Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Student Protests: Wheelchair Attack 'Lawful'

    Police officers were justified in pulling a student fees protester from his wheelchair and "inadvertently" hitting him with a baton, an inquiry has found.

    :: Jody McIntyre, speaking in December 2010, gives his account of eventsĀ 

    Jody McIntyre, 21, was attacked by officers during a demonstration on December 9, but the actions police were "justifiable and lawful given the volatile and dangerous situation", Scotland Yard's Directorate of Professional Standards said.

    Mr McIntyre claimed he was the victim of an unprovoked attack, complaining that an officer tipped him out of his wheelchair onto the ground, then dragged him across the road onto the pavement.

    He said the treatment amounted to discrimination on the basis of his disability.

    But a statement from the force said: "The investigation, supervised by the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC), did not find evidence to substantiate any of the complaints made by Jody McIntyre regarding two separate incidents at the demonstrations.

    "Whilst there is evidence that Jody McIntyre was inadvertently struck with a police baton, the investigation found that the actions of officers were justifiable and lawful given the volatile and dangerous situation occurring at the location and his removal from his wheelchair was also justifiable given the officers' perceived risk to Jody McIntyre."

    Following the incident, investigators took advice from the force's independent disability advisory group, which recommended that guidance be developed around the most appropriate way to move a wheelchair user should it become necessary.

    Acting Commander Carl Bussey, head of the Directorate of Professional Standards, said:

    "The allegations made by Jody McIntyre were extremely concerning and we have carried out a very thorough investigation under the supervision of the IPCC to establish the facts.

    "The investigation did not find evidence to substantiate any of the complaints and, given how damaging these allegations were to the reputation of the MPS and relationship with both protesters and London's disabled community, it is only right that we report back and therefore publicly account on what occurred."

     

    98 comments

    • Jennifer  •  1 year 0 months ago
      The risk they perceived from him... well whenever I see a police officer I perceive they constitute a risk to my rights and my health. Can I 'inadvertantly' club them?
      • Ivan 1 year 0 months ago
        "...perceived risk to him...". Read the article before making comments Jenny.
      • Mike Hansen 1 year 0 months ago
        Ivan..... "....perceived risk to him...." yeah so lets dump him out of his wheelchair, grag him across the road and hit him with a baton so that he's safe!!!! I don't think so!!!!
      • Ivan 1 year 0 months ago
        "...perceived risk to him...". Read the article before making comments Jenny.
    • Lynne B  •  1 year 0 months ago
      With all due respect, I don't think this finding is necessarily going to reassure the public about the police.
      • Paul Bruce 1 year 0 months ago
        It's not the Police action that concerns me, but the Protesters'
      • A Yahoo! User 1 year 0 months ago
        Bleeding students .... they wanted a protest - and that i what happens.

        They would not have enjoyed the experience other wise.

        Compare this to Middle East then complain.
      • G.Orwell 1 year 0 months ago
        The police have shown far more than just this act as to what they as a force are prepared to treat the people of this country like....and far worse. The types of actions by police and associated agencies are slowly being normalised.

        The video covered on the TV news said it all. That was @#$% well hitting the guy deliberately !

        This inquiry only show that the inquiry board is corrupt as well.

        The real insult is to tacitly label this country as being full of idiots that can not tell the difference between deliberate force and "inadvertantly" being hit.
    • Vengeful Strumpet  •  1 year 0 months ago
      If someone had pulled a police officer over or 'inadvertently' hit them, it would be a different story.
      • Elisa 1 year 0 months ago
        too right!
      • bluebell 1 year 0 months ago
        True, but wheelchair users are not above the law jsut because they have a disability. They are wuick to scream discrimination when theya re treated differently, then when theyg et treated the same they dont like it. I think this is a case of a disabled students using his disab ility as an excuse for his behaviour,. Mind you, I don't think the polcie shoudl be dragging any student across the ground and hitting them with batons unless there is a real risk they ar ein danger.And before the red fingers appear I work with disabled young people and I fully support the student demostrations.
      • Elisa 1 year 0 months ago
        You have a lot to say considering you werent even there
    • peter  •  1 year 0 months ago
      "inadvertently" hitting him with a baton !!!!!!
    • PETER  •  1 year 0 months ago
      Obviously this is a case of discrimination! An able bodied person would have received a good kicking whilst on the ground as well!
    • john c  •  1 year 0 months ago
      Never read so much bullshit from the Police in my life. How the hell do you get whacked on the head with a baton by accident.And couldn't they have just wheeled him out of the way,it would have been much quicker.
      The IPCC is a sham.
    • Mike  •  1 year 0 months ago
      OK it is now lawful for a police person to chuck a disabled person out of a wheel chair and inadvertently club them.

      Isn't that what Gaddafi has been telling us for weeks?
      • dale paul 1 year 0 months ago
        mike.i saw film footage of the day and i saw this so called disabled person walking about and throwing things at the police
      • bluebell 1 year 0 months ago
        oh dale and how do you know it was the same one, of course being disabled and a wheelchair user he was easy to spot, funny in normal circumsances most disabled people become invisible.
      • Mike 1 year 0 months ago
        DP.

        Then make a statement to the police so they can investigate.
        Or pop round to his place, throw him out of his wheel chair and take it away and see if he gets up.

