Yahoo!. Now with Friends.

Discover news, videos and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Talking Politics

    Taxing meat could make us thinner

    By Yvonne Bishop-Weston

    It's no secret that the UK's girth is expanding day by day. In fact, British health officials recently announced that we need to cut five billion calories from our collective daily diet in order to slow the current obesity crisis. Left unchecked, obesity-related health problems could cost the NHS £10 billion a year by 2050.

    The government has made some attempts to slim down our country by asking the food and beverage industries to reduce the amount of salt and fat in their products, requiring calorie contents to be posted where possible and encouraging people to exercise. But these efforts are like trying to bail out a sinking ship with a spoon.

    They need to find a way to get the message across that we need to change our diets. One suggestion for combating our growing obesity crisis would be to tax meat products and promote a healthy plant-based diet. We would do well to learn from the Danes, who recently implemented a tax on food products that are high in fat, including meat and other animal products, as a means of tackling their growing rate of obesity. Also the Belgians, who've cut portions of meat served in nurseries and school canteens by up to 50 per cent in order to prevent future generations from following in their parents' overweight footsteps.

    Our country's meat-heavy diet is a major contributor to obesity, as well as many of the UK's top killers, including heart attacks, strokes, diabetes and some cancers. Overwhelming scientific evidence shows that vegetarians and vegans are less likely to be overweight than meat-eaters are and are more likely to be in better overall health. The American Dietetic Association — the largest group of professional nutritionists in the US — reviewed hundreds of studies and concluded that compared to people who consume meat, vegetarians have lower rates of obesity, heart disease, diabetes and cancer.

    Eating contaminated meat also sickens and kills many thousands of people each year. Campylobacter bacteria is the most common cause of food poisoning in the UK and, in 2008, was responsible for an estimated 321,000 cases in England and Wales alone, resulting in more than 15,000 hospitalisations, 76 deaths and an estimated cost to the economy of more than £583 million. Encouraging the consumption of vegetables and fruits over foods that come from animals would reduce this risk and this burgeoning public health problem.

    Along with deterring people from buying unhealthy foods, the government also needs to make it as easy as possible for its citizens to eat healthfully. For example, although preparing plant-based meals is just as simple as cooking meat- and cheese-laden ones, many people may not have had experience with this. We need to teach plant-based cooking and show people how easy it is to include protein from healthy and inexpensive sources such as beans and pulses. More governmental power could also be used to ensure supermarkets offer more healthy foods and display them in prime positions. It would also help if food magazines became more proactive at featuring healthy and delicious recipes and kept the ones high in saturated fats and sugar clearly labelled as treats, not as everyday foods.

    The dire prediction being made by health professionals and government officials that this generation of children could die before their parents because of preventable, obesity-related health problems does not need to come true. More, however, does need to be done to promote healthy eating in schools. A good strategy would be to adopt meat-free Mondays in all schools and provide parents and children with up-to-date nutrition information and simple meat-free recipes to make at home.

    Our country's rate of obesity represents a full-blown crisis, and the time for decisive action is now. Taxing animal-derived foods and promoting plant-based eating would give us another possible chance at slimming down and enjoying good health. And with all the unwanted weight that Britons would lose, animals would gain: every person who goes vegetarian saves more than 100 animals a year from the cruelty of factory farming and slaughter. They might just save their own lives too.

    Yvonne Bishop-Weston is a leading UK clinical nutritionist and co-author of a number of healthy eating books

     

    388 comments

    • bob  •  2 months ago
      Tax is not the answer to obesity, what a retarded opinion. The only thing tax does is give MPs more money to steal.
    • BBW101  •  2 months ago
      It's not meat that makes people fat, it's the fact that the cheapest foods available are ready-made rubbish full of additives and hidden salt & fat. 3 for 2 offers on pies, biscuits, pizzas, crisps etc are the norm, McDonalds/Burger King - so much cheaper than a chicken salad... but make your food from scratch and you'll be fine. And steer well clear of ready meals claiming to be "diet"... they'll be full or salt and sugar and chemicals. The obesity "epidemic" started after the introduction of slimming aids. It's nonsense, just be sensible.
    • mutaali t  •  2 months ago
      Tax pasta, pizza and ready made chips: get thin (king!)
    • Feyd  •  2 months ago
      LOL! More sophisticated scientists have found that folk on low income are more likely to be overweight. Another regressive tax wont help. There's loads of excellent ideas for goverments to raise revenue from the rich, in the brilliant new book 'The Courageous State' by tax expert Richard Murphy.
    • Cliff  •  2 months ago
      Wouldn't it be better to tax Chips, Pizzas, Crisps,Doner kebabs,pies, pasties and 2litre
      bottles of Cola which have become the staple diet of the average Dumbo in this country?
    • Simon  •  2 months ago
      Complete and utter drivel!!!!!! has this woman ever been into a supermarket? The problem isn't meat it's the endless aisles of frozen pizzas, crisps, cakes, biscuits and sweets that people guzzle - meat can be perfectly lean and healthy, cakes sure as hell can't. I smell a not-very-well-hidden PETA agenda embedded in the above.
    • Jake24  •  2 months ago
      If meat is consumed properly it doesn't have any worse affect on peoples weight at all. It's the re-constituted rubbish that is put into ready meals and fast food outlets. And the manufacturers put 'e' numbers and allsorts of rubbish to bulk them out for maximum profit. Then there's the salt content, and the sugar. We need more legislation to prevent companies exposing people to rubbish. They are more to blame than the idiots addicted to junk food.
    • MICHELLE  •  2 months ago
      Such utter rubbish, if you eat in moderation and exercise there is no reason to be overweight. We have meat of some description on a daily basis, and we are all healthy happy people, my kids have a varied diet and plenty of exercise (which costs nothing). People need to educated at school age as to how to cook, as nobody seems to anymore. Take the ready meals, pizzas and cakes off the shelves or tax them instead as that is the problem, not the amount of meat we eat. By taxing meat small time producers like ourselfs will go out of business as the prices would have to rise too much, we are already struggling with the ever increasing costs of animal feed, and fuel rises, don't make things even more difficult for people!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    • Uebermensch  •  2 months ago
      just means that poorer people will eat more junkfood.Subsidise our vegetable farmers so we can get cheaper veg .
    • Sammy Wrae  •  2 months ago
      I have to admit, this is a remarkably one-sided rant by someone who CLEARLY has an agenda. No attempt at balance, and a whole bunch of emotive comments ("cruelty of factory farming and slaughter" for example) to make you ignore the apparent lack of facts in the rest of it.

