Ken Paxton successfully ousts three Republican criminal appeal court judges

The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals on Jan. 15, 2020.
The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals on Jan. 15, 2020. Credit: Miguel Gutierrez Jr./The Texas Tribune

Three incumbent judges on Texas’ highest criminal court have been ousted in their bids for reelection on Tuesday after Attorney General Ken Paxton targeted the Republicans over a 2021 ruling that struck down the attorney general’s ability to unilaterally prosecute voter fraud.

The Associated Press declared David Schenck, Gina Parker and Lee Finley won their races over Judges Sharon Keller, Barbara Hervey and Michelle Slaughter respectively. Presiding Judge Keller was first elected to the bench in 1994.

Paxton targeted the judges as part of a larger political revenge tour in which he attempted to oust Texas House members who voted to impeach him in May.

In 2021, Keller, Hervey and Slaughter sided with five of the other Republican judges on the Court of Criminal Appeals in a voter fraud case. The 8-1 decision ruled that the Office of the Attorney General violated the separation of powers in the Texas Constitution by trying to prosecute election cases without the permission of a local prosecutor.

But in media appearances and primary advertisements, Paxton painted the three incumbents as rogue Republicans who stripped the attorney general’s power to go after voter fraud — a political topic dear to the modern GOP in light of former President Donald Trump’s false claims of election interference.

Together, the three incumbents had nearly a century of experience practicing criminal law, as prosecutors and jurists. Nine judges sit on the Court of Criminal Appeals which is the state’s highest criminal court. The Texas Supreme Court hears civil cases.

The Texas attorney general is the state’s chief lawyer, but leaves the prosecution of crimes — including voter fraud — to locally elected county attorneys and district attorneys.

With Keller, Hervey and Slaughter off the bench, there are still five judges on the court that Paxton has previously said should be ousted for voting against him in 2021. Two of those judges, David Newell and Bert Richardson, will be up for reelection in 2026 should they choose to run. Kevin Patrick Yeary, the sole pro-Paxton vote, will also be up for reelection that same year.

In a statement released by Paxton late Tuesday evening, the attorney general said the incumbent losses were a victory for democratic principles.

“To those who would seek to obstruct justice or undermine our laws, know this: The people of Texas will not tolerate it,” Paxton said in his statement. “Your days of judicial activism are numbered, and Texans are ready to hold you accountable.”

The all-Republican court is likely to remain entirely in GOP hands as the three elections are open to statewide voters. It’s been three decades since a Democrat won a statewide election.

Presiding Judge

Schenck, who will now face Democratic nominee Holly Taylor this November, was gratified by Tuesday’s results, which he attributed in part to Trump’s recent endorsement. He said the issue of election integrity was important in all three races, even if he did not make it central to his campaign. Schenck has been hesitant to opine on the court’s voter fraud opinion.

Taylor, an assistant director in the civil rights division of the Travis County District Attorney’s office, ran unopposed in the Democratic Primary on Tuesday.

Looking forward, Schenck said he was eager to improve judicial integrity as part of the new generation of leadership.

“The public doesn’t believe courts are working fairly and they want impartial, competent and efficient judges,” he said Tuesday evening.

Schenck, a former judge for the state’s Fifth District Court of Appeals in Dallas, ran on campaign criticizing the pace at which the court moved. He argued the appeals court had lost the confidence from some in the legal community for the rate at which it delivered opinions. He previously ran for the Texas Supreme Court in 2022; he lost by 10 points.

Keller was elected to the criminal appellate court in 1994 as the first female judge. Prior to her decades-long tenure, Keller worked as an assistant district attorney for Dallas County.

Prior to this year’s election, Keller was the subject of several ethics complaints, which included a failure to disclose millions in personal holdings and an incident in which she closed the clerk's office for the court as attorneys for a death row inmate attempted to file a last-minute appeal.

Place 7

Following her decisive victory, Parker said in a statement that it was clear Republicans want a new chapter on the Court of Criminal Appeals.

Parker is a Waco attorney who has practiced both civil and criminal law and owns the dental equipment company, Dental Creations Ltd. She disagreed with the current court’s decision in the 2021 voter fraud case, arguing it was an attack on the attorney general’s power and the Legislature’s ability to make laws that empower Paxton’s office.

“Texans want more from their Judiciary: higher standards and more productivity while seeking to maintain that balance of honoring the intent of the legislature and proper interpretations of our constitutions as we deliberate the cases that will come before us,” Parker's statement read.

This was Parker’s second attempt to challenge a Republican incumbent on the criminal appeals court bench. In 2020, she lost to Judge Bert Richardson in that year’s Republican primary and he was eventually re-elected to his Place 3 seat.

When Hervey, who has been on the bench since 2001, was reached by phone Tuesday evening, she said, “Darth Vader is not supposed to win the war in those movies.”

Soon after AP called her race for Parker, Hervey said she was worried about the future of the court. She plans to work through the year to ensure someone would pick up the mantle of the programs she’s pioneered over the last two decades.

In addition to her judicial duties, Hervey co-chairs the Judicial Commission on Mental Health. She also runs an education program that provides legal courses and assistance to judges, prosecutors, defense attorneys and court personnel.

Had Hervey and Keller won reelection, they both would have had to retire before the end of their six-year terms given a Texas law requiring judges to leave the bench at 75. The governor would appoint someone to finish their terms.

Parker will face Democratic nominee Nancy Mulder, who presides over Texas Criminal District Court 6 in Dallas County, in the November general election.

Place 8

Finley, a U.S. Marine Corps veteran, has practiced criminal law for over 20 years, according to his campaign biography.

He came under scrutiny during the Republican primary over reports that he and his wife are facing a civil judgment after defaulting on a home mortgage payment in 2016. The couple appealed a district court decision ordering them to repay lenders, pausing the seizure of their home.

In November, Finley will face Chika Anyiam, the Texas Criminal District Court 7 judge in Dallas County, who already secured the Democratic nomination.

Slaughter, a former district judge in Galveston County, was in her first term on the criminal appeals bench after winning her election in 2018.

During the primary season, Slaughter pushed back against Paxton’s characterization of the 2021 opinion. She said the attorney general and her critics were pushing misinformation about her and the court.

The Texas Tribune answering reader questions about 2024 elections. To share your question or feedback with us, you can fill out this form.

We can’t wait to welcome you to downtown Austin Sept. 5-7 for the 2024 Texas Tribune Festival! Join us at Texas’ breakout politics and policy event as we dig into the 2024 elections, state and national politics, the state of democracy, and so much more. When tickets go on sale this spring, Tribune members will save big. Donate to join or renew today.

Correction, March 6, 2024 at 4:57 p.m. : An earlier version of this story incorrectly reported that there are four other judges on the Texas Courts of Criminal Appeal that Attorney General Ken Paxton had said should be ousted for voting against him in 2021. There are five other CCA judges targeted by Paxton.