Monsanto found liable for California man's cancer and ordered to pay $80m in damages

Sam Levin in San Francisco


A federal jury ruled that Monsanto was liable for a California man’s cancer and ordered the Roundup manufacturer to pay $80m in damages.

The ruling on Wednesday, which holds the company responsible for the cancer risks of its popular weedkiller, is the first of its kind in US federal court and a major blow to Monsanto and its parent company, Bayer. A spokesperson said Bayer would appeal.

In a verdict during an earlier phase of the trial, the jury in San Francisco unanimously ruled that the herbicide was a “substantial factor” in causing the cancer of Edwin Hardeman.

Edwin Hardeman, right, stands with attorney Aimee Wagstaff.

Edwin Hardeman, right, stands with attorney Aimee Wagstaff. Photograph: Jeff Chiu/AP

Hardeman, a 70-year-old Santa Rosa man, was the first person to challenge Monsanto’s herbicide in a federal trial, alleging that his exposure to the glyphosate weedkiller caused him to develop non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma (NHL), a cancer that affects the immune system.

The case has attracted international attention and raised new questions about the potential health hazards of Roundup. It also challenged the conduct of Monsanto, now owned by the German pharmaceutical company Bayer. The corporation is facing more than 9,000 similar lawsuits across the US that allege Roundup has caused cancer.

The jury ruled that Roundup’s design was “defective”, that the product lacked sufficient cancer warnings, and that Monsanto was negligent in its failure to warn Hardeman of the NHL risk. The jurors ordered the company to pay Hardeman $75m in punitive damages, $200,000 for past economic losses and $5.6m in non-economic losses.

Related: Monsanto: Roundup substantial factor in man’s cancer, jury finds in key verdict

“As demonstrated throughout trial, since Roundup’s inception over 40 years ago, Monsanto refuses to act responsibly,” Hardeman’s lawyers said in a statement. “It is clear from Monsanto’s actions that it does not care whether Roundup causes cancer, focusing instead on manipulating public opinion and undermining anyone who raises genuine and legitimate concerns about Roundup.”

Hardeman’s case is considered a “bellwether” trial in the federal court system, meaning the verdict could have an impact on how future litigation and potential settlements are resolved. In a historic verdict last year, a state jury ruled that Roundup caused the terminal cancer of Dewayne Johnson, a former school groundskeeper, and that Monsanto had “acted with malice or oppression” and owed the plaintiff $289m in damages.

The second phase of Hardeman’s trial focused on allegations that Monsanto for years worked behind the scenes to control research, sway regulators and shape public opinion about the safety of its product. The case built on the Johnson trial, which alleged that Monsanto “bullied” scientists, fought to suppress damning research about Roundup and helped “ghostwrite” studies that encouraged continued usage.

Aimee Wagstaff, Hardeman’s lawyer, told the jury that Monsanto had a “cozy relationship” with Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) employees and had also paid “prestigious” scientists to author “favorable” studies: “Monsanto has influenced and manipulated the science through its relationships with regulatory officials and through ghostwriting.”

Hardeman testified that he had sprayed the herbicide for nearly three decades and at one time got it on his skin, before he was diagnosed with cancer. He used the chemical to control weeds and poison oak on his properties, starting in 1986. He also said in court he would not have used the product if it had come with a cancer warning.

Related: 'The world is against them': new era of cancer lawsuits threaten Monsanto

Bayer has continued to argue that Roundup is safe to use, doesn’t cause cancer and does not require a label warning. The corporation’s attorney, Brian Stekloff, told the jury prior to the verdict that their decision should not be a “popularity contest” about the company: “Monsanto, consistent with the science, consistent with how the science was being viewed around the rest of the world, did act responsibly.”

The company said in a statement on Wednesday that it was “disappointed” with the decision, but said the “verdict does not change the weight of over four decades of extensive science and the conclusions of regulators worldwide that support the safety of our glyphosate-based herbicides and that they are not carcinogenic”.

In 2015, the World Health Organization’s international agency for research on cancer (IARC) ruled that glyphosate was “probably carcinogenic to humans”, based on a review of existing research. The EPA, however, has deemed glyphosate safe for use.

Hardeman’s legal team said the unanimous ruling made a strong statement about the company’s behavior over the years: “Today, the jury resoundingly held Monsanto accountable for its 40 years of corporate malfeasance and sent a message to Monsanto that it needs to change the way it does business.”


  • FGM: Egyptian father charged over ‘tricking daughters to believe procedure would be coronavirus vaccine’
    News
    Evening Standard

    FGM: Egyptian father charged over ‘tricking daughters to believe procedure would be coronavirus vaccine’

    Egyptian authorities are to prosecute a father who allegedly tricked his three daughters into undergoing female genital mutilation by pretending they were to receive a coronavirus vaccine.The girls say their father told them a doctor was coming to vaccinate them against Covid-19, according to the Thomson Reuters Foundation reporting from Cairo.

  • Duchess of Sussex's lawyers withdraw claims of 'harassment and humiliation' against Mail on Sunday
    News
    The Telegraph

    Duchess of Sussex's lawyers withdraw claims of 'harassment and humiliation' against Mail on Sunday

    The Duchess of Sussex’s lawyers have withdrawn accusations that the Mail on Sunday harassed, humiliated, exposed and manipulated ‘fragile’ Thomas Markle as they resubmit their court claim minus 357 words. The Duchess’s legal team has filed an amended version of their case against the newspaper, following a strike-out hearing in May. She is suing Associated Newspapers over the publication of parts of the handwritten letter to her father, which she claims breached her privacy, along with copyright and data protection laws. Her representatives had argued they should be allowed to build a picture of the newspaper’s “bad faith” and “obvious agenda of publishing intrusive or offensive stories” about her. Mr Justice Warby struck out those claims in a written judgement last month, saying they were irrelevant in law, presented to the court inadequately, or were disproportionate to investigate. The Duchess’s team has now resubmitted paperwork deleting paragraphs of the original claim as required by the court. Retracted allegations include that the Mail on Sunday ”harassed and humiliated” and “deliberately manipulated and exploited a vulnerable and fragile individual” in the form of Mr Markle, the Duchess’s father, It also deleted a claim that the newspaper had “already published articles containing false or misleading information” about Frogmore Cottage and its funding. The Mail on Sunday has consistently denied the allegations. No date has been set for the full trial yet.

  • Major setback as shock analysis shows coronavirus transmission levels rising in England
    Health
    Evening Standard

    Major setback as shock analysis shows coronavirus transmission levels rising in England

    England's battle against coronavirus appears to have suffered a major setback in recent days as transmission levels rise probably due to more travelling and mixing between households, a shock analysis warned today.The research by a Cambridge University/Public Health England joint modelling team suggested the disease may now be spreading very slightly in the North West, is at a stand-still level in the South West, and is declining in other regions, but far more slowly in London than previously.

  • UK Coronavirus Deaths Top 40,000 As 357 More Fatalities Confirmed
    News
    HuffPost UK

    UK Coronavirus Deaths Top 40,000 As 357 More Fatalities Confirmed

    But government figures have lagged behind estimates from the UK's statistics authorities, which put the total past 50,000

  • Vitamin K could help fight coronavirus, study suggests
    Health
    The Guardian

    Vitamin K could help fight coronavirus, study suggests

    Vitamin K could help fight coronavirus, study suggests. Scientists in Netherlands explore possible link between deficiency and Covid-19 deaths

  • Norwegian Princess reveals she and her black boyfriend had death threats over their relationship
    Celebrity
    Yahoo News UK

    Norwegian Princess reveals she and her black boyfriend had death threats over their relationship

    Princess Martha Louise says she and her boyfriend have been threatened over their relationship.

  • Fewer than one in 1,000 now infected with coronavirus in England each day
    Health
    The Telegraph

    Fewer than one in 1,000 now infected with coronavirus in England each day

    Coronavirus infections in the community have more than halved in a week, data from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) has shown. Last week, surveillance testing by the ONS suggested there were around 133,000 people infected at any given time between May 11 and May 24, amounting to 0.24 per cent of the population. But the latest data shows that dropped to 53,000 between May 17 and May 30 – a fall of 60 per cent. The chance of catching the virus in the community is now thought to be very low, with just one in 1,000 people now testing positive on any given day. The overall reproduction 'R' number for the UK remains between 0.7 and 0.9, and between 0.7 and one for England, although there is regional variation. But Government scientists believe that figure is "artificially high" because it includes care homes and hospitals, where the chance of picking up an infection is much higher.

  • North Korea's Supreme Sister scolds 'human scum' jeopardising deal with south
    News
    RFI

    North Korea's Supreme Sister scolds 'human scum' jeopardising deal with south

    Kim Yo-jong, the sister of North Korean Supreme Leader Kim Jong-un, has called defectors “human scum” and “mongrel dogs” for flying hot air balloons carrying anti-Pyongyang propaganda across the border from the South. She has threatened to cancel a military deal with Seoul.South Korea may ban defectors from flying anti-Pyongyang leaflets into the North, officials said on Thursday, hours after leader Kim Jong-un's sister threatened to scrap a military agreement with Seoul.Kim Yo-jong, the influential younger sister and key adviser to the leader, issued the warning at a time when inter-Korean ties are in the deep freeze, despite three summits in 2018 between her brother and southern president Moon Jae-in, who has consistently been favorable to closer engagement with Pyongyang.But North Korean defectors and other activists have long flown balloons across the border carrying leaflets that criticise Kim over human rights abuses and his nuclear ambitions.The Supreme Sister does not approve.“On 31 May I heard a report that so-called ‘defectors from the North’ scattered hundreds of thousands of anti-Democratic People's Republic of Korea leaflets into the areas on our side of the frontline areas,” she writes in a statement published by the state-run Korean Central News Agency (KCNA).“What matters is that those human scum hardly worth their value as human beings had the temerity of faulting our supreme leadership and citing ‘nuclear issue’,” she fumes, referring to initiatives by her brother and South Korea’s leader to ease tensions on the peninsula.“Riff-raff” and “mongrel dogs”“I wonder if the world knows what kind of riff-raff those foolish 'defectors from the north' are,” she asks.“It is the height of irony. Those fools who are almost illiterate wanted to talk about the 'nuclear issue' though they know no concept about it. This is like ‘a shop-boy near a temple chanting a sutra untaught’,” she says, referring to attempts by US President Donald Trump, Seoul and Kim Jong-un to scale down Pyongyang’s nuclear program in exchange for the US removing its nuclear arsenal from the region. Apart from being “human scum little short of wild animals who betrayed their own homeland” she calls the defectors “mongrel dogs as they bark in where they should not”.And this has to come to an end, she says, asking the “south Korean authorities” if they are “ready to take the consequences” of the damage done by these “rubbish-like mongrel dogs” who “took no scruple to slander us”.There will be serious consequences if Seoul doesn’t comply, she threatens.Among those consequences: a possible cancellation of the 2000 North-South Joint declaration, which was signed by Kim Jong-un’s father Kim Jong-il and then South Korean President Kim Dae-jung, while the 2018 Panmunjon Declaration for Peace and Prosperity on the Korean Peninsula jointly signed by Kim Jong-un and South Korean President Moon Jae-in may be in danger too. Sister Kim angrily points out that this text specifically refers to ceasing “all hostile acts against each other in every domain, including … distribution of leaflets, in the areas along the Military Demarcation Line.”Complete withdrawalApart from cancelling the agreements, she also threatens the complete withdrawal of North Korea from the cross-border cooperation project at the Kaesong Industrial Park, and the closure of the north-south joint liaison office.The effect was immediate: just hours after the KCNA published Kim’s statement, Seoul's unification ministry said the government was considering legislation to ban leaflet campaigns on the grounds they caused tension at the border."Any act that could pose a threat to the life and property of the residents in the border area should be stopped," said ministry spokesman Yoh Sang-key.The leaflet campaigns have been a thorny issue between the two Koreas, but enacting such a law could spark an outcry in the South over the right to freedom of expression.An official at the South Korean presidential office said the leaflets did "more harm than good," adding the government would "respond firmly" to anything that damages national security. Yonhap news agency reported that mayors of townsin the border area had also requested the ministry to take steps and prevent defectors from flying leaflets into the North.And Kim himself?Meanwhile Supreme Leader Kim Jung-un has disappeared for the third time in two months. When he was not shown in public after inspecting an assault plane group in the west of the country on 12 April, speculation had it that he had died of heart problems in late April, but on 2 May, KCNA published a slideshow of Kim opening a fertilizer factory, looking puffy, but not unhealthy.He then disappeared again without trace for another three weeks, before being photographed chairing a session of the Military Commission on 24 May, the last time he was seen in public. This week’s sudden appearance of his sister adds fuel to speculation that she has been increasingly taking a leadership role in the country.

