'Shameful': Walmart stole charitable Women's March logo, artist claims

Mandy Velez
Contributing Writer
Photo: ModCloth

The Women’s March in January was chock-full of powerful, original artwork put onto signs and shirts for the world to see. And graphic designer Deva Pardue was among the artists to contribute to the imagery on display. She designed the famous image of three side-by-side fists thrust upward, each representing a woman of a different skin tone.

Her illustration went viral after she shared the photo of it on Instagram at the start of the year. But more recently, it popped up somewhere else entirely — and Pardue, who is a design director at the Wing, was not involved. According to Fast Company, Pardue received messages that women’s retailer ModCloth, owned by Walmart, had been selling clothes with an almost exact replica of the design front and center.

Pardue sent the company a cease-and-desist letter, with which the company complied; the store removed all items with her design on Nov. 6.

But Pardue wasn’t satisfied. She posted about the situation on social media, alleging that the brand not only stole her design — used to raise money for charity — but had yet to respond to her letters.

“They’ve since ignored two cease-and-desist letters from my lawyer,” Pardue wrote. “A shameful example of huge corporations profiting from grassroots movements.” She tweeted at the ModCloth executives shortly after, including CEO Matt Kaness, to tell them that she has not received compensation for use of her work.





Pardue’s design is part of For All Womankind, an initiative she founded to raise money for nonprofit groups working to advance women’s rights and equality. Since launching in December 2016, the organization has raised $12,000 for the Center for Reproductive Rights and Emily’s List.

ModCloth tweeted to Pardue to address the allegations, claiming that the items were removed from the site and that the team was not aware of the design beforehand.


Still, Pardue wrote: “I have emailed you, multiple times, & have sent physical cease & desist letters that cost me money. I have received absolutely no response from you until this very underwhelming tweet.”

Yahoo Lifestyle has reached out to Pardue for comment but has not yet received a response.

ModCloth told Yahoo Lifestyle that the company worked on the design with a third-party vendor.

“We were not aware it was an original design or we would have never gone forward,” said ModCloth spokesperson Aire Plichta Reese. “The miscommunication of not connecting with her was what the issue was. We emailed her as soon as we could asking if it’s OK with her to donate sales of shirts to charity of her choice.”

Reese did not confirm whether or not Pardue accepted. ModCloth is also looking into the third-party vendor. She called the situation a “mistake” and said the brand plans to tighten up the system it has to prevent similar situations.

ModCloth is one of many brands over the years that have faced allegations of design theft from indie creatives, especially for the popular Women’s March designs. Pardue claims that African retailer Jet Fashion is also selling her three-power-fist design without permission. Amanda Brinkman, co-founder of Google Ghost and the designer behind the now-iconic “Nasty Woman” shirt, also had her design lifted and put on other company’s shirts without permission. Retail site Redbubble has tons of knock-off Women’s March designs that appear to have not been approved by their creators, including the official Women’s March logo by Nicole LaRue.

Brinkman told Allure that she used the money from the shirts to raise money for Planned Parenthood — more than $130,000 — but has lost would-be sales to the knockoff versions.

Pardue said she was tired of the rip-offs. “These huge companies are just assuming I can’t afford to sue them,” she said in a tweet. “Which I can’t.”

Read more from Yahoo Lifestyle:

• The Amazon gift guide: 45 stylish gifts for the whole family 
 The best holiday gifts under $100, according to beauty experts
 15 statement shoes to buy now to boost your 2018 shoe game 

Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter for nonstop inspiration delivered fresh to your feed, every day.

  • Samantha Markle accuses Meghan Markle of 'ignoring' her father tells sister to 'step up to the plate' in latest tirade
    News
    Evening Standard

    Samantha Markle accuses Meghan Markle of 'ignoring' her father tells sister to 'step up to the plate' in latest tirade

    Meghan Markle's outspoken half-sister Samantha Grant has called for the Duchess of Sussex to "step up to the plate" following reports she has not spoken with her father for two months. Ms Grant, known as Samantha Markle on Twitter, lashed out at the Duchess online, appearing to accuse her of "ignoring" their father Thomas Markle. It comes as Thomas Markle said he is prepared to travel from Mexico to England to visit Meghan and husband Prince Harry amid fears he is being "frozen out" by the Royal family.

