Man acquitted of raping female colleague because she did not scream

Charlotte England
Justice Minister Andrea Orlando (right) has asked for an investigation into the case: AFP/Getty Images

A man has been acquitted of rape in an Italian court because the woman did not scream.

"There was no crying, no screaming," Judge Diamante Minucci told the victim, at the court in Turin, northern Italy. "You didn't push him away. We have to ask why?"

He then freed the 46-year-old alleged attacker.

The court heard that the woman had said "enough" to the man according to the Daily Mail. But the court ruled that this was "too weak a reaction" to prove that she did not consent to the advances of her former colleague, who was accused of raping her on a hosptial bed.


Lawyers representing the alleged victim insisted the woman's silence was because of the "painful situation" she was in and did not prove she consented to sex.

Italy's justice ministe, Andrea Orlando, has asked officials to look into the case, which concluded last month, according to Italian news agency, ANSA.


Centre-right Forza Italia opposition lawmaker Annagrazia Calabria decried the ruling.

She said: “Certainly, you cannot punish the personal reaction of a woman terrified by what is happening to her.”

The ruling has also sparked an outcry among women's groups.

  • News
    Sky News

    Clocks going back 'led to Gaia Pope arrests'

    The changing of the clocks led to a pensioner, her son and grandson being arrested for the murder of teenager Gaia Pope, it has been alleged. Rosemary Dinch, 71, Paul Elsey, 49, and Nathan Elsey, 19, were held by police after Miss Pope, 19, from Swanage, Dorset, went missing on 7 November. Mrs Dinch and her grandson Nathan were arrested six days after Miss Pope vanished, and were released under investigation the next day.

  • News
    Sky News

    David Cassidy, 1970s teen idol and The Partridge Family star, dies

    David Cassidy, whose role in the 1970s show The Partridge Family earned him teen heart-throb status, has died aged 67. A statement by the actor and singer's family said: "David died surrounded by those he loved, with joy in his heart and free from the pain that had gripped him for so long. Cassidy was rushed to a hospital in Florida last week, with his publicist saying at the weekend that he was suffering organ failure.

  • News
    Sky News

    The Likely Lads star Rodney Bewes dies aged 79

    Actor Rodney Bewes, best known for his role as Bob Ferris in The Likely Lads, has died aged 79. Bewes starred alongside James Bolam in The Likely Lads - together the pair played two working class friends who worked in the same Newcastle factory. In 1973, Bewes and Bolam reprised their roles for the show's sequel, Whatever Happened to the Likely Lads, starring alongside Brigit Forsyth and Sheila Fearn.

  • Britain to detail Brexit bill when EU agrees to move talks forward
    News
    Reuters

    Britain to detail Brexit bill when EU agrees to move talks forward

    LONDON/BRUSSELS (Reuters) - Prime Minister Theresa May will only detail how big a divorce settlement Britain is willing to pay the EU when the bloc gives a commitment to moving talks forward, according to a plan rubber-stamped by even her most pro-Brexit ministers. In Brussels, British media speculation that May has won the backing of Brexit hardliners to offer more cash prompted talk among EU diplomats that a deal to unblock talks on future trade relations could be in the making ahead of a crunch Brussels summit in three weeks. At a meeting on Monday, May's Brexit committee - made up of some of her top ministers - backed the long-held strategy that Britain would honour commitments made when it was a member of the European Union.

  • Russia finds 1,000-times normal level of radioactive isotope after nuclear incident claims
    News
    Reuters

    Russia finds 1,000-times normal level of radioactive isotope after nuclear incident claims

    Russia’s meteorological service said on Tuesday it had measured pollution of a radioactive isotope at nearly 1,000 times normal levels in the Ural mountains, the first official Russian data supporting reports that a nuclear incident had taken place. The data appears to back up a report by the French nuclear safety institute IRSN, which said on Nov. 9 a cloud of radioactive pollution over Europe had indicated some kind of leak had taken place at a nuclear facility either in Russia or Kazakhstan in the last week of September. Neither Russia nor Kazakhstan has acknowledged any accident.

  • Elite Royal Navy rescue team sent as possible calls detected from missing Argentine submarine
    News
    The Telegraph

    Elite Royal Navy rescue team sent as possible calls detected from missing Argentine submarine

    Elite Royal Navy rescue team sent as possible calls detected from missing Argentine submarine

  • FTSE gets sterling boost, land purchase threat dents housebuilders
    News
    Reuters

    FTSE gets sterling boost, land purchase threat dents housebuilders

    Britain's top share index touched a session high as chancellor Philip Hammond delivered his budget statement on Wednesday, boosted by a dip in sterling as Brexit-bound Britain slashed economic growth forecasts. Housebuilding stocks swung sharply, losing ground after Hammond announced a review of unused planning permissions, though a stamp duty exemption to spur house buying offered some support to the sector. The FTSE 100 ended the session just 0.1 percent higher at 7,419.02 points as sterling recovered and headed higher, though the blue chip index still outperformed a negative European market.

