BBC Proms 29 and 32 review: Musical nostalgia from John Wilson’s ensemble and a larger than life performance from the National Youth Orchestra USA

Prom 29: The Warner Brothers’ Story, John Wilson Orchestra, John Wilson


With a swoon of strings and blinding razz of brass, the John Wilson Orchestra announce their 10th anniversary appearance at the Proms, taking us back to Hollywood’s Golden Age – an era that swathed even the grittiest domestic tragedy in musical mink and pearls.

And what luxury we get. From the quiet yearning of Max Steiner’s score for Bette Davis-vehicle Now, Voyager (strings here sanded back to the same soft-focus glow as the cinematography) to the swashbuckling urgency of Korngold’s The Sea Hawk and the seedy sensuality of Alex North’s A Streetcar Named Desire, this is where film music really began. A final encore of John Williams’ music for Harry Potter reminds us just how far its influence extends.

Wilson’s brand of musical nostalgia is delivered with a straight face and absolutely no sentimentality, letting the late-Romantic radiance of so many of these scores (Dimitri Tiomkin’s The Old Man and the Sea is a delicious, if too-brief, highlight) speak for itself. His is an orchestra of generals, and the colour these players draw from these sepia masterpieces is dazzling.

Whether it’s the dirty-talking solo trumpet in Howard Arlen’s Blues in the Night or the swing-band swagger of the brass in the overture to Gypsy, the orchestra is the star here. Which leaves soloists Louise Dearman, Matt Ford and Mikaela Bennett seeming just a little superfluous. Their slick numbers from My Fair Lady, Calamity Jane (a tour-de-force by Dearman) and A Star is Born have plenty of musical pizzazz, but lose something of their personality in the anonymising classical stadium of the Royal Albert Hall.

Prom 32: Joyce DiDonato, National Youth Orchestra USA, Antonio Pappano


There are no such difficulties for the National Youth Orchestra of America, whose sprawling forces and big-boned programme of Strauss and Berlioz are already larger than life. Bounding into the hall in their blazers, red jeans and matching trainers, the group look more like young Olympians than a symphony orchestra, and the similarities only increase once they start to play.

A curtain-raiser by 19-year-old American composer Benjamin Beckman (how often do you hear classical music by a teenager performed by his own peers?) establishes the warm power of the ensemble’s sound. Energy is a given with youth orchestras, but restraint, pacing and blend are a bonus. The latter is the key to Berlioz’s sumptuous song-cycle Les nuits d’ete, with its drifting clouds of harmony and highly perfumed texts. American mezzo Joyce DiDonato is a natural communicator, meeting the orchestra on their own, delicate territory before drawing them out into brighter, blowsier bloom in the cycle’s glorious close “L’ile inconnue”.

Strauss’s mighty Alpine Symphony leads its listeners up a mountain and down again in just under an hour, taking in waterfalls, meadows and a sunrise, as well a ferocious storm, along the way. Playing with light-footed ease and swiftness under the Royal Opera’s Antonio Pappano, the orchestra give a youthful account of the piece, never lingering along the way, but still finding plenty of detail in this Alpine landscape – a familiar scene viewed here as though from a fast-moving train, but all the more exhilarating for it.