Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Tax Chiefs Attacked Over 'Deals' For Big Firms

    Tax bosses have been lambasted by MPs (BSE: MPSLTD.BO - news) for bending rules to do favours for big firms at a cost of millions to the taxpayer - then hiding the details.

    The public accounts committee warned millions more were at risk unless procedures were tightened and said senior officials should face punishment for a series of costly failures.

    Its (Euronext: ALITS.NX - news) report called for safeguards to be put in place to avoid the impression that HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) enjoyed an "unduly cosy" relationship with major companies.

    And the MPs demanded explanations as to why officials wrongly claimed they could not discuss deals with the committee and gave "imprecise, inconsistent and potentially misleading" answers.

    Richard Murphy, founder of Tax Justice Network, told Sky News: "I think the MPs are right; there is very clear evidence that there has been a bias in the way that the tax system has been operated.

    "Large companies have had a very cosy deal with the HMRC, but small businesses and individuals have had a bad deal in comparison to those.

    "The Parliamentary committee has done a great job in exposing these."

    The report represents the conclusions of a stormy public inquiry by the influential committee, which saw the country's top tax official Dave Hartnett accused by the chairwoman of lying.

    A former judge has now been appointed to investigate by the National Audit Office.

    Mr Hartnett, who it was recently announced will retire as HMRC Permanent Secretary for Tax in the summer, has admitted an error led him to approve one tax avoidance dispute.

    Banking giant Goldman Sachs (NYSE: GS - news) was let off paying a multi-million pound interest bill on unpaid tax on bonuses after Mr Hartnett was wrongly advised there was a "legal impediment" to collecting it.

    The potential cost to the taxpayer is officially put at £8m - but a whistleblower told the committee the sum could be as high as £20m.

    MPs expressed astonishment in the report that HMRC allowed the same senior officials to both negotiate and approve such deals.

    The report also said the Goldman deal was done "without legal advice" or an official note being taken of the meeting, with officials relying on the firm's records.

    It also revealed that Mr Hartnett alone had enjoyed 107 dinners and lunches with companies, tax lawyers and advisers over two years, which MPs said raised concerns that relations could seem "unduly cosy".

    HMRC, the report claimed, "consistently failed to give straight answers to our questions which has severely hampered our ability to hold it to account for the settlements reached".

    Mr Murphy from Tax Justice Network said: "Large Companies have had a very cosy relationship with Dave Hartnett.

    "He has been very good at socialising with them, in way that has not necessarily been minuted."

    HMRC rejected the committee's conclusion that there were systemic failures in its management of tax disputes.

    "The report is based on partial information, inaccurate opinion and some misunderstanding of facts," a spokesman said.

    The spokesman denied the error made in the Goldman Sachs case was evidence of a wider, systemic failure and rejected the claim that the loss to the taxpayer could be as high as £20m.

    "This assertion, based on untested, leaked information, is without foundation," the spokesman said.

     
     
    Top Locations London

    128 comments

    • jeannette  •  5 months ago
      Not surprised at this at all, a bit like letting the bankers get away with it all.
      nothing changes it still seems to be "not what you know, but who you know".
      • sus 5 months ago
        The bankers did get away with it...thanks to Cameron in Brussels.
      • R 5 months ago
        Wonder how much went into there back pockets SACK THEM and make them pay it back its our money
      • zombiesi 5 months ago
        Sus. The bankers have Immunity. No matter what they do no charges can come to them. Wake up! we are rule by corruption.
    • Alan  •  5 months ago
      When are people going to catch on? corruption is rife in this country
      • zombiesi 5 months ago
        Never most people are to DUMB to see the LIES. And CORRUPTION. Ask your self this. why is it that we need MONEY again. 80% of crime is about money. People die of HUNGER because of money. People pay DEBTS that dont even belong to them. why is it people dont see it intill we turn into the other countrys we see on the news and trust me thats the only way the rich are gonna get richer.
      • jack d 5 months ago
        best thing about it the people think there going to get something out of it clowns
      • Trax 5 months ago
        The docile British public are too ignorant to even follow what you are saying...
    • DAVID R  •  5 months ago
      Private Eye got this info into the public domain months and months ago - now what about HMRCs and Hartnetts deal with Vodafone..............Private Eye have been highlighting this for ages too!
      • Trax 5 months ago
        What has the stupid public done about it? It's costing us billions every year. Come to think of it - if we collect this money, we won't have a national debt!
    • sensible sam  •  5 months ago
      Will the man face any disciplinary actions or just given the usual golden handshake. Spineless politicians who are also in bed with these people.
      • Lynne 5 months ago
        He is indeed being given an early golden handshake. How long before he becomes an advisor to Goldman Sachs ? How many dinners does it take for someone to be guilty of corruption ?
      • Trax 5 months ago
        Lynne: It's been happening for very many years. Corruption is rife in this country. Politicians are not spineless, they are corrupt.
    • TonyH  •  5 months ago
      This has been going on for ages with the governments knoledge while at the same time pensioners have been harassed and bullied for measely ammounts of unpaid tax that the majority did not know about and did not owe in the first place.
      • Trax 5 months ago
        The MPs have known about it for years too....
    • Donatas  •  5 months ago
      Just one word:
      CORRUPTION
    • Merlynson  •  5 months ago
      I think we are closer to unravelling the corruption in this country. With 98 out of the 100 British FTSE companies not paying tax, vast rebates on millionaires' pensions, various other tax rebates and allowable tax cuts for the rich, while at the same time the poor are accused of laziness and cheating, what we have to do is becoming clear:-