  • 'Ethical' John Lewis should pull its Mail ads, says 'anti hate' group
    News
    The Guardian

    'Ethical' John Lewis should pull its Mail ads, says 'anti hate' group

    The original John Lewis Christmas advert for 2016 featuring Buster. The campaign group that encouraged Paperchase to apologise for its marketing activities with the Daily Mail is pushing for John Lewis, the department store chain, to stop advertising with the newspaper as well as with the Sun and Daily Express. John Lewis has become a prime target for Stop Funding Hate on the back of the launch of its Christmas advert and as retailers increase their spending on advertising as the festive season approaches.

  • News
    Sky News

    US Navy C-2 aircraft carrying 11 crashes into Pacific

    A US Navy aircraft carrying 11 crew and passengers has crashed into the Pacific Ocean, the US 7th Fleet said. A search and rescue operation has found eight of those who were on board the C-2 "Greyhound" transport aircraft, "in good condition" the US Navy said. The US Navy confirmed it had taken the eight to the carrier for medical evaluation and was continuing to search for the other three.

  • News
    Sky News

    Britain's most notorious prisoner Charles Bronson refused parole

    Notorious prisoner Charles Bronson has been refused parole - consigning him to at least another two years behind bars. The 64-year-old, serving a life sentence for robbery and kidnap at Wakefield Prison in West Yorkshire, will have to wait until 2019 for another review of his case after the Parole Board recommended that he not be released. Bronson, who was born Michael Peterson but is now called Charles Salvador after changing his name by deed poll in tribute to artist Salvador Dali, has earned public notoriety because of a history of violence both in and out of jail - including an attack on a prison governor in 2014.

  • Zimbabwe's Mnangagwa to be sworn in as president on Friday
    News
    Reuters

    Zimbabwe's Mnangagwa to be sworn in as president on Friday

    Zimbabwe's former vice president Emmerson Mnangagwa will be sworn in as president on Friday, marking a new era for the country ruled by Robert Mugabe from independence nearly four decades ago until his swift downfall this week. The ruling ZANU-PF party has nominated Mnangagwa to fill the vacancy left by Mugabe on Tuesday and he will be sworn in on Friday, said Jacob Mudenda, the speaker of parliament. Mnangagwa fled for his own safety and the military seized control, shattering Mugabe's authority.

  • U.S. Representative Conyers denies harassment allegation
    News
    Business Insider UK

    U.S. Representative Conyers denies harassment allegation

    U.S. Representative John Conyers on Tuesday acknowledged that there had been a harassment allegation against him but said he denied it and resolved the matter with a payment but no admission of guilt. Conyers issued a statement after a BuzzFeed News report cited allegations from former staffers that he made sexual advances to female staff. The Democratic congressman did not give details of any allegation but said he would fully cooperate in any House investigation.

  • See the Stranger Things cast before they were famous
    Digital Spy

    See the Stranger Things cast before they were famous

    It might seem like the entire cast of Stranger Things came out of absolutely nowhere, but each now-iconic actor had actually been in other projects before their star-making turns on the Netflix show. We've gathered some of the most surprising. From Digital Spy

  • News
    Business Insider UK

    Witness: Men accused of bribes negotiated sale to Qataris

    A sports marketing company whose owners have been charged with bribing top soccer officials tried to negotiate a sale to an entity associated with Paris Saint-Germain team president Nasser Al-Khelaifi, a witness testified Tuesday in federal court. Santiago Pena, a former executive of the Argentina-based Full Play Group, testified that he spent a lengthy period of time on secret negotiations called the "New York project," given the name because the deal for 51 percent of Full Play was valued at $212 million — 212 is a New York City telephone area code. Pena said the talks with Al-Khelaifi and the sovereign wealth fund Qatar Sports Investments ended on May 27, 2015, when U.S. prosecutors unsealed indictments against Full Play's controlling principals, the father and son Hugo and Mariano Jinkis, for racketeering conspiracy, wire fraud conspiracy and money laundering conspiracy.

