn't share my views. looks like I may be in the minority nowadays. Absolutly disgusted

    jack.gardner4 From jack.gardner4 on Fri Oct 23 01:35PM

    Report abuse

  9. BBC YOU SHOULD BE ASHAMED,,THIS WAS BULLYING AT ITS TOP LEVEL,,GRIIFFIN NEVER STOOD A CHANCE

    swanseamotors From swanseamotors on Fri Oct 23 01:36PM

    Report abuse

  10. When he said he "hadn't a conviction for Holocaust Denial" it was hardly an answer to the question.His own views were so muddled that the question is just what did he deny-he didn't seem that sure himself.He just came across as a plonker really-a plonker who needs ex football hooligans as minders

    alicespiral From alicespiral on Fri Oct 23 01:39PM

    Report abuse

Comment on this article

Please sign in to add your comments.


Latest UK news

Add to my Yahoo/RSS

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! All rights reserved.

Notice: We collect personal information on this site. To learn more about how we use your information, see our: Updated Privacy Policy