  • Trump news – live: Outrage over president's George Floyd comments as he says coronavirus 'gift from China'
    Politics
    The Independent

    Trump news – live: Outrage over president's George Floyd comments as he says coronavirus 'gift from China'

    Outrage quickly followed Donald Trump's comments on George Floyd during a press conference to announce 2.5m new jobs to the US economy in May, saying that he would be "looking down right now" on a great thing happening for our country.After Trump's on-going feud with former employees, ex-chief-of-staff John Kelly fired back to support Jim Mattis and say the president would either fire or push people so hard they would resign. Hundreds of former diplomatic and military officials, meanwhile, signed a letter denouncing the show of force by soldiers on civilian protesters.

  • Tommy Robinson held by police investigating ‘assault’
    News
    PA Media: UK News

    Tommy Robinson held by police investigating ‘assault’

    The allegation concerns an alleged incident in Barrow-in-Furness, Cumbria.

  • Which kind of face mask is the best protection against coronavirus?
    Health
    The Guardian

    Which kind of face mask is the best protection against coronavirus?

    Which kind of face mask is the best protection against coronavirus?. Your questions answered on what type of mask to wear to cut the risk of getting Covid-19

  • Dana White in foul-mouthed attack on ‘f****** nutbag’ Oscar De La Hoya and ‘f****** scumbag’ Bob Arum
    Sport
    The Independent

    Dana White in foul-mouthed attack on ‘f****** nutbag’ Oscar De La Hoya and ‘f****** scumbag’ Bob Arum

    Dana White has taken aim at promotion rivals Oscar De La Hoya and Bob Arum once more in an expletive-ridden rant.The UFC president reignited the war of words between the American fight promoters on Talk the Talk featuring Eddie Hearn and Tony Bellew.

  • Pharmaceutical giant begins producing vaccine ahead of trial results
    Health
    PA Media: UK News

    Pharmaceutical giant begins producing vaccine ahead of trial results

    A potential Covid-19 vaccine is being developed at Oxford University and results of trials could be announced in August.

