Going the Wrong Way on Electric Car Highway

COMMENTARY | We can hardly meet our energy needs wearing beanies with wind-driven propellers while continuing to rely on unstable Middle Eastern countries.

The life preserver for the economy and for individual Americans could be the revamped bipartisan 2011 Nat Gas Bill, according to the website of a popular trucking news magazine.

Yet, politics reigns supreme.

Conservatives rail against Rep. Nancy Pelosi benefitting from natural gas incentives due to her natural gas investments. Anti-capitalist activists fret about billionaire T. Boone Pickens benefitting from the Nat Gas Bill.

Pickens has spent more than $80 million promoting natural gas, writes Joe Nocera of the New York Times.

Meanwhile, the Department of Energy touts the gains that can be achieved if cars, trucks, and buses ran on natural gas. The EPA called the 2010 Honda Civic GX the "cleanest internal combustion vehicle on Earth."

The traffic jams in New York would be far less toxic if the cars and trucks in line to cross the George Washington Bridge, the Lincoln and Holland tunnels or the outer-bridge crossing were running on natural gas.

Among the options for small CNG powered vehicles are home refilling stations or a limited number of public CNG stations. The high cost of building CNG stations, as reported in the Kansas City Star, is a significant reason for remaining stuck in the rut of electric car subsidies.

Ethanol subsidies have further encouraged dependency on gasoline, and discouraged ventures into natural gas vehicles.

The most annoying thing about current energy policy is the expensive headlong rush toward electric or electric-hybrid vehicles.

But electric car slash hybrid makers like Fisker, Tesla or General Motors with its Chevy Volt could end up permanently relegated to the niche markets.

The $96,000 Fisker Karma hybrid, with its $529 million dollar federal loan, is stalled in the slow lane and so is its battery supplier, according to Yahoo! Autos.

The $109,000 Tesla Roadster is a celebrity niche ride. Tesla's hopes are in the $60,000 Model S. For an extra $20,000, you can get a 300-mile range version, according to a Motor Trend article.

The Chevy Volt suffers from the same range limitations as other electric vehicles, with the added spark of the much publicized battery conflagration.

The Nissan Leaf is borderline affordable and, in spite of limited range, is probably the best on the electric vehicle car lot.

Anthony Ventre is a freelance writer who has written for weekly and daily newspapers and several online publications. He is a frequent Yahoo contributor, concentrating in news and financial writing.

 

24 comments

  • Kascha_Kwan  •  Atlantic City, United States  •  2 months ago
    When you get stuck on the highway with an all electric car , will the AAA still come and give you a boost ?
  • GaryB  •  2 months ago
    Back in the 1910s and '20s electric cars died before steamers did. Enough said.
  • James  •  Raton, United States  •  2 months ago
    Natural gas tech can work right now. Battery technology is not green. We need to demand alternatives to oil the middle class ( what's left of it) can afford.
  • jeffrey  •  Edenton, United States  •  2 months ago
    Go for it!! Also what happened to hydrogen fuel?Just learned we are paying for green fuel for the Navy at 15.00 dollars a barrel,when we can get it a lot cheaper.But the Govt likes expensive things.Be ready to sell your children for what its going to cost in the future.
  • Swede  •  2 months ago
    EV's are the furute but for now it would be so easy to convert any gas powered vehicle. They have been doing it for years, I had a friend in the eighties who got great milage with his two CNG powered cars and they were converted from stock showroom cars.
  • Easily Offended  •  2 months ago
    Environmentals rarely have the answer (they shot down the hybrid cars when first invented - cuz even though they forced automakes to install catalytic converters on cars, they were not forward thinking enough to envision relativeley clean internal combustion engines (they are with multiple catalytic converters).
    .
    Electricity genrated where it is used is worth much more since so much electricity is lost in transmission lines.
    .
    That said, i would rather buy the billionth hybrid off the asemly line than the first or even the millionth vehicle off the assembly line.
    .
    There is no massive conspiracy in transportation outside of the considerable technological and infrastructure hurdles (Just like it wasnt a conspiracy that prevented 14th century monks from operating airplanes).
  • James B  •  Riyadh, Saudi Arabia  •  2 months ago
    What everyone seems to forget about electric vehicles is that elecricity is generated using coal or natural gas as a rule. People act as if elecricity is just "out there" for the taking. It will be decades before solar or wind compete large scale with coal or gas generated elecricity.
  • Fritz_Schnabel  •  2 months ago
    EV's will work when they can store the electrical energy cheaply. All the battery manufacturing corporations (those whose business model is to exclusively produce batteries) are going broke - both domestically, and even in China.

