Fish are sentient animals who form friendships and experience 'positive emotions', landmark study suggests

Ian Johnston
Zebrafish are less scared of danger when they are in a group: Getty

Fish are sentient animals who form friendships, experience “positive emotions” and have individual personalities.

That, according to the Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSPCA), is the implication of a landmark new study which found zebrafish are social animals in a similar way to humans and other mammals.

And people who refuse to eat meat on moral grounds but do eat fish – as well as people who keep fish as pets – should bear that in mind, Dr Penny Hawkins, head of the RSPCA’s research animals department, told The Independent.

The researchers discovered that being in a group gives zebrafish a kind of “social buffering” so they are less afraid when confronted by danger.

And this effect was associated with a distinct pattern of brain activation known to be involved in social buffering in mammals, they added.

Because of this similar mechanism, the scientists hope zebrafish can now be used as a model to study social effects on human health with suggestions that isolation can have a significant impact on conditions such as depression.

But Dr Hawkins said the study also added to the growing body of evidence that fish should not be viewed as lesser animals.

“I think if you are going to think it’s okay to eat any animal, then you have to realise what you are doing,” she said.

“You are causing the death of an animal who is sentient, who has experiences, interests.”

She said the RSPCA did not advocate vegetarianism but operated a “welfare friendly” labelling scheme for meat and fish.

“If you do choose to eat meat and fish do just be aware of what you are buying into and make sure you go for higher welfare labels and not just the cheapest,” she said.

Asked if she thought fish could form friendships, Dr Hawkins said: “It depends how you define friendship. It’s not going to be analogous to human friendship.

“But if you think of friendship in terms of being with another individual who you are familiar with and whose company you seek and who makes you feel positive emotions, then these are fish friendships.

“It would be a good thing if these kinds of results were used, not only to improve the lives of laboratory fish, but also for people who keep fish in fish tanks to think about what they are doing when they mix unfamiliar fish together or when they split groups of fish up.

“They are not just ornaments or play things for people, they are individuals, they are sentient.

“There’s quite a lot of research going on into fish personalities. Some fish are bold, some are shy, there’s a whole lot more going on in the fish tank than people than people thought previously.”

However she also criticised the study, saying the anaesthetic used on the fish before they were killed had been “shown to be very irritating for them”.

“They will work quite hard to get out of it. There are other anaesthetics that don’t have this effect,” Dr Hawkins said.

She said it was a “a bit of a tragic conflict” that the evidence “to make people sit up and think” about fish had come from a study that involved animal suffering.

“The price these individuals paid in order to find this out was pretty high,” Dr Hawkins said.

The zebrafish were kept in a laboratory tank and exposed to their own ‘alarm substance’, a secretion from their skin that signals danger, the researchers said in the journal Scientific Reports.

If they were alone, they displayed signs of greater fear, but when they were with other zebrafish they responded more calmly. They were then killed to allow their brains to be examined.

Professor Rui Oliveira, of the ISPA university in Lisbon, who led the study, said what made it significant was the discovery that zebrafish shared a similar social buffering process in the brain with humans and mammals.

Asked about whether it should change people perceptions of fish, he said: “What this study shows is certainly they change the way they perceive their environment when others are present, which suggests they might be cognitively more complex than we originally thought.

“Maybe because of that people will become more aware of their needs and welfare issues. I think if it helps, it’s great.

“There are all the myths about fish have a memory of five seconds, like in [the film Finding] Nemo, that’s obviously not the case.”

On Dr Hawkins’ complaint about the way the zebrafish were killed, he said the anaesthetic used was part of the official protocol and he was unaware of a better alternative.

His colleague, Dr Ana Faustino, stressed the zebrafish’s social support process “does not have the complexity of the social support verified in humans”.

But she added: “Research in zebrafish will allow us to explore in depth the neural mechanisms involved in this social behaviour, which is paramount to the well-being and mental health of the human species, particularly due to its relevance to certain psychological diseases such as depression.”

  • The UK will soon reap what it has sown amid the Windrush generation scandal
    News
    The Independent

    The UK will soon reap what it has sown amid the Windrush generation scandal

    The disgraceful treatment of the Windrush generation is not some aberration that has been thrown up from the bowels of the Home Office, as some seem to think. The “hostile environment” policy of the Home Office typifies the attitude to migrants, particularly since the Brexit vote. The UK will pay the price, with its ageing population and creaking public services that are in the main kept going by migrant labour.

  • Princess Charlotte will make history when the royal baby is born
    News
    Evening Standard

    Princess Charlotte will make history when the royal baby is born

    In September last year, the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge announced they were expecting their third child in ‘April 2018’. While Britain gears up for the new royal addition – and imminent royal wedding between Uncle Prince Harry and Meghan Markle next month – it’s Princess Charlotte who could be making royal history. This is due to the Succession to the Crown Act 2013, which was passed when the Duchess was pregnant with Prince George and stated that succession to the throne would be based wholly on birth order – not gender.

