Matt Hancock accused of ‘passing the buck’ to local councils over care homes row

·3-min read
Health Secretary Matt Hancock giving evidence to the Science and Health Committees (House of Commons/PA) (PA Wire)
Health Secretary Matt Hancock giving evidence to the Science and Health Committees (House of Commons/PA) (PA Wire)

Matt Hancock was today accused of trying to “pass the buck” to local councils after he told MPs he did not have a list of care homes at the start of the pandemic.

The Health Secretary faced a grilling from MPs yesterday in which he defended the Government’s attempts to protect care homes at the start of the pandemic.

He said the Government “tried to” put a protective ring around care homes but claimed he had “extremely limited” powers at the start of pandemic and his department did not have a list elderly care homes.

Critcis pointed out that the regulator Care Quality Commission has a publicly available directory on its website that lists all the care homes in England and allows people to search all facilities that cater just for the elderly. Local authorities also have lists.

Charlie Williams from Covid 19 Bereaved Families For Justice said it was “hard to comprehend” why they could not access a list, adding: “The handling of the pandemic seems to be marked by a lack of communication between departments, policy makers and sector leaders.”

Shadow communities and local government secretary Steve Reed said it was an “astonishing” admission from the Health Secretary who should have had the information “at his fingertips”.

He added: “Yet again Matt Hancock is attempting to pass the buck to councils and government officials in order to deflect from his own failure to protect care home residents.”

The huge death toll in care homes during the first wave has emerged as one of the key mistakes the public inquiry will look at.

Mr Hancock told MPs yesterday: “I am Secretary of State for Health and Social Care. Yet at the start of this pandemic, the powers I had over social care were extremely limited.

“The formal powers rest with local government and formally social care is the responsibility of local government, but I feel it keenly.

“We didn’t have the data. When I first asked for a list of all of the elderly care homes - we didn’t have one. Which I find totally extraordinary saying – but it’s true.

“We simply didn’t have the levers and we had to invent a whole series of them. We now have far better data.”

The Health Secretary also said the deaths in care homes “weighs heavily on me and always will”.

He also said a decision not to prioritise tests for patients being discharged into care homes was partly taken on advice that testing people without symptoms would produce false negatives.

It comes after the Prime Minister’s former senior aide Dominic Cummings said claims the Government put a protective shield around care homes at the start of the pandemic were “complete nonsense”.

A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said an “accurate list” of all care homes was “not readily available” at the start of the pandemic. They said it is largely the responsibility of providers to inform the CQC of any changes so their list “may not be up-to-date”.

They added: “We have learned lessons through COVID-19 and taken action to work much more closely with the CQC, local authorities, NHS England and providers to improve the available data on adult social care.”

They did not directly answer how long it took to compile a list or why the Government did not have one in the first place.

During his evidence the Health Secretary stressed they put in funding and made sure PPE was “as available as possible” by building a distribution system. He said they set out their first guidance for care homes on February 25, weekly staff testing in July and most recently made care homes a “top priority” for vaccinations.

Asked why the Government did not have a list of care homes, a spokesman for the Prime Minister said: “This was an issue that the Health Secretary discussed in front of the House yesterday. All I can say is that throughout the pandemic we’ve done everything possible to try and protect care home residents and staff.”

Read More

Cummings evidence release could breach code of conduct, No 10 suggests

Vaccines minister admits Pfizer supplies tight, but UK on track for jab target

Portugal holiday prices plunge after removal from green list