  • Lord Mayor's Hot Air Balloon Regatta: 50 giant hot air balloons to fly over London
    News
    Evening Standard

    Lord Mayor's Hot Air Balloon Regatta: 50 giant hot air balloons to fly over London

    Fantastic, because 50 giant inflatable light bulbs will be soaring over the capital's skyline on Sunday July 22 for 30 minutes of Instagram epicness. Since 2015, the city's top 'grammers, amateur photographers and the odd tourist have descended on the beauteous beast that is Battersea Park to get sights of the 2018 RICOH Lord Mayor's Hot Air Balloon Regatta®, an annual celebration in support of the Lord Mayor's Appeal organised by Exclusive Ballooning. If you've got no clue what we're on about, it's basically a massive charity stunt to create awareness for all the millions of pounds the city and the City of London Corporation raise for charities and good causes in London and beyond.

  • Giant ad agencies realize they have serious problems – and are finally making some bold moves
    News
    Business Insider UK

    Giant ad agencies realize they have serious problems – and are finally making some bold moves

    While the world's biggest advertising agencies continue to face "very real" concerns, these companies are exhibiting "increasingly outward signs of change," according to a new report. Brian Wieser, senior analyst Pivotal Research, says that he is encouraged by a number of recent  ad holding company moves. The advertising industry finally seems to be waking up.

  • Saudi aviation academy to train first women pilots
    News
    Reuters

    Saudi aviation academy to train first women pilots

    A flight school in Saudi Arabia is opening its doors for women, following the end of a decades-long driving ban in the deeply conservative Muslim country where many social restrictions are easing. Oxford Aviation Academy, a leading trainer and crew recruiter, has already received applications from hundreds of women hoping to start lessons in September at a new branch in the eastern city of Dammam. "People used to travel abroad (to study aviation), which was difficult for women more than men," said applicant Dalal Yashar, who aspires to work as a civil pilot.

  • News
    Business Insider UK

    Smoke blankets Yosemite park but trails and lodges are open

    A deadly wildfire near Yosemite National Park has doubled in size and shrouded the popular destination in smoke, but tourists could still use all trails, campgrounds, lodges and restaurants Monday, officials said. Visitors were arriving and amenities were open, but the growing flames shut down a key route into the California park at the peak of tourist season. A stretch of State Route 140 has been closed since the weekend, and motorists have been urged to find alternate routes.

  • Prince Charles admits to being fan of TV’s Poldark
    News
    PA Entertainment

    Prince Charles admits to being fan of TV’s Poldark

    Charles’ admission came when he visited a Cornish bookshop.

  • Audi SQ8 sounds fierce during Nürburgring test
    News
    motor1

    Audi SQ8 sounds fierce during Nürburgring test

    Several Audi SQ8s are spied lapping the Nordschleife in this short clip.

  • Consecrated virgins need not be virgins, says Vatican 
    News
    The Telegraph

    Consecrated virgins need not be virgins, says Vatican 

    Consecrated virgins need not be virgins, says Vatican 

  • Queen Elizabeth owns how many swans? Annual count gets underway
    News
    Business Insider UK

    Queen Elizabeth owns how many swans? Annual count gets underway

    An 800-year-old tradition of counting the swans owned by Britain's Queen Elizabeth started on Monday, an annual ceremony of "swan upping" that in modern times has become a means of wildlife conservation. The upping sees three teams -- one representing the queen and the others the old trade associations of the Vintners and Dyers -- patrol the River Thames in south England over five days to capture, tag and release any families of swans with young. The upping dates back to the 12th century when the English crown first claimed ownership of all mute swans, then considered a delicacy that would be served at royal banquets.