        Even if what you are accurately interpreting what you saw, does that give the police the right to assault him, the same way they assaulted tomlinson
    • Charlie  •  1 year 0 months ago
      I am a fulltime carer to a wheelchair user and a volunteer helper with a local disabled group.
      I am appalled that a fully grown adult male of above average fitness could not have found a less violent solution without having had an inexcusable loss of self control and compassion.
      Most of the people I see in wheelchairs would not fare well from being dragged by an arm, let alone clubbed. They tend to have poor joint mobility, skin like tissue paper, bruise easily and lastingly and also have weak bones. They may even have unstable spinal fractures, colostomy bags............ .
      And YES. Disabled people have alot more right to be angry than the rest of us;
      we "don't know the half of it" !
      SHAME ON YOU police officer.
      • Invictus 1 year 0 months ago
        I blame the government and media also. It's a crime to be ill or disabled now. There have been both verbal and physical attacks on disabled people nationwide since the government and media started their hate campaigns against them.

        This is only the start of things. Aside from the attacks many will be left with no support,lack of finance and homeless over the next few years.
      • Invictus 1 year 0 months ago
        I blame the government and media also. It's a crime to be ill or disabled now. There have been both verbal and physical attacks on disabled people nationwide since the government and media started their hate campaigns against them.

        This is only the start of things. Aside from the attacks many will be left with no support,lack of finance and homeless over the next few years.
    • Viva Espana  •  1 year 0 months ago
      There is going to be one facing manslaughter charges soon. Those resposible for this should also be charged. To drag someone out of their wheelchair & strike them with a baton is the behaviour of a despicable coward.
    • mark d  •  1 year 0 months ago
      "Whilst there is evidence that Jody McIntyre was inadvertently struck with a police baton". The police officer needs prosecuting for "careless batoning".

      You can see the jusges words now can't you. "and where were you constable while this carless batoning was occurring?".I was on the other end of the baton m'lord!

      What is becoming plainly obvious from this type of issue, the police are no longer really decent people and should be steered well clear of. In the future, for ever step society evolves it changes that the police will end up being the objects of peoples anger.
    • Fay  •  1 year 0 months ago
      How do you "inadvertently" hit someone with a baton? As for the comment made by "C" - where are you coming from?!
    • more  •  1 year 0 months ago
      life is just sh!!!!!!!! do not think you can go out side without thinkig who or whot is out ther I do not think you are safe at all
    • ROLAND  •  1 year 0 months ago
      what a sick police force and laws we have when a disable person is dragged from his wheel chair,by a fit and strong policeman,may be he picked on this man because he was a coward and did not want to take on a normal fit man,i have faced situations like this on security jobs,but i would resign before i was ordered to drag a disable man out of his wheel chair, be very carefull. and i have just been talking to some friends in australia[australians] on phone and they said if it was in australia ,the policeman would be sacked, of cause in uk, the police carry out complaints against they own police unlike others countrys.i rest my case.
    • E  •  1 year 0 months ago
      Directorate of Professional Standards - Don't make me laugh. If these officers can't handle a volatile situation they are clearly not professional and should be dismissed. These officers are criminal thugs and if the IPCC can't ensure they a charged it just shows how corrupt the IPCC and the police are really are.
    • Bill Ovtangerine  •  1 year 0 months ago
      the disabled damed if they ask for help damed if they dont
    • SL  •  1 year 0 months ago
      If you strike a police officer just make certain you do it """"inadvertenly""" then walk off..they will understand...
    • David.H  •  1 year 0 months ago
      Yet again the Police get away with criminal actions. There's one law for them and another for the rest of us! The state takes care of it's guardians! The Biringham six,Maguire seven, Guildford four, Stephan Kiskow,John Magranigan,Carl Bridgewater,Jean Charles Menendez,BarryGeorge,Judith Ward,Stephen Downing,Paul Blackburn,the Bridgewater four etc etc I could literally go on and on about how the Police ARE NEVER BROUGHT TO ACCOUNT FOR THEIR CORRUPTION ,PERJURY AND BRUTALITY! But what's the point as the general public IN THIS COUNTRY COULDN'T GIVE A TOSS THAT'S UNTIL IT happens to you!!!
    • C  •  1 year 0 months ago
      Perhaps the Libyan armed forces could intervene to protect the civilian population from injury and death at the hands of the state security police including attacks on the disabled, the killing of a street vendor and an attack by a 16 stone police officer on a 7 stone woman. Perhaps we should also mention the shooting dead of a man who was lawfully travelling on the underground or the innocent man shot dead in his car because he looked liked somebody else.
    • GEOF  •  1 year 0 months ago
      Hang on a minute. Why do "the disabled" ALWAYS expect "special" treatment when THEY expect NORMAL service ? Having been to the Dental Clinic, I joined a large throng awaiting a Tram at the University to City stop. As the Tram arrived at the platform, some "motorised disabled middle-aged female" suddenly drove-up the ramp's sloping end bellowing "EXCUSE ME!! EXCUSE ME!!" at the people waiting for the automatic doors to open. Someone said "There is a queue!" "Ger art on me way!" the female screamed, brandishing an "extendable walking stick" Disabled ??
    • Phil Darby  •  1 year 0 months ago
      So a guy in a wheel chair posed enough of a threat to justify, being hit with a baton, tipped out of his chair then dragged across the road onto the pavement, during a volatile and dangerous situation.

      This to me doesnt really have anything to do with discrimination, its more to do with bullying someone, unable to defend themselves and at the very least use of excessive force.

      Im "inadvertently" getting fed up of the bullies in blue and the corrupt system that defends them.

      Is it just me or are we slowly turning into a clone of the third reich ?