Family had to say goodbye to child battling suspected hospital bug, inquiry told

·5-min read
The inquiry is looking at the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow (Jane Barlow/PA) (PA Wire)
The inquiry is looking at the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow (Jane Barlow/PA) (PA Wire)

A father has told how his family were called in around four times to say a final goodbye to his cancer patient daughter as she fought an infection he suspects was linked to the hospital environment.

Mark Bisset told the Scottish Hospitals Inquiry (SHI) they discussed switching off the machines his daughter was on as doctors appeared to have run out of options for her treatment.

The inquiry is investigating the construction of the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital (QEUH) campus in Glasgow which includes the Royal Hospital for Children, after issues at the flagship site were linked to the deaths of two children.

Mr Bisset’s daughter was diagnosed with leukaemia in January 2019 when she was seven. She was initially treated at the old Edinburgh Hospital for Sick Children between January 2019 and July 2019 before being admitted to the QEUH on July 21 that year for a bone marrow transplant.

Lord Brodie is chairing the inquiry (Jane Barlow/PA) (PA Wire)
Lord Brodie is chairing the inquiry (Jane Barlow/PA) (PA Wire)

The inquiry heard she had the transplant on ward 4B in the adult part of the hospital in early August but she developed breathing difficulties and her condition deteriorated over the next few days.

Around August 18 she was moved to the Paediatric Intensive Care Unit (PICU), where she was placed on a ventilator and Mr Bisset said that around August 22 they were told to “get the family up”.

Asked what he took that to mean by Victoria Arnott, junior counsel to the inquiry, he said: “She was not going to make it through the night. She had only been on the ventilator a day or two and we were told her condition was becoming serious and there was not much more they could do apart from keep her comfortable at the time.”

At the start of September doctors also tried placing his daughter on an oscillator ventilator before moving her back to an ordinary ventilator, at which point the family discussed whether treatment should continue.

Mr Bisset said: “That’s when we’re having the discussions as a family, discussing if we should switch the machines off because she is at the point now, the doctors are telling us that there’s nothing they can do or try to save her, it was just about keeping her comfortable at that point.”

However another intensive care doctor then suggested giving the child a massive dose of steroids for a few days to see how she responded, and that saved her.

His daughter spent around eight weeks in PICU before being discharged back on to ward 4B around mid-October.

In my view, due to all the building work, the ventilation and the water supply were affected, and this had an effect on my daughter

Mark Bisset

Mr Bisset said when his daughter was initially admitted to PICU he found out she had a fungal infection, which he discovered was called aspergillus when he overheard a conversation between nurses.

In his witness statement to the inquiry, Mr Bisset said he believes his daughter caught aspergillus in ward 4B as she was never out of the room on the ward.

He stated: “In August 2019, one of the infections, aspergillus, was so bad that she was admitted to PICU and we were told several times by intensive care staff that we may lose her.

“In my view, due to all the building work, the ventilation and the water supply were affected, and this had an effect on my daughter.

“When you Google aspergillus in a hospital environment, it can only come from ventilation, water supply or from building work.”

Mr Bisset’s daughter was moved back to ward six, which he said he was not happy about and added: “Every time you went up to ward six there was a different room sealed off, taped up.

“A lot of the nurses were adamant that it wasn’t safe.”

Just before his daughter’s transplant went ahead, Mr Bisset said the girl in the room next door had to be evacuated because the room flooded.

Ms Arnott said she wanted to ask Mr Bisset about a smell he had mentioned in his statement.

Mr Bisset said: “There was a constant smell of sewage.

“I know the hospital is built right next door to Glasgow sewage works but the hospital does not have any windows that open.

“Every time you go to use the sinks or wash your hands you could smell the sewage coming from the drains.”

He added that you can smell sewage wherever you are in the hospital.

“It was billed as Scotland’s super hospital but there’s nothing super about it,” added Mr Bisset.

Ms Arnott said she wanted Mr Bisset to reflect on the impact that all of this had on him and his daughter.

Mr Bisset said: “It has been hard, she’s really struggled to fight back, she has been two-and-a-half years leukaemia-free.

“She dreads going to Glasgow (hospital), even for an in and out visit, she’d happily go to Edinburgh hospital no bother.

“If I never have to see Glasgow hospital again I’d be quite happy.”

The inquiry is also examining the construction of the Royal Hospital for Children and Young People and Department of Clinical Neurosciences in Edinburgh.

It was ordered after patients at the Glasgow hospital died from infections linked to pigeon droppings and the water supply, and the opening of the Edinburgh site was delayed due to concerns over the ventilation system.

Earlier this year, an independent review found the deaths of two children at the QEUH campus were at least in part the result of infections linked to the hospital environment.

The inquiry in Edinburgh, chaired by Lord Brodie, continues.

Health boards will be giving evidence at a later stage in the inquiry.

Read More

‘End in sight’ for polluting coal with new moves announced at Cop26

Nicola Sturgeon defends Scotland’s targets after they were deemed ‘overcooked’

Douglas Stuart reflects on how Booker Prize win has ‘transformed’ his life

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting