Easter taste test: where to buy the best Easter eggs in 2018

From intricate eggs to sumptuous simnel cake and the fruitiest hot cross buns, five top chefs put seasonal snacks to the blind taste test, selecting the stars of the show. -
From intricate eggs to sumptuous simnel cake and the fruitiest hot cross buns, five top chefs put seasonal snacks to the blind taste test, selecting the stars of the show. -

Spectacular Easter eggs from the high street and specialist producers (including one shaped like half an avocado - yes, really), have been tested by Martyn Nail, the executive chef (and self-proclaimed chocolate fan)  at Claridge’s.

"The snap and crack is all-important in a chocolate egg. At the hotel, we hide praline quail’s eggs inside our Valrhona egg before it is foiled, ribboned and boxed."

claridges.co.uk

Selfridges Selection Artisan Milk Chocolate Easter Egg

£29.99 for 190g

Selfridges selection Easter egg
Selfridges selection Easter egg

I love the high-gloss finish and artistic design, but there’s an unpleasant sourness to the chocolate flavour and it has an oily texture. What a shame.
RATING 1.5 out of 5

Betty’s Limited Edition Spring Bloom Egg

£30 for 315g

Bettys spring bloom egg
Bettys spring bloom egg

Beautifully ornate, but it’s a shame there’s nothing inside. There’s no nose to the white chocolate so the taste is a bit of a let-down. Good if you like white chocolate.
RATING: 2 out of 5

Chococo Madagascar 65% MegaMilk Easter Egg

£18 for 175g

Chococo mega milk egg
Chococo mega milk egg

I like the diamond-mould design, but the shell itself is not terribly well-finished and has uneven thickness. It’s caramelly chocolate, with slight bitter notes, but a tad one-dimensional.
RATING: 2 out of 5

Sainsbury’s Exclusive Godiva Milk Chocolate Easter Egg

£14 for 255g

Godiva egg at Sainsburys
Godiva egg at Sainsburys

A simple yet quite effective design, but there’s nothing on the nose and the chocolate is soft and sickly, and too creamy for my taste.
RATING 2.5 out of 5

Tesco Finest Caramelised Hazelnut Egg

£8 for 240g

Tesco egg
Tesco egg

I like the natural acorn-shell look. There’s no crack at all and the chocolate falls apart. The nuts make a lovely combination, but they are carrying the chocolate here.
RATING: 3 out of 5

Marks & Spencer Hand Painted Belgian Milk Chocolate Egg

£12 for 240g

marks and spencer egg
marks and spencer egg

More grown-up in look than it tastes – the chocolate is a bit flat in flavour, and very sweet and cloying. The champagne truffles that come with it are sugary sweet, too.
RATING: 3 out of 5

Artisan du Chocolat Pineapple Easter Egg

£15 for 200g

Artisan du Chocolate
Artisan du Chocolate

Nicely sculpted, with a satisfying snap, but there’s no smell at all and the flavour is disappointing. The piña colada dark-chocolate balls are much better, if you don’t mind the punchy filling!
RATING: 3 out of 5

Asda Extra Special Hand-Decorated Belgian Dark Chocolate Egg with Cherry

£7 for 290g

Asda chocolate egg
Asda chocolate egg

A great crack and an instantly strong flavour. It’s dark and glossy, and has a clever texture with freeze-dried fruit.
RATING 3.5 out of 5

Prestat Pink Popping Prosecco Egg

£17.50 for 170g

Prestat popping candy egg
Prestat popping candy egg

The foil is an appealing look and there’s a nice surprise of truffles inside, and a brush of pink chocolate. Popping candy is a playful addition – thumbs up for the innovation and excitement factor. It’s quite charming.
RATING: 4 out of 5

Waitrose Chocolate Avocado

£8 for 250g

Waitrose avocado egg
Waitrose avocado egg

A very clever idea and use of textures. It’s really well executed and has a strong chocolate aroma, plus a great crack, which means it has been brilliantly tempered. Lovely taste of good-quality, dark chocolate with bitter notes. Nicely done.
RATING: 4.5 out of 5

Demarquette 71.1% Chocolate Clam On Easter Egg

£40 for approx 500g

Demarquette clam on egg
Demarquette clam on egg

Very beautiful and unusual, with little caramel shells and a large, thick egg of dark chocolate. It has such depth of flavour – slightly smoky, earthy and bitter – and the caramels are super-salty for contrast. A step above the rest.
RATING: 5 out of 5