A US judge has praised the victims of the so-called Islamic State terror cell known as The Beatles as “undeniably heroes” as he sentenced one of the group’s British members to life behind bars.
Alexanda Amon Kotey, 38, originally from Paddington, London, showed no emotion as he was handed eight life sentences for his crimes at Alexandria District Court, in Virginia, on Friday.
Judge Thomas Selby Ellis described his actions as “egregious, violent and inhumane” and described the victims as “soldiers for good”.
The court heard 13 impact statements from members of the victims’ families including those of British humanitarians Alan Henning and David Haines.
“We have all witnessed (the) exceptionally moving, heart-rending statements of these victims’ families,” Mr Ellis said, becoming audibly emotional himself following the statements.
“It should be a reminder of what we knew about the hostages.
“Countries celebrate heroes and we should celebrate these individuals who demonstrated courage, purpose and compassion under the most difficult of circumstances.
“The victims of the hostage-taking by Isis are undeniably heroes.”
Kotey’s co-defendant El Shafee Elsheikh was also present for the victim impact statements at the court hearing ahead of his sentencing in August after being convicted of his role in the murder plot.
Among those reading statements were Mr Haines’ brother Mike Haines, wife Dragana, and daughters Bethany and Athea.
Eleven-year-old Athea, who was just four when she lost her father, said his death had “affected my life in so many ways”.
“Sometimes I get sad when I see my friends laughing and playing with their fathers,” she told the court.
“It’s not easy to be the girl in school whose dad was killed by terrorists.”
Mr Haines described his brother as a “hero” and “a force for good” who had an “unrelenting desire” to help others.
“That was the fire that was in his belly,” he said.
Speaking to Kotey, he continued: “You have inflicted more pain than I can ever put into words… our lives will never be the same again.”
“For too long now, you and your cohort have held power over me and my family.
“I am no longer willing to let that happen.”
Then, in an extraordinary demonstration of his rejection of hatred, Mr Haines added: “Today I can say to you, you no longer have power over me and mine. I forgive you.”
Dragana Haines was less forgiving, telling both Kotey and Elsheikh that she hoped they lived “for 200 years” with their crimes.
“For all I care you can live long and suffer,” she said.
David Haines’ eldest daughter Bethany described the pair as “monsters”.
“I wonder why monsters like these men are on this earth while my dad isn’t… the anger bubbles inside me like a volcano and eventually it erupts,” she said.
“Neither of these men have expressed one ounce of remorse. These men are selfish and only care about themselves.
“I have no pity for them and hope they are forced to think about (the things they have done) and regret them for the rest of their lives.”
As Kotey left the courtroom, Mr Haines was heard telling him to “rot in hell”.
As part of his plea bargain, Kotey is expected to spend 15 years in jail in the US and then may be sent to the UK to serve the remainder of his sentence, where he may face further charges relating to the killings of Mr Henning and Mr Haines.
Kotey, an Islamic convert, was one of four so-called Islamic State militants nicknamed The Beatles by their captives due to their British accents, who carried out wanton acts of brutality in the mid 2010s.
The terror cell also comprised ringleader Mohammed Emwazi, known as Jihadi John, who was killed in a drone strike in 2015, and Aine Davis, who was jailed in Turkey in 2017.
Kotey was sentenced on eight counts – four counts of hostage-taking resulting in death; conspiracy to commit hostage-taking resulting in death; conspiracy to murder United States citizens outside of the United States; conspiracy to provide material support to terrorists, hostage-taking and murder, resulting in death; and conspiracy to provide material support to a designated foreign terrorist organisation resulting in death.
Kotey admitted his guilt in September last year, apparently agreeing to fully co-operate with authorities as part of his plea agreement.
The Queens Park Rangers football fan said that when he departed the UK he held “the belief and understanding that the Islamic concept of armed jihad was a valid and legitimate cause and means by which a Muslim defends his fellow Muslim against injustice”.
He admitted his role in capturing hostages and said when his involvement in that came to an end, he worked in IS’s recruitment division, as a sniper and in the terror group’s “English media department”.
He denied being present when the murders were carried out.
Kotey was charged in relation to the killings of four US hostages, journalists James Foley and Steven Sotloff and aid workers Peter Kassig and Kayla Mueller.