  • News
    Business Insider UK

    Mother accused of killing baby with drug-laced breast milk

    A 30-year-old woman with a painkiller addiction has been accused of killing her 11-week-old son with a lethal mix of drugs in her breast milk. Samantha Jones was charged Friday with criminal homicide in the April 2 death of her baby. According to an affidavit, Jones told police she'd been too tired to make the baby a bottle when he awoke crying at 3 a.m. and instead breastfed him.

  • News
    Business Insider UK

    The Latest: Judge halts deportations of reunited families

    A federal judge has temporarily halted deportations of families who have been recently reunited after they were separated by the Trump administration. The American Civil Liberties Union filed paperwork saying attorneys were concerned about "mass deportations" following reunification of children ages five to 17 with their parents. Judge Dana Sabraw said Monday he'd order a temporary halt to any deportations for a week until the government can respond to the ACLU motion.

  • NHS decision to fund new asthma drug a 'beacon of hope' to thousands
    News
    The Telegraph

    NHS decision to fund new asthma drug a 'beacon of hope' to thousands

    NHS decision to fund new asthma drug a 'beacon of hope' to thousands

  • Net-a-Porter expand into childrenswear with Gucci capsule collection
    News
    Evening Standard

    Net-a-Porter expand into childrenswear with Gucci capsule collection

    Net-a-Porter has made its first ever foray into the childrenswear category, with a full-on fashion fabulous Gucci mini me collection. Think logo-print bum bags, mini pink frilly party dresses, tiny tiger-emblazoned intarsia knit jumpers and even mini versions of those iconic Gucci furry backless loafers. “The kidswear pop-up on Net-a-Porter is such an exciting moment for us,” said Alison Loehnis, President at Net-a-Porter and Mr Porter.

  • Nigeria: Army denies reports of missing soldiers after Boko Haram attacks
    France 24 Videos

    Nigeria: Army denies reports of missing soldiers after Boko Haram attacks

    Hundreds of Nigerian soldiers are reportedly missing after clashing with Boko Haram militants over the weekend. The military's denied local claims that troops are unaccounted for after armed extremists ambushed a military convoy near Bama in Borno state on Friday. Whilst in Kenya, former US president Barack Obama visited his father’s home town to open a youth centre. And football fans across Africa react to France’s World Cup win. The team featured 15 players of African origin.

  • Schoolboy Charlie Dunne killed in 'terrible accident' at beach in north Devon
    News
    Evening Standard

    Schoolboy Charlie Dunne killed in 'terrible accident' at beach in north Devon

    A schoolboy has died after a "terrible accident" on holiday in north Devon. Charlie Dunne, 18, who had recently completed his A-levels, was on a break with his family and friends when tragedy struck last week. The talented rugby player suffered a "catastrophic injury" to his vertebrae causing spinal injury before going into cardiac arrest.

  • The Guardian view on Elon Musk: a billionaire in need of humility
    News
    The Guardian

    The Guardian view on Elon Musk: a billionaire in need of humility

    Elon Musk says he is ‘somewhat libertarian’, but not enough to stop sucking up $4.9bn in government subsidies. Elon Musk is 47 years old and terrified by artificial intelligence. Mr Musk made his money from the online payment company PayPal.

  • Hollyoaks wedding drama revealed in 12 new pictures
    Digital Spy

    Hollyoaks wedding drama revealed in 12 new pictures

    Will Damon and Holly have a happy future? From Digital Spy

  • Kaleidoscope festival 2018: Tickets, line-up and everything you need to know
    News
    Evening Standard

    Kaleidoscope festival 2018: Tickets, line-up and everything you need to know

    Kaleidoscope, at Alexandra Palace and Park, will fuse together music, theatre, poetry and panel discussions. It will feature everything from one of America's best loved alternative rock bands to an immersive theatre experience taking place deep within the rarely opened basements beneath the Palace. It will take over the iconic Alexandra Palace, a long-standing bastion of live music, and the adjoining Alexandra Park, with six indoor and outdoor stages spread across both.

  • Trump 'treasonous' after siding with Putin on election meddling
    News
    The Guardian

    Trump 'treasonous' after siding with Putin on election meddling

    Donald Trump has been condemned as “treasonous” for siding with the Kremlin over his own government agencies after a stunning joint appearance with Vladimir Putin in which he seemingly accepted the Russian leader’s denial of election meddling. At a joint press conference after one-on-one talks lasting more than two hours in the Finnish capital, the US president offered no criticism of Putin or the cyber-attacks that the US intelligence community says he coordinated to help Trump’s 2016 election campaign.

  • News
    Business Insider UK

    Chinese online group Pinduoduo targets up to $1.63 billion in U.S. IPO

    Pinduoduo, owned by Walnut Street Group, plans to sell about 85.6 million American Depositary Shares in its initial public offering (IPO) at a price range of $16 to $19 each, according to its filing, which was uploaded to the exchange website on Monday. The company, backed by Chinese internet giant Tencent Holdings, will open the book to institutional investors on Tuesday and price its IPO next Wednesday, said two people close to the transaction.

  • Prime Day has become such a big shopping event that even retailers that never run deals are jumping on the opportunity
    News
    Business Insider UK

    Prime Day has become such a big shopping event that even retailers that never run deals are jumping on the opportunity

    The athletics label has said in the past that it avoids discounting its products. "People will pay for the product, and if you have a good product, you don't need sales," the company's founder, Tyler Haney, told Business Insider in an interview in June. Outdoor Voices, the trendy, Texas-based athletics label that usually doesn't offer discounts, is running a 40%-off sale on some of its core items from Monday to Friday of this week.

  • 2000trees review: Beautifully independent rock festival where kindness is king
    News
    The Independent

    2000trees review: Beautifully independent rock festival where kindness is king

    “This is the festival we made sure we’d be at,” and other such sentiments, are heard again and again at Upcote Farm, in the Cotswold Hills, over the course of 2000trees. Organisers proudly trumpet the fact that many performers high on the bill had early shows there too – Black Peaks, for example, who storm The Cave tent on Thursday prior to post-hardcore legends At the Drive-In’s whirlwind headline set. Baltimore hardcore punks Turnstile tear it up, Jonah Matranga brings emo nostalgia, Skinny Lister, sold to me as “angry sea shanties”, see hilariously wild mosh pits for their accordion-tinged folk-rock.

  • Huge New York power outage leaves more than 17,000 people without electricity
    News
    The Independent

    Huge New York power outage leaves more than 17,000 people without electricity

    Thousands of New Yorkers are currently without ectricity due to an unexplainable power outage. Over 17,000 homes experienced the outage after National Grid reported an issue with a high voltage transition line. "The lines are out of service," Steve Brady, a spokesperson for the National Grid, told the Rochester news outlet Democrat and Chronicle.

  • News
    Business Insider UK

    Lebanon must investigate torture claims by actor, HRW says

    The New York-based Human Rights Watch is calling on Lebanese authorities to investigate allegations of torture made by a well-known actor who was detained and later exonerated of charges of spying for Israel. The watchdog said Monday the case of Ziad Itani is a test for whether the law criminalizing torture, passed in November, will end impunity for security officials. Bassam Khawaja, a HRW researcher, said Itani's case "was extremely disturbing." Itani alleges he was framed, held incommunicado for days during which he was tortured and threatened with violence against his family.

  • Nadiya’s Family Favourites: Bake Off was just the start — Nadiya is Eliza Doolittle for a new generation
    News
    Evening Standard

    Nadiya’s Family Favourites: Bake Off was just the start — Nadiya is Eliza Doolittle for a new generation

    Is Nadiya Hussain the greatest culinary talent to emerge from British TV sensation The Great British Bake Off? A young, Muslim woman with a supportive, photogenic family, she is the ideal poster girl as the corporation finds its place in multicultural Britain. During her tenure as a contestant on the sixth series of GBBO, which she eventually won, much of Hussain’s inspiration for a long list of fun and creative bakes were the dishes she whipped up at home for her husband and children.