Advertisement

Labour unanimously wins Opposition vote to pause universal credit roll-out 299-0 as Tories abstain

Labour has unanimously won an Opposition motion vote calling for a pause in the introduction of universal credit – but Theresa May said she will not delay the roll-out.

Tory MPs were ordered to abstain from the Commons vote on the flagship benefits reform, which was called by Labour as an Opposition Day debate. It was passed by 299 votes to 0 on Wednesday evening.

Just hours before the vote, the PM was facing a revolt by Tory MPs and a concession was made as ministers announced the scrapping of controversial charges of up to 55p a minute to call a UC helpline.

Opposition Day motions are not binding on the Government. Only one Tory rebel, former GP Sarah Wollaston, voted with Labour.

MPs also abstained when facing probable defeat on similar Labour motions on NHS pay and university tuition fees in September.

Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn speaks during PMQs on Wednesday. (PA)
Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn speaks during PMQs on Wednesday. (PA)

But Commons Speaker John Bercow said the Tories could not "suddenly say we didn't lose" after Labour's 299-0 victory just because they did not take part.

The result is a fresh sign of the minority Government's vulnerability to protests from a relatively small number of MPs and its tactics caused disquiet among so-called "constitutional Tories".

Shortly after the vote, the editor of BBC Newsnight announced work and pensions secretary David Gauke had pulled out of a programmeinterview on UC.

Ian Katz tweeted: "Work + Pensions secretary David Gauke pulled frm £newsnight 2.5 hrs before scheduled interview on universal credit...'circumstances changed'."

Work and Pensions secretary David Gauke today announced that charges of up to 55pm a minute for calls to a UC helpline will be scrapped. (PA)
Work and Pensions secretary David Gauke today announced that charges of up to 55pm a minute for calls to a UC helpline will be scrapped. (PA)

Sir Edward Leigh questioned the point of the Commons if it merely expresses opinions "for the sake of it".

He said he had trooped through the lobbies to vote on hundreds of divisions on Wednesdays over 34 years as an MP, and that he was "under the impression that it served some purpose".

"And what worries me is that surely there is some sort of precedent here," he told MPs after the vote.

"This is not and should not be a university debating society, what is the point of the House of Commons if we just express opinions for the sake of it and surely when we vote it should have some effect?"

A senior Labour source had earlier described the tactic as "a sign of the paralysis and failure of the Government" after it emerged that Tory MP Douglas Ross would not even be present because he was due to run the line as assistant referee in a Champions League football match in Barcelona.

Several Tory MPs used the opposition day debate to highlight UC's problems such as claimants having to wait six weeks for payments, which has been linked to rent arrears and other debts.

But only the respected Commons Health Committee chairwoman Sarah Wollaston voted with Labour after warning ministers they need to address the "fundamental flaw" of the six-week wait.

Heidi Allen, who was among a group of potential rebels invited to Downing Street for talks with the Prime Minister on Tuesday, suggested introducing fortnightly payments and sending housing payments straight to landlords.

The backbencher said she was disappointed the Government did not pause the roll-out while some of the issues were resolved but said it was "too ambitious to expect a response just yet".

He colleague Peter Aldous said ministers must be "pragmatic and not dogmatic" while Stephen Kerr suggested the Government should "reflect" on the six-week wait for first payments.

Earlier, Mrs May clashed with Jeremy Corbyn over the issue at Prime Minister's Questions.

The Labour leader, who highlighted the helpline charges in the Commons last week, called for a delay to the roll-out of UC telling the PM: "The fundamental problems of Universal Credit remain. The six-week wait, rising indebtedness, rent arrears and evictions."

But Mrs May replied: "It is a simpler system. It is a system that encourages people to get into the workplace. It is a system that is working because more people are getting into work."

Additional reporting by Press Association.