Fact Check: This Is a Genuine Pic of Someone Watching the Twin Towers During 9/11 Attacks
Claim:
A photo shared online in 2024 authentically showed a young woman seated on a building ledge, watching one of the Twin Towers burn during the 9/11 terrorist attacks in the U.S.
Rating:
In the days before the 23rd anniversary of 9/11 terrorist attacks, a photo purportedly showing a woman in New York City watching one of the Twin Towers burn circulated on social media.
For instance, an X user shared the photo in late August 2024 with the caption, "Can't believe this girl just sat there and let 9/11 happen."
can't believe this girl just sat there and let 9/11 happen pic.twitter.com/Hh95lmWqCH
— The Notorious J.O.V. (@whotfisjovana) August 26, 2024
The image has circulated online for more than a decade. One iteration on X, posted in July 2024, amassed more than 28 million views as of this writing. Some people replied to that post saying they were unsure whether the photo was real. One X user wrote: "Have never seen this photo before. I'll assume it's fake for engagement… like this," while another said: "Can't be real. She'd have been cold that morning dressed like this. It was a crisp morning."
One person suggested the image had been digitally created using artificial intelligence (AI): "I'm guessing this is ai. First this picture is too clear to be from 2001 and second it looks like she has another finger growing off of her ring finger. Something just doesn't seem right."
The picture also exists in posts on Imgur and Reddit from 2019, two more Reddit posts from 2017 and 2016, and a post on Flickr from 2013.
During a photo shoot, a model in New York City is distracted by the first plane hitting the World Trade Center on September 11th, 2001.
byu/beaverkc inpics
Snopes traced the image back to Los Angeles-based photographer Ari Abramczyk, who confirmed via email she took picture. She also showed us other photographs she captured from that moment but asked us not to publish them. Abramczyk provided Snopes with the original files, where the metadata showed they were taken on the morning of Sept. 11, 2001.
Abramczyk said she initially put the photo in question on Flickr in 2005; however, she was uncomfortable with how widely it circulated online, so she took it down.
On Sept. 12, 2021, Abramczyk wrote a post on Instagram explaining the story behind the image:
I think it's time I set the story straight on this image. This is my image, I took it when I was 18, living in Tribeca in a model apartment on the West Side Highway in New York. I've always been pretty private about these images. This image was posted one time, on Flickr, with a small caption, when I was in school for photojournalism, and never again since. I have never released the other images from that day, and I don't know if I ever will. I have never sold this image or given permission for anyone to post it. I have never made a single penny off of it, and would never want to. In the 15 or so years since I made that image public, it has taken on a life of its own, and every year, several friends tag me in posts to alert me where the image has gone. I've never wanted to make a post about it, but this year, on the 20th anniversary of the attack, the comments got even more brutal. Every year, I have a panic attack. Every year I am so disturbed, so effected by what people say about it. I thought maybe it was time to get the real story out there. I don't think I owe anyone an explanation. I lived through a traumatic event and I had PTSD for many years. Maybe I still do. But I thought maybe, if the real story is out there, it might ease my mind on the coming years.
She later told Snopes she was 17 when she took the picture, not 18.
Abramczyk provided a more thorough explanation behind the photo in a follow-up post the same day. She said she was working as a model at the time and lived with three other models in her Tribeca apartment. On the morning of Sept. 11, she was woken up by an "incredibly intense" sound that shook the building.
I looked out of the window to the street below and saw nothing. Then I looked over and saw it. One of the twin towers was on fire. I started to hear people screaming. People were running down the highway away from the building.
Abramczyk explained that she grabbed her camera and went up to the roof to take photos to process what was happening.
"It was a shield between me and the world. I didn't know what else to do," she wrote.
"One of my new roommates sat down on the ledge, and I saw this wild juxtaposition between her beauty and the horror in front of us, and I took the picture."
She then said she witnessed another plane hitting the second tower before packing a bag and fleeing her apartment while screaming and crying.
The photographer took more pictures upon reaching the street and even more in the following weeks. She said the event made her realize she wanted to be a photographer but later switched to commercial photography as she "didn't have the stomach" for photojournalism.
However, Abramczyk explained how she regretted posting the photo online:
I regret posting the image with model's name who is in it. I captioned it like I had been told to do in school. I imagine that she sees this image every year, and I imagine it's probably painful for her, too. I have never spoken to her again, nor has she reached out to me. But if you ever read this, please know that I am sorry. If I could take that back, I would. I have relived this moment so many times. I think maybe it will ease my mind that I know that the real story is out there, if people want to know it.
Although Abramczyk asked Snopes not to publish the other images, she did give us permission to use the photograph in question in this article.
More than two decades on, numerous tales, claims and rumors continue to spread regarding what happened on 9/11, and Snopes has published dozens of articles on the subject.
Sources:
'Contact'. ARI ABRAMCZYK PHOTOGRAPHY, https://ariabramczyk.com/info. Accessed 8 July 2024.
Instagram. https://www.instagram.com/p/CTtKuY3lj8b/. Accessed 8 July 2024.
---. https://www.instagram.com/p/CTvHm0kB993/. Accessed 8 July 2024.