  • Could World War III Be Fought Without Nuclear Weapons? | Opinion
    News
    Newsweek

    Could World War III Be Fought Without Nuclear Weapons? | Opinion

    As the US, Russia and China test each other’s patience and strategic focus, speculation about the chances of a world war has hit a new high. Russia and China, by contrast, have nothing of equivalent quantity or quality with which to threaten the US mainland.

  • Theresa May ‘may have to bow to parliamentary pressure’ over customs union
    News
    The Independent

    Theresa May ‘may have to bow to parliamentary pressure’ over customs union

    Theresa May’s team have reportedly accepted that she may have to bow to parliamentary pressure to keep Britain in a customs union with the European Union. It follows an embarrassing defeat in the House of Lords last week when peers in the upper chamber voted in favour of a customs union after Brexit and reports that around a 10 Tory MPs are prepared to vote in favour of membership in the Commons. The Prime Minister – since her Lancaster House speech in January 2017 – has repeatedly insisted that Britain will leave the customs union in order to pursue free trade deals across the world.

  • What we must learn from Asperger exposé
    News
    The Guardian

    What we must learn from Asperger exposé

    The late Lorna Wing, above, had Hans Asperger translated long before the world knew of his involvement in the Nazis’ euthanasia programme, says Uta Frith. It has taken me a while to digest Herwig Czech’s deeply upsetting information about Hans Asperger (Revealed: how Doctor Asperger aided the Nazi project, 19 April). Neither Lorna Wing, the instigator of the translation, nor I believed he was part of the Nazi machinery of death.

  • Prince Harry and Meghan Markle's royal wedding: date, details and latest news
    News
    The Telegraph

    Prince Harry and Meghan Markle's royal wedding: date, details and latest news

    Prince Harry and Meghan Markle's royal wedding: date, details and latest news

  • News
    Reuters

    Canadian accused of killing Peruvian medicine woman lynched in Amazon

    A Canadian man was lynched in the Peruvian Amazon after residents of a remote village accused him of killing an 81-year-old medicine woman a day earlier, a spokesman for the attorney general's office said on Sunday. Olivia Arevalo, a traditional healer of the Shipibo-Conibo tribe, was shot twice and died on Thursday near her home in the Amazonian region of Ucayali, said Ricardo Palma Jimenez, the head of a group of prosecutors in Ucayali. Some villagers had blamed Arevalo's murder on Sebastian Paul Woodroffe, a 41-year-old Canadian citizen who lived in the region and who was believed to have been one of her clients, said Jimenez.

  • World's first ocean plastic-cleaning machine set to tackle Great Pacific Garbage Patch
    News
    The Independent

    World's first ocean plastic-cleaning machine set to tackle Great Pacific Garbage Patch

    The system, originally dreamed up by a teenager, will be shipped out this summer to the Great Pacific Garbage Patch, between Hawaii and California, and which contains an estimated 1.8 trillion pieces of plastic. The Great Pacific Garbage Patch (GPGP) spans 617,763 sq miles - more than twice the size of France, and contains at least 79,000 tons of plastic, research found last month.

  • German shoppers sample burgers made of buffalo worms
    News
    Reuters

    German shoppers sample burgers made of buffalo worms

    Supermarket shoppers in the western German city of Aachen have stepped out of their comfort zone to sample insect burgers made of buffalo worms. The worms, highly nutritious due to their high protein content, are the larvae of buffalo beetles and are bred in the Netherlands.

  • Number of Deaths in Kabul Suicide Bombing Rises; Second Bombing Leaves 6 Dead
    Storyful

    Number of Deaths in Kabul Suicide Bombing Rises; Second Bombing Leaves 6 Dead

    An Islamic State suicide bomber killed at least 63, including women and children, and wounded 119 outside a voter registration center in Afghanistan’s capital, Kabul, on Sunday, April 22, India’s Business Standard and other sources reported. Estimates of the number of people killed in the bombing, also acknowledged on Sunday by Islamic State’s propaganda arm, Amaq News, rose steadily through the day. Reports said the bombing was the latest attack on preparations for Afghanistan’s elections on October 20. “It happened at the entrance gate of the centre. It was a suicide attack,” Dawood Amin, Kabul police chief, told Agence France Presse. A second attack on Sunday in the northern province of Baghlan left six people dead, including three women and two children, in a roadside explosion. Credit: Azadi Radio

  • News
    Newsweek

    Jay Feeley Responds to Prom Gun Photo, Says It Wasn't Loaded

    Jay Feely, a former American football player who ended his career with the Chicago bears in 2014, posted an image Saturday of him holding a gun while standing with his daughter and her prom date. The image caused controversy for being in bad taste with the current climate on gun control, but Feely later responded, insisting the image was a joke and that he respects gun safety. "Wishing my beautiful daughter and her date a great time at prom #BadBoys," Feely tweeted.

  • Sir Anthony Hopkins puzzles fans with ‘scary’ Twitter video
    News
    PA Entertainment

    Sir Anthony Hopkins puzzles fans with ‘scary’ Twitter video

    The actor said his actions in the video were what happens ‘when you’re all work and no play’.