    We need a killer Ultra/Super-cap that can be manufactured for 1/100 of the cost of lithium-ion packs before this "EV Revolution" becomes real.
  • ChristineS  •  2 months ago
    Battery technology requires use of rare earth elements, which China has 95% of the market. Rare earth elements produce acid water as a by-product. Going green will poison the earth faster than oil.
  • DVCAZ  •  Tucson, United States  •  2 months ago
    G.M. had no reason to try and fix what was not broken. The EV-1 never exploded. So why didn't they just bring it back in an improved form? Having an electric Edsel on their hands now does no one any good. Talk about watching the "bailout money" go up in flames! If the cost of building CNG stations is so high this is when the government, on a day that it might actually function, can provide the assistance needed to add them to our infrastructure improvements. Just say NO to exploding cars that cost too much and will take too long to fix. Times a wastin', lets get the natural gas train moving so that we can be on the track that will really lead us away from oil.
  • Karl A.  •  Santa Clara, United States  •  2 months ago
    I like my VW and Audi designed and built direct injection diesel powered cars that, along with their other European market counterparts, if adopted at the same rate by Americans, as Europeans have been doing for the last ten to fifteen years would lower our oil imports, by at least 1.5 million barrels of oil per day, and reduce our CO2 footprint too.

    These
  • Wake up America  •  Texarkana, United States  •  2 months ago
    And 85% of us electricity is made using natural gas...
  • Enjoy the GAME  •  Seoul, South Korea  •  2 months ago
    find and watch "Who Killed the Electric Car," and you will know more about the truth.
  • edwin  •  Hermiston, United States  •  2 months ago
    you all have seen the windmills going up everywhere well guess what they consume more electrcity than they generate. each windmill uses electricity to run the commputers which control the blade pitch ,and heaters and pumps for oil which lubricate the gears and runs the hydraulics only when the wind blows strong and steady do they break even or come out ahead
  • edward  •  Reno, United States  •  2 months ago
    Anthony Ventre does not know what he is talking about when he says that "the Chevy Volt suffers from the same range limitations as other electric vehicles". The vehicle switches to a gasoline engine when it reaches the range limitations of it's batteries.
  • robc  •  Everett, United States  •  2 months ago
    lest you not forget the issues with natural gas. Fracking.
    Explore both technologies and develop them to work together.
    Safely and clean.
    Natural gas technology is far less green than battery technology.
  • Avran  •  Palm Springs, United States  •  2 months ago
    Expensive yes, but not as expensive as the models they make each year for the super-rich, technology is advanced enough to create a new kind of vehicle that run's on a multifunctional. A Chinese genius ( yes I know ) showed me a blueprint of a vehicle that re-create's up to half the energy it originally powered up with. Like an electric, solar, n. gas combo.lightweight MTR.
  • John Q Galt  •  Jacksonville, United States  •  2 months ago
    All of these free electrons that surround us each day can power the majority of our lives but we won't use them? The sun puts out more power than we could ever use but something is in the way of collecting that free power... What? The Law of Supply and Demand don't seem to work here; You want cheap power for your homes and transportation yet Solar Cell companies are going bankrupt; how do you explain this? It is pass time to solve this problem and America has the ability to do it. Where are the tinkerers?
  • D.R.  •  2 months ago
    Maglev trains, NOT cars are the answer.
  • Buck Naked  •  Atlanta, United States  •  2 months ago
    We got people movers! Why not car movers at bridges and other areas where traffic crawls?