  • The Hyperpigmentation Products I Swear By For Dark Skin - All at Sephora
    Style
    Pop Sugar UK Beauty

    The Hyperpigmentation Products I Swear By For Dark Skin - All at Sephora

    Hyperpigmentation is the proper name for the splotchy dark spots I've been blessed with all my life (and I won't share the not-so-holy name I call them in private). Even if I haven't picked my pimples, I still get dots on my face after they settle down and, hell, even the area on my nose where my glasses rest has turned noticeably darker in the past. This is actually very common for people of color and happens because of an increase in melanin production, which then results in visible darkness in the affected area. Sure, I can cover the little spots and larger patches with concealers, but I'd rather have something that isn't just hiding the problem spots until I wash my face again.I'm hyper-cautious of products that promise to fade dark spots - which immediately makes me fear skin lightening - and always do a smaller spot test before slathering anything on my face (and would recommend this for any product, especially if you're sensitive). I've tried dozens of treatments over the years and culled this group of skin saviors that have evened out my complexion, no matter how big (or small) the danger zone is. The most important thing I've learned is that most of these items take time to work and must be applied regularly. There have been some that I dismissed after a week or two because I didn't see a change . . . to then only see amazing results when used consistently for more than a month. Ahead are nine top products from Sephora to treat hyperpigmentation, acne scarring, and other dark spots on darker skin.

  • 'Revolting': Trump condemned for saying George Floyd is praising US economy
    Politics
    The Guardian

    'Revolting': Trump condemned for saying George Floyd is praising US economy

    'Revolting': Trump condemned for saying George Floyd is praising US economyPresident made the comments after better-than-expected jobs report showed national unemployment rate falling

  • Health Secretary announces all NHS staff will be required to wear masks
    Health
    PA Media: Video

    Health Secretary announces all NHS staff will be required to wear masks

    All hospital visitors and outpatients will be required to wear face coverings and all hospital staff will be required to wear surgical masks in England from June 15, Health Secretary Matt Hancock said.

  • Sadiq Khan says more people may have caught coronavirus due to face mask delay
    News
    Evening Standard

    Sadiq Khan says more people may have caught coronavirus due to face mask delay

    The delay in making face masks mandatory on public transport may have led to more people catching coronavirus, Sadiq Khan has said.The Mayor of London has the power to make coverings mandatory on the TfL network but said he decided not to do so before it became government policy to ensure "message clarity".

  • George Floyd death: Trainee officer charged over arrest tried to object, court told
    News
    Sky News

    George Floyd death: Trainee officer charged over arrest tried to object, court told

    One of the four former Minneapolis officers charged over George Floyd's death tried to warn his fellow officers during the arrest, a court has heard. J. Alexander Kueng hadn't yet completed his third full shift as a police officer when the deadly arrest occurred, his lawyer Tom Plunkett claimed. Mr Plunkett said Kueng allegedly told his fellow officers as they were detaining George Floyd : "You shouldn't do that."

  • Coronavirus news – live: WHO says everyone must wear face masks in public as Matt Hancock urges people not to attend George Floyd protests
    News
    The Independent

    Coronavirus news – live: WHO says everyone must wear face masks in public as Matt Hancock urges people not to attend George Floyd protests

    The World Health Organisation has updated its coronavirus guidance in response to recent research to say everyone should wear face coverings in public where there is a risk of virus transmission.The change came as Matt Hancock, the health secretary, announced all hospital visitors would have to wear face coverings from 15 June and urged the public to not attend upcoming George Floyd protests due to concerns about the potential for large gatherings to spread Covid-19.

  • Protesters Break Into Dance During Oakland George Floyd Rally
    Politics
    Storyful

    Protesters Break Into Dance During Oakland George Floyd Rally

    A group of protesters broke out in dance during a George Floyd rally in Oakland, California, on Wednesday, June 3.This video shows a large group of people doing the Cupid Shuffle outside of a Chase Bank outlet on 14th Street.Oakland City Council ended the city’s curfew order on Thursday, Mayor Libby Schaaf announced in a tweet. Credit: Ken Murphy via Storyful

  • Black Lives Matter protesters take a knee in Trafalgar Square
    News
    PA Media: Video

    Black Lives Matter protesters take a knee in Trafalgar Square

    People take part in a kneeling protest for Black Lives Matter in Trafalgar Square, London, in memory of George Floyd, who was killed on May 25 while in police custody in the US city of Minneapolis.