      Dethrone the mighty and raise the poor.
    • Russell Ballantyne  •  5 months ago
      I Don't Belieive it!... Victor Meldrew ...Bless you!... I retired at the age of 69. now really a hard struggle to exist on a state pension. I have a small Private pension, from a previous employment. That is taxed!.. because my Wife, bless her, works a few hours a week to make ends meet. Big Firms... Get Tax Perks... My Arse! Do I sound pissed Off? Yes I am...
    • davelo  •  5 months ago
      AND SO..! there we have it a classic case of the rich looking after the rich, funded by financially running the lower earning end of our society into the ground by bleeding us dry at every oppertunity....NICE WORK IF YOU CAN GET IT...! and you have NO scruples what so ever...!
    • Comfortably numbty  •  5 months ago
      This makes Kim Jong Il's 13 holes in one sound plausible. At least it is scientifically possible which is more than you can say about the truth spoken by M Ps and top civil servants
    • Dylan Lapin  •  5 months ago
      I always knew we were living in a corrupt third world country, without the political will to stop the elite and rich from robbing the rest of us. The politicians should take heed, riots last summer (not for political change though) ,the general apathy over elections, was it 25% voted at the last by election. The British people are fast becoming ripe for there own revolution,unless those who should pay large tax bills companies included, pay and the Elite and Rich also are truely made to pay there full share to help us out of this mess. BUT I DON'T THINK ANY GOVERNMENT HAS THE BALLS TO DO IT. DO YOU?
    • billy  •  5 months ago
      This actually surprises people?
    • Robert H  •  5 months ago
      Do a deal today get a consultancy job tomorrow. Public servants - joke.
    • StollenCakeHead  •  5 months ago
      how corrupt, authoritarian and arrogant this arm of the govt is. They hammering part timers, pensioners, etc with massive repayments due to mistaken PAYE calculations from years ago but let big companies off ! Oh & they can still spend our taxes on foreign countries like Africa, Pakistan, supporting wars in Libya,, Afghanistan, Iraq, never mind the people here who dont want to work and asylum seekers and economic migrants...
    • RICHARD  •  5 months ago
      Why is it that people in high office think they are above the law? And why is it that this hasnt been reported as fraud to the police? Before you all mention the MP`s expenses, i believe that more of them should have been reported and charged by the police! If any of us fiddled our expenses at work we would be sacked on the spot and criminal procedures could/would follow!
      If someone is accused of working whilst obtaining benefits, it is considered to be "A crime against her majestys` government" and taken very very seriously, as it should be! Why does it feel like this is totally different and not so important?
      As it stands, the gent who is in the middle is probably going to retire on a fat lump sum payment with a nice handshake from the companies that he helped out!
      There is something wholey wrong in this country!
    • Jake24  •  5 months ago
      Brown envelopes have been passed across desks for years. All parties in government were and are the same. It's not so much the party in power, more the corrupt civil servants making deals for their own personal benefit. Let's hope investigations are made and these parasites kicked out of their lucrative positions. Hopefully, the investigators will be able to go back at least 6 years to recover any lost revenue and expose the corrupt officials responsible. This is far worse than the benefit cheats, and probably goes up quite high within the ranks of HMRC. Find them and get rid of them!
    • David J  •  5 months ago
      HMRC are servants of the Crown, if the committee does not get satisfactory answers then it amounts to gross misconduct.

      This Hartnet person seems not to care as he leaves (I presume retires next year)
      If it is true that he has had 107 lunches provided over 2 years that means a lunch meeting every week.
      Officials in his position should NOT be allow to accept ANY handouts.
    • Fiona  •  5 months ago
      Corrupt from the bottom to the top. Smells the same as our local would only sell some of their land to one developer reducing it from £90,000 to £10,000 on the pretext it was only going to be garden for development then passed planning permission for a 4/5 bed house using land as main access. Developers + £80,000 taxpayer - £80,000. LGO found maladministration in initial disposal of the land but has no teeth to rectify the situation. Our MP seems to be able to do nothing about it. Audit committee and standards board being abolished.This government is going to be allowing more of this corruption by removing any pretence of accountability and with their "localism" bill. Then why would they be bothered its beginning to be" business as usual" from the bottom to the top of our system.
    • Girosnooty  •  5 months ago
      It looks like corruption is endemic in the UK now .We had better get it sorted its very bad for business in the long term. We are a trading nation and integrity is vital to some foreign countries . It has destroyed some nations and we are not immune.
    • Pete  •  5 months ago
      It's all coming to the surface. The financial services industry that has been ripping off investors by taking high fees and charges that dilute pensions. The tax collectors that are granting favours to big business and the bankers. The bankers robbing their banks. The bosses robbing their corporations. All part of the secret gang in the City of London so dear to Mr Cameron. And a single mother who forgets a few pounds in her tax return is hounded. If this corruption in high places is not stamped out soon and Government does nothing to bring about a genuine redistribution of wealth to the people there will be a violent reaction