  • Suicidal children abandoned by NHS, Commissioner tells Parliament
    News
    The Telegraph

    Suicidal children abandoned by NHS, Commissioner tells Parliament

    Suicidal children abandoned by NHS, Commissioner tells Parliament

  • News
    Business Insider UK

    Vatican beefs up oversight of diplomats after 2 sex probes

    Pope Francis has beefed up the Vatican's oversight of its diplomatic corps after two recent cases of alleged sexual misconduct and other instances of its ambassadors going off-message from the pope. The Vatican said Tuesday that Francis had created a new section in the secretariat of state to coordinate the selection, training and service of its diplomats. It said the change will enable the head of the diplomatic office to make more frequent visits to embassies and better coordinate with the Vatican's secretary of state, and its interior and foreign ministers.

  • Jeremy Corbyn's furious response to Philip Hammond's Budget
    Press Association video

    Jeremy Corbyn's furious response to Philip Hammond's Budget

    Jeremy Corbyn predicted Philip Hammond's Budget will unravel within days, warning "misery" will continue for people across the country. The Labour leader also reacted furiously after he was heckled while speaking about elderly care.

  • News
    Business Insider UK

    BRIEF-HPE reports Q4 EPS $0.31

    Nov 21 (Reuters) - Hewlett Packard Enterprise Co

  • What Happened to Aretha Franklin? Rep Speaks Out Amid Erroneous Death Rumors
    News
    Newsweek

    What Happened to Aretha Franklin? Rep Speaks Out Amid Erroneous Death Rumors

    Legendary singer Aretha Franklin did not die, nor does she have pancreatic cancer. The “Respect” singer’s name became a top-trending Twitter top on Tuesday, which usually means one of two things when it concerns a person of a certain age: She’s dead, or it’s a death hoax. TV host Shaun Robinson, who serves as a rep for Franklin, put the rumors to rest.

  • Breitbart Editor Alex Marlow Says the Word ‘Rape’ Has Lost Meaning During #MeToo Campaign
    News
    Newsweek

    Breitbart Editor Alex Marlow Says the Word ‘Rape’ Has Lost Meaning During #MeToo Campaign

    Alex Marlow complained on Breitbart’s daily SiriusXM show that rape used to have a much more “narrow definition,” and he said the word has lost its meaning in the midst of the #MeToo campaign. Breitbart CEO Steve Bannon, who was President Trump’s former strategist. Breitbart has come under fire lately for defending Roy Moore, the former Alabama chief justice whose Senate campaign has been marred by sexual misconduct allegations from nine women, some of whom claimed Moore harassed them when they were teenagers.

  • Walmart is unleashing a key weapon against Amazon in 500 stores (WMT)
    News
    Business Insider UK

    Walmart is unleashing a key weapon against Amazon in 500 stores (WMT)

    The company just revealed that it's planning to add the kiosks, which Walmart calls pickup towers, to at least 500 stores. The last time we reviewed Walmart's in-store pickup service for online orders, we were underwhelmed. A couple of days later, we got an email from Walmart saying our order was ready.

  • Oxford graduate sues university for £1million because he did not get a first class degree 
    News
    The Telegraph

    Oxford graduate sues university for £1million because he did not get a first class degree 

    Oxford graduate sues university for £1million because he did not get a first class degree 

  • Judges under 'intolerable pressure' from social media, says new Lord Chief Justice
    News
    The Telegraph

    Judges under 'intolerable pressure' from social media, says new Lord Chief Justice

    Judges under 'intolerable pressure' from social media, says new Lord Chief Justice

  • Former NBA star Ray Allen tells court he was a victim of 'catfishing' by man who claims he was being stalked
    News
    Business Insider UK

    Former NBA star Ray Allen tells court he was a victim of 'catfishing' by man who claims he was being stalked

    Bryant Coleman told the Orlando court he was being stalked by Ray Allen. ORLANDO, Fla. (AP) — Retired NBA star Ray Allen said he is a victim of "catfishing," and has asked a court to throw out a case where he is accused of stalking someone he met online. Allen filed an emergency motion in Orange County, Florida, on Tuesday, one day after Bryant Coleman told the court he is being stalked by the 10-time All-Star and two-time NBA champion.

  • Why Are These Ikea Dressers Killing Children?
    News
    Newsweek

    Why Are These Ikea Dressers Killing Children?

    A two-year-old boy died after an Ikea dresser fell on him in May 2017—the eighth child killed by these dressers. The recall, reannounced Tuesday, covers 17.3 million dressers sold in the United States between 2002 and 2016. A previous recall in June 2016 also included dressers sold in Canada.

By using Yahoo you agree that Yahoo and partners may use Cookies for personalisation and other purposes