      I know this is the opinion page, but tomorrow I want to see someone pointing out that eating meat can actually be healthy for you, and that for some people meat is an important part of their diet.
    • Simon  •  2 months ago
      wheres all the wonderfully healthy fish thats caught off our shores then? £5 a piece in the supermarkets, WTF??? How come King prawns that are caught here end up as cheap as #$%$ in Spain, but here cost a arm and several legs??
    • John O'Sand Bay  •  2 months ago
      Some of the fattest people I've seen & know don't eat that much meat. - The men drink several pints of beer per day and don't exercise, so they mostly look 18 months pregnant !
      -Their meat? - Mainly burgers and sausages a few times per week, with loads of chips.
      THAT's the way to become Mr.Blobby in double-quick time!
      As for the women - a lot of the young women have already been in training to become MRS. Blobbies by binge drinking from their teens onwards. -By their mid-20s you can feel the pavement shake as they rumble down Newton Road in Rushden towards the pubs ! (And elsewhere, of course). - The only exercise they get is when they all stagger out at closing time and fight eachother.
    • Edison  •  2 months ago
      If i eat a plate of lamb, then the following day a plate of beef and the following day a plate of pork, which day would make me fatter if I did not exercise? Answer all the same. its not about how much everyone consumes, its about balance of diet and exercise. Eating loads of potatoe or bread will have the same effect if you dont exercise.
      Ping, lightbulb moment, perhaps this all come from the seed sewn two weeks ago, when Geogie porgy was accused of eating too many pies as his waiste line had expanded. Hence he asked for this lady's advice. Grace and favour perhaps. This government, never.
    • Magic Lemur  •  2 months ago
      Not another tax!

      When 160 of our 320 taxes don't make any money and the government has £42bn in uncollected revenue, a new tax is the last thing we need.

      And with regard to punishing and rewarding meat/veg eaters, didn't Jesus say something about seeing the speck in your brother's eye while ignoring the log in your own? Develop a vegetarian alternative to bacon first and then people might listen...
    • Garry  •  2 months ago
      Yvonne Bishop-Weston is a militant vegetarian, also a leading UK clinical nutritionist and co-author of a number of healthy eating books about vegetables.

      Fixed taht foy you? have i yahoo?
    • Jac  •  2 months ago
      I'm not fat and happen to like eating a wide variety of food INCLUDING MEAT. This woman maybe a clinical nutritionist but she is also an author, which means she is looking for ways to make us notice her and maybe buy her books. This won't happen. People who eat meat won't be converted to vegetarianism simply because she thinks it's right. I think perhaps she has a rather large ego if she thinks her opinion will make a difference.
    • Richard  •  2 months ago
      Quack alert: While her advice is not necessarily bad it should be noted that the writer is a nutritionist and not a dietitian. The difference is significant as "nutritionist" is not a protected title, which means anyone can claim to be one unlike dietitian which is protected and only certified professionals can use it. As Dara O'Briain put it, the difference between a dietitian and a nutritionist is like the difference between a dentist and a toothyologist.

      Particularly notable is that she claims to have been trained by ION, a group founded by well known fruit-loop Patrick Holford, who amongst other crazy claims has argued that vitamin C is a better treatment for HIV than conventional drugs and promoted the idea that the MMR vacine causes autism, as well has being in hot water with Advertising Standards on more than on occasion lack of truthfulness and substantiation.
    • InoJo  •  2 months ago
      Oh good grief!! You would be better off taxing several large and well-known fast food chains as it is a strange coincidence that the rise of obesity has exactly followed the rise of fast food chains....What a truly ridiculous article, human being were designed as meat eating animals, all we need to do is follow a balanced diet INCLUDING meat! Not stuff our face with processed #$%$ with little or no nutritional value then wonder why we are all getting fatter!!
    • Edison  •  2 months ago
      Oh dear, we are now going to have to pay tax on water.
    • A-M  •  2 months ago
      I'm pretty sure skinless chicken, lean beef and most kinds of fish (which may not be classed as meat, but are certainly not vegetarian) are all very good for your health. What an ill-thought through idea. How can someone who calls themselves a nutrutionist advocate the taxation of such beneficial foods?