Keir Starmer criticised by Labour left-wingers for backing tax rises on low-paid

Jon Stone
·3-min read

Keir Starmer is facing criticism from Labour's left wing for supporting the government's planned income tax hike for lower-paid workers – fresh from taking a stand opposing rises on corporate profits.

Chancellor Rishi Sunak announced on Wednesday that he would freeze the tax-free personal allowance at £12,570 from next year until 2026, along with the threshold for the higher rate.

The move, described by the Institute for Fiscal Studies as "the least progressive way of raising income tax", amounts to a tax rise on lower-paid workers because the allowance would normally be uprated by inflation.

Labour's front bench on Wednesday night indicated it supported the measure "in principle" – but the stance drew criticism from some in the party who said the leadership was giving the impression it had the wrong priorities.

A spokesperson for left-wing campaign group Momentum said Labour should be fighting "for a redistribution of wealth and power away from the elite and towards ordinary people".

They added: "That means borrowing to invest and supporting increases in the rates of tax paid by both profitable corporations and the mega-rich. Our party has to be crystal clear about who's side we're on - and equally, who's side we're not on. Key workers need a pay rise, not a tax rise.

"Any changes to the tax system must shift the burden upwards, onto those who can afford to pay, and leave working people better off overall."

The party's front bench spent the last week insisting that corporation tax should not go up immediately, and that to raise it would be a form of austerity – though it ultimately backed the government's decision to bring in a rise later by 2023.

Commenting on the approach, Matt Zarb-Cousin, a former spokesperson for Jeremy Corbyn, said: "So now we support taxing nurses and other key workers more following a pandemic, having just resisted increasing tax for the corporations who have done well out of the pandemic. The optics are s***, the politics is s***, the values are s***. A hat-trick of utter s***."

In 2017 and 2019 Labour pledged headline corporation tax rises roughly of the magnitude introduced by Mr Sunak. But the party explicitly opposed tax rises on the bottom 95 per cent of workers, saying only that it would increase income tax for those earning more than £80,000 – the top 5 per cent of salaries.

The opposition's response to Wednesday's budget criticised the government for some of the tax rises confirmed by Mr Sunak, notably his ending of the freeze on council tax, which the opposition says will hit families hard.

But shadow chancellor Anneliese Dodds indicated that the party would support the four-year freeze on income tax thresholds, stating: “In principle we are not against the freeze.”

Asked on Thursday about Labour backing parts of the budget that would hit lower earners with tax changes, Keir Starmer told reporters:

"We've been critical of the government's budget, and the impact on those on lower incomes and you could see it in a number of different areas.

"There's the council tax hike that's coming, that'll hit families across the country. Universal Credit coming to an end in six months, six million families will lose £1,000 a year as a result of that.

"So we're very concerned; and of course a pay freeze for key workers, including all the staff in this hospital that I've just been talking to, so this budget is hitting those lower incomes, very very hard."

Read More

Budget 2021 tax changes: What it means for you

Freezing personal tax thresholds to increase income tax is a stealth tax, whatever Rishi Sunak says

Rishi Sunak to reverse George Osborne corporation tax cuts and raise rate to 25%

Is Labour’s opposition to corporation tax rises indefensible?