Search

politics.co.uk

What Susan Boyle says about the UK

Mon Jun 01 12:10PM
Susan Boyle is on her way to the Priory clinic today, just another shattered victim of our obsession with celebrity.

Earlier in the weekend, Gordon Brown had this to say: "I hope Susan Boyle is OK because she is a really, really nice person and I think she will do well."

It's the latest prime ministerial intervention in celebrity. During her dying days, Jade Goody was treated to his approval, when he praised her determination "to help her family". A while earlier, he had claimed to wake up to the Arctic Monkeys every morning, a fact most people treated with considerable disbelief.

None of this chimes particularly well with his insistence Britain had started to overcome celebrity, just before becoming prime minister.

Keen to highlight his superiority over Tony Blair, the then-chancellor said: "I think we're moving from this period when, if you like, celebrity matters, when people have become famous for being famous."

If only that was true.

This country has developed an increasingly unhealthy relationship with celebrity. We have always built people up to knock them down, but we now appear to be doing it with a ruthless speed and an utter indifference to their mental state.

Watching Boyle appear on Britain's Got Talent over the weekend was a case in point. After a week of newspaper stories about her increasingly deranged behaviour, she appeared fragile and vulnerable. Her expressions were nervous and indicated a desperation to please, while her mannerisms came across as odd and jolted.

She was, for all to see, just another victim of the celebrity machine. It sucks them in, uses them, and then spits them out: used and worthless.

Some of the blame can be placed on the format of reality television. Big Brother set the tone a decade ago, when it filmed people in an enclosed space for days on end and forced them to vote against each other, before the audience themselves chose who got kicked out. Then talent shows, heavily reliant on a judging panel made up of, ironically, thoroughly talentless but hugely vindictive narcissists, sealed the deal.

Contestants were ushered on, so the audience could bask in the stream of vitriolic unpleasantness emitted from the judges. Gone was politeness, or caring for people's feelings. Cruelty and sneering were in fashion.

But it's not just the format. We are responsible as well. Our obsession with celebrity has now reached a kind of tipping point. Even the expenses scandal was thought appropriate for celebrity fixes, with Esther Rantzen and other D-listers quickly cited as replacements for MPs. What on earth would make us think they would be any less greedy, or incompetent? What possible reason could there be to presume such a thing, unless the country has gradually come to the conclusion that 'celebrity=good', as a form of a priori reasoning.

Broadsheets and glossy celebrity mags seem to live a world apart, but they are in fact two sides of the same coin.

As we become increasingly disillusioned with politics, we turn to the empty world of celebrity to distract ourselves. But in this world, somewhere, are real people. They have feelings, and hopes and aspirations. They are very much like you and I.

When we package them up and sell them - much as Boyle was constructed as a fairy story character - and then ruthlessly tear them down, we damage them. And we also damage ourselves.

When the television shows and magazines and newspapers allow people to talk to others this way - calling Heather Mills a 'slag', for instance - it has a direct effect on the way people treat each other in society.

Children take their cue from those on television, and what they read. And adults, in a slower, less obvious way, do the same.

This isn't a cry for a more family-friendly, Mary Whitehouse style censorship campaign. It's just a request for a little less cruelty, and a little more compassion, in the way we treat the people who enter the news agenda.

David Cameron hasn't made it part of his 'Broken Britain' agenda, even though the two facts are intimately connected. Gordon Brown will only discuss celebrity to jump on the latest bandwagon.

A real political leader would challenge our views, and try to forge something a little healthier. Both for the celebrities, and for Britain.

Ian Dunt

Comments41 - 50 of 1002

  1. And for those who dont understand the opening headline it means what impression of the people in the UK does the treatment of Susan Boyle give

    necromonger1975 From necromonger1975 on Mon Jun 01 01:01PM

    Report abuse

  2. Poor Susan she did look very on the edge at the finale, and her behaviour was very odd after the public vote, so you do not need to be cleaver to see there is something wrong.
    This poor lady now DOES have an idea of how spiteful and hurtful people can be if you don't fit the media's idea of how you should look, as most of the comments are personal, and I am not to sure she would have been up to winning anyway. Whatever happens now I feel sure she will get to do what she likes most and that is to sing
    Shame on the so called journalists, anything to titillate the wolf pack.

    ladytaylorwood From ladytaylorwood on Mon Jun 01 01:03PM

    Report abuse

  3. What a poignant and smart comment on our current state of affairs. And much needed to, I agree, I hope people read this and analyze their own behavior in regard to this fad which has long outstayed its welcome, as we are ALL to blame. Our cultural decline and mindless obsession with "celebrities" will only stop if the media think we will not buy papers that print this garbage (and at at present people simply do, on mass). Why do we find it acceptable that the whole media brutalize a clearly vulnerable and incredibly sweet woman? The best way to show our disapproval of such vulgar behavior is to boycott the trashy papers and magazines that print this rubbish. Although this is a frighteningly large number of tabloids, glossies and unfortunately now even broadsheets, it's the only way they will ever consider changing. If we as a nation say "No we wont stand for it" and refuse to put up with such unintelligent, cruel and vacuous reports any longer.

    jesslflynn From jesslflynn on Mon Jun 01 01:04PM

    Report abuse

  4. No one forces people to appear on BB or BGT or others to watch it.
    Gordon Brown wanted the job.
    remember the adage "be careful what you wish for... it may come true"
    I have no sympathy at all.

    davidnance From davidnance on Mon Jun 01 01:04PM

    Report abuse

  5. i feel for susan boyle how many people of her age get to be a star i do hope her future in music continues she was brill get well soon susan show them all hey

    maureen.hick From maureen.hick on Mon Jun 01 01:04PM

    Report abuse

  6. well i agree with every word susan boyle didnt say about the u.k most uplifting or did i miss it?

    vclarknicholson From vclarknicholson on Mon Jun 01 01:05PM

    Report abuse

  7. Susan Boyle seemen a bit 'odd' from the get go... it takes alsorts i guess.. im sure that her brothers & sister (that i hadnt heard of until sunday) will 'look' after her... seems a crazy world when if you can kick a ball..get your baps out of be thick as two short planks (but makes good viewing)you will be worth a few million. Jade Goody.. Jordan etc are dreadful to watch.. i dont understand it.. doesnt seem to bring them happiness though !!

    elainetorrington579 From elainetorrington579 on Mon Jun 01 01:05PM

    Report abuse

  8. Excellent article - what idiot added the ambiguous headline???

    tonylyd From tonylyd on Mon Jun 01 01:05PM

    Report abuse

  9. this is not a recent thing, its always been the same. i have loved singing ever since i was 5. have always had a good response from audiences at jam nights ect. but ive always known i would never want to do it professionally. celebrities are built up then knocked down all the time and this is seen as part of the industry, if ever a celeb moans about it they are told that they knew the pitfalls and should be grateful for thier celebrity status. child stars seem to be the ones who suffer most and if susan boyle bless her heart has slight brain damage then she is in essence a child. my heart goes out to her and i hope a short break helps her to recover. she has an effortlessly beautiful voice. the playground name calling of the press needs to stop. for gods sake, the papparazi killed princess dianna. surely these people should be bought into line.

    clairebear12399 From clairebear12399 on Mon Jun 01 01:07PM

    Report abuse

  10. Return to the days when you COULD find enough males to make up a five a side football team from any TV production office !!!!

    parsec1 From parsec1 on Mon Jun 01 01:08PM

    Report abuse

Comment on this article

Please sign in to add your comments.


Add to my Yahoo/RSS

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! All rights reserved.

Notice: We collect personal information on this site. To learn more about how we use your information, see our: Updated Privacy Policy