  • Kicking up a stink on Record Store Day
    News
    The Guardian

    Kicking up a stink on Record Store Day

    It was Record Store Day on Saturday 21 Apr 2018. ‘Buying records on the internet and having them delivered in nice brown parcels is so much more pleasant,’ writes Mark Goodall. Photograph: Matthew Chattle/Rex/Shutterstock

  • News
    Business Insider UK

    Poster for Elvis North Carolina show sells for over $42,000

    RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — A rare vintage poster for a 1955 Elvis Presley show in North Carolina has sold at auction for more than double the expected price.

  • Feeling stressed? This paint-pouring art will chill you out
    News
    PA Viral News UK

    Feeling stressed? This paint-pouring art will chill you out

    Her videos have thousands of views.

  • Greek anarchists throw paint at French consulate
    News
    AFP

    Greek anarchists throw paint at French consulate

    A Greek anarchist group on Sunday attacked the French consulate in Athens, Greek police said, in protest at France's involvement in airstrikes against Syria.

  • Regulation of the media is in clear need of fresh thinking
    News
    The Guardian

    Regulation of the media is in clear need of fresh thinking

    In these times of Russian meddling in democracies’ information environments and an authoritarian government in Russia hostile to media freedom, it would be a satisfying irony if Russia were to contribute indirectly to regulatory reform leading to greater media freedom in the UK. The thought occurred last week when Ofcom, the UK broadcasting regulator, opened seven new investigations into “the due impartiality of RT news and current affairs programmes”.

  • 11 migrants dead, 263 rescued off Libya coast: navy
    News
    AFP

    11 migrants dead, 263 rescued off Libya coast: navy

    At least eleven migrants died at sea and another 263 were rescued on Sunday in two separate operations off the coast of Libya, the country's navy said.

  • Video shows panic as window falls off due to turbulence during packed Air India flight
    News
    The Independent

    Video shows panic as window falls off due to turbulence during packed Air India flight

    This is horrifying moment a flight attendant tries to fix a window panel which has fallen off during a packed flight – less than 24 hours after a woman died when she was sucked through a plane window. The footage shows the aftermath of severe turbulence which had caused the frame to come loose and left three people needing hospital treatment. Many of the 240 passengers on board the Air India flight appear panicked as the crew member tries heroically to lodge the panel back in.

  • Arsenal star Henrikh Mkhitaryan ruled out of Europa League semi-final first leg against Atletico Madrid
    News
    Evening Standard

    Arsenal star Henrikh Mkhitaryan ruled out of Europa League semi-final first leg against Atletico Madrid

    Arsene Wenger has confirmed that Henrikh Mkhitaryan will not recover from a knee injury in time to feature in the first leg of the Europa League semi-final against Atletico Madrid with Mesut Ozil also a potential doubt. Mkhitaryan returned to light training on his own this week and, as Standard Sport reported yesterday, is recovering well from an injury that had led to initial fears he might miss the remainder of the season. The first-leg had always seemed too soon for the Armenian playmaker, who has not featured since limping out of the second leg of quarter-final against CSKA Moscow and Wenger has indeed confirmed that Mkhitaryan will not recover in time.

  • Deaf and partially blind dog stays with toddler for 15 hours after she gets lost in Australian bush
    News
    Evening Standard

    Deaf and partially blind dog stays with toddler for 15 hours after she gets lost in Australian bush

    An elderly family dog stayed by the side of a three-year-old girl after she got lost in the Australian bush for more than 15 hours. Loyal Max, who is 17 years old, deaf and partially blind, led police to toddler Aurora after she wandered off into Queensland's Southern Downs, ABC News reported. Queensland Police tweeted: “SUCH A GOOD BOY, MAX! He stayed with his 3-year-old human who was lost near Warwick last night while we frantically searched for her.

  • Origami-inspired skyscraper which can be folded and flown into disaster zones wins architecture competition
    News
    The Independent

    Origami-inspired skyscraper which can be folded and flown into disaster zones wins architecture competition

    An origami inspired skyscraper design which can be dropped into disaster zones to provide temporary shelter has won a competition. Skyshelter.zip is a foldable structure which can be neatly packaged into a box and carried to disaster zones by helicopter. Once there, the skyscraper can be anchored to the ground even on unstable soil and almost instantly inflated by a large helium balloon inside.

  • News
    Business Insider UK

    Mexico's Pena Nieto optimistic on NAFTA overhaul talks

    BERLIN (AP) — Mexico's president has said at a trade fair in Germany that he's optimistic about reaching a deal to overhaul the North American Free Trade Agreement.

  • Police join beekeepers in battle against swarms buzzing into town
    News
    The Telegraph

    Police join beekeepers in battle against swarms buzzing into town

    Police join beekeepers in battle against swarms buzzing into town

  • Hero Firefighters Who Tackled The Grenfell Blaze Have Completed The London Marathon
    News
    HuffPost UK

    Hero Firefighters Who Tackled The Grenfell Blaze Have Completed The London Marathon

    Two crews of firefighters who tackled the Grenfell Tower blaze have finished

By using Yahoo you agree that Yahoo and partners may use Cookies for personalisation and other purposes