'Bake Off' Week 4: Paul Hollywood storms off from worst Technical Challenge ever

  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
·7-min read
In this article:
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
(Channel 4)
(Channel 4)

Brace yourselves, Great British Bake Off fans, for possibly the most disastrous Technical Challenge in the show’s history, ending in Paul Hollywood storming off from the judging table.

Pretty much everyone had a terrible week in the tent, but we’ve never seen anything quite so bad as this episode’s blind task.

Read more: See the first Hollywood Handshake of the series

However, be warned if you haven’t seen the result yet – the baker sent home was a huge shock.

Last year featured the inaugural vegan week in the Bake Off tent, but 2019 has seen the pendulum swing back towards animal products with the show’s first ever dairy week.

In other news, Helena’s voice is back! And it isn’t the Geordie or Scottish version that Noel Fielding offered to order her from the internet last week.

The Signature Bake

In celebration of all things dairy, the bakers kicked off with a cake made using cultured milk – although very few of them seemed clear on why that was a good thing (spoiler: because it’s delicious).

Phil proved once again to be a man after our own hearts as he announced: “It’s full fat all the way, here.”

Quite right.

Fun fact: in case you were wondering which truck Phil drives, it’s a 44-tonne fuel tanker, and he’s never run anyone over, although he has “done a few pigeons”.

Some fancy tins caused the most tension we’ve seen in Bake Off yet this series – Michelle managed to smash the cake stand while turning hers out, and poor Michael left half of his cheesecake swirl bake stuck in the tin.

Our hearts broke as Michael burst into tears yet again when Paul and Prue Leith told him the cake was delicious regardless, and Sandi Toksvig was on hand for a big hug.

It’s still Halloween at Helena’s bench, where she kicked off with a ghost cake and has already started planning her future with fellow goth Noel.

Who won the Technical Challenge?

Get ready for the worst Technical ever seen on Bake Off...

This week, the bakers were tasked with making a Tudor treat: maids of honour, full of a lemon curd cheese.

Read more: Paul Hollywood made over 9 times more than his Bake Off co-stars last year

Just in case you hadn’t noticed that making baking curds looks a little like vomit in a sieve, Michael was on hand with some handy sound effects.

Priya suffered one of the biggest Technical disasters we’ve seen so far when she completely miscalculated the timings, only partly baked her maids of honour, and presented just a few of the 10 required cakes, with some tipped upside down, which the judges refused to even taste.

She was far from the only baker in trouble though. Paul turned his back on the judging table and went to storm out of the tent, declaring: “They’re awful. They’re really bad.”

Unsurprisingly, Priya came last, but Steph was sort of triumphant when she was deemed the best of a bad bunch and managed to win the Technical by being slightly less awful than the others.

Read more: GBBO winner thanks Amanda Holden after missing sister is found

The Showstopper

Prue and Paul changed things up from the usual gargantuan bakes for this challenge, by asking the contestants to make a mishti centrepiece, a selection of milk-based Indian sweets.

Again, the stress levels were high, particularly for Henry, who was this challenge’s victim when his kulfi refused to set in the freezer and he was forced to serve up melted ice-cream puddles.

The highest praise Prue could muster for Henry was “you’d eat it if you were given it”, while Henry added: “As a prisoner, maybe?”

Prue also had a backhanded compliment for Phil’s gnome garden, telling him: “The rest of them are all so classy, they couldn’t do it.”

Who won Star Baker?

The race for top position was on between David and Steph this week, with Steph even dissing her rival’s lack of fringe when it got to the point where they could smell the Star Baker title.

Eventually Steph was named the crème de la crème in a week that could have seen pretty much anyone who wasn’t her or David go home.

However, we can all be in agreement that the real star of the week was the duck and her gorgeous ducklings, who stole the show in every scene.

Who went home?

Well, this one was a bit of a shocker for both the viewers and the bakers.

Priya’s week had been pretty disastrous, especially during the Technical; Henry looked a sure bet to be in the bottom few; and Michael was in tears for most of the episode over his failed bakes.

So the contestant going home in dairy week was... Phil?

The news was such a surprise that he couldn’t manage a gracious loser face, and even Paul admitted he had good reason to think it was an odd decision.

Ok, his gnome mishti weren’t exactly a Bake Off classic, but we don’t feel his exit was at all deserved.

The Great British Bake Off continues on Tuesdays at 8pm on Channel 4

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting