MPs narrowly back transport secretary Chris Grayling in vote of no confidence over timetable chaos

Benjamin Kentish
Chris Grayling has faced criticism over his handling of timetable disruption on Northern Rail and the Govia Thameslink Railway: REUTERS

Chris Grayling has survived a Commons vote of no confidence called by Labour after weeks of railway chaos.

MPs backed the beleaguered transport secretary by 305 votes to 285 – a majority of 20 - despite opposition MPs arguing he could “never recover” from the recent train timetable fiasco.

Labour tabled the no confidence motion in a bid to force Theresa May to replace Mr Grayling, who has faced criticism over railway disruption that caused chaos for thousands of passengers using Northern Rail and the Govia Thameslink Railway (GTR).

It said the transport secretary needed to “step up and shoulder the blame” for the saga.

Although the vote was not binding, Ms May would have come under fresh pressure to sack Mr Grayling had Conservatives MPs joined opposition parties in voting against him.

Speaking in the Commons, Andy McDonald, the shadow transport secretary, said he regretted having to table the motion but accused Mr Grayling of a "breach of faith and trust".

He said: "Given the totally unacceptable state of the railways, I felt I had a duty to passengers.

"I am afraid the breach of faith and trust is so great that the Secretary of State's credibility will never recover.

He added: "There comes a point where the publicly accountable politician in charge of the railways should step up and shoulder the blame.

"It seems to me, and I suspect to many rail users, that we have more than reached that."


UK news in pictures

UK news in pictures

  • 1/50 18 June 2018

    Prime Minister Theresa May finishes speaking following visiting patients at the Royal Free Hospital in London. Ms May announced a new package of £20 Billion worth of funding for the NHS.

    Getty

  • 2/50 17 June 2018

    Competitors begin the race after a rolling start during round two of the 2018 Championship, the F1H2O UIM Powerboat World Championship Grand Prix of London, at the Royal Victoria Docks.

    Getty

  • 3/50 16 June 2018

    Fire fighters attend the scene of a second fire at Glasgow's School of Art four years after part of the Charles Rennie Mackintosh designed building was destroyed by fire. The blaze spread to nearby buildings including the Campus nightclub and O2 ABC music venue

    Christopher Flyvbjerg / SWNS.com

  • 4/50 15 June 2018

    Dean of Westminster, John Hall, accompanied by first wife Jane Hawking, watches as daughter Lucy Hawking, places flowers at the site of the internment of the ashes of Stephen Hawking in the nave Westminster Abbey. The world renowned physicist and author of A Brief History of Time, died early in the morning of 14 March 2018, at the age of 76. Professor Hawking's ashes will be laid to rest close to Sir Isaac Newton and Charles Darwin.

    Getty Images

  • 5/50 14 June 2018

    British singer Robbie Williams performs during the opening ceremony of the 2018 World Cup at the Luzhniki Stadium in Moscow.

    REUTERS

  • 6/50 13 June 2018

    Prince Charles uses a power drill during a visit to the Owenkillew Community Centre in Gortin, as part of his tour of Northern Ireland.

    Getty

  • 7/50 12 June 2018

    England manager Gareth Southgate, his players and coaching staff pose for the official England squad photo ahead of traveling to the World Cup in Russia.

    The FA

  • 8/50 11 June 2018

    Play was suspended during the match between Lancashire and Essex as an Air Ambulance landed on the pitch after one of the spectators was taken ill on day three of the Specsavers County Championship, Division One match at Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester.

    PA

  • 9/50 10 June 2018

    Marchers hold up banners as they gather to mark 100 years since women won the right to vote in the UK.

    Getty

  • 10/50 9 June 2018

    The parade makes its way up The Mall from Horse Guards Parade to Buckingham Palace, central London, following the Trooping the Colour ceremony, as the Queen celebrates her official birthday.

    PA

  • 11/50 8 June 2018

    Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau meets with British Prime Minister Theresa May at the G7 Leaders Summit in La Malbaie, Quebec.

    Rex Features

  • 12/50 7 June 2018

    Brexit Secretary David Davis, right, and International Trade Secretary Liam Fox leave 10 Downing Street. Prime Minister Theresa May held an emergency Brexit cabinet meeting in an attempt to resolve tensions over the UK's Irish border plan.

    Getty

  • 13/50 6 June 2018

    Britain's Prime Minister Theresa May welcomes Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to Downing Street.

    Reuters

  • 14/50 5 June 2018

    British fashion designer and environmental campaigner, Dame Vivienne Westwood delivers an anti-fracking letter to 10 Downing Street in London.

    EPA

  • 15/50 4 June 2018

    New images issued by the Grenfell Tower Inquiry of the kitchen in flat 16 where the fire started on June 14 last year. Seventy-one people were killed after the fire tore through the housing block in Kensington.

    Grenfell Tower Inquiry/PA

  • 16/50 3 June 2018

    Bishop of Southwark Christopher Chessun and members of the public attend a commemoration service on the first anniversary of the London Bridge terror attack. Britain held a national minute of silence on June 3, one year on from the London Bridge terror attack that killed eight people and injured dozens more.

    AFP/Getty

  • 17/50 2 June 2018

    William Buick ridding Masar celebrates crossing the line and winning the Investec Derby race on Derby Day at Epsom Downs.

    Getty

  • 18/50 1 June 2018

    Traffic passes anti-Brexit signs on the County Derry/Londonderry Northern Ireland and County Donegal in the Irish Republic. Northern Ireland could be given joint EU and UK status and a 'buffer zone' on its border with the Republic, under new plans being drawn up by David Davis, according to reports.

    EPA

  • 19/50 31 May 2018

    Eleanor Crossey Malone displays an abortion pill packet after taking a pill as abortion rights campaign group ROSA, Reproductive Rights Against Oppression, Sexism and Austerity distribute abortion pills from a touring bus in Belfast, Northern Ireland. Flouting Northern Irish governmental laws which forbid the use of abortion pills the group are also protesting outside offices belonging to the main political parties in the province. Women in Northern Ireland have been prosecuted for buying abortion pills over the internet and it is illegal for a woman to have an abortion unless in special circumstances unlike the rest of the United Kingdom. The Republic of Ireland voted in favour of pro-choice last week in a referendum.

    Getty

  • 20/50 30 May 2018

    West Midlands Police officers carrying out scene searches near to where a 15-year-old boy was fatally stabbed in Wolverhampton.

    PA

  • 21/50 29 May 2018

    A view at Westminster Abbey from the medieval Triforium that is hosting an exhibition in London. The Queen's Diamond Jubilee Galleries, set more than 16 meters, (52 feet) above the Abbey floor in the medieval Triforium, will open to the public for the first time on June 11, displaying over 300 treasures from the Abbey's collection which will tell the rich thousand-year history of the institution at Westminster Abbey.

    AP

  • 22/50 28 May 2018

    People enjoy the hot weather on Bournemouth Beach during bank holiday Monday in Dorset.

    PA

  • 23/50 27 May 2018

    Chris Ashton of the Barbarians scores against England at Twickenham.

    Getty

  • 24/50 26 May 2018

    Lightning strikes over the city of London.

    Reuters

  • 25/50 25 May 2018

    Rory Mcilroy took the clubhouse lead in to round three of the BMW PGA championship at Wentworth.

    Action Images via Reuters

  • 26/50 24 May 2018

    Alastair Cook batting against Pakistan during the first test match of the summer at Lord’s cricket ground, London.

    Getty

  • 27/50 23 May 2018

    Home Secretary Sajid Javid speaking at the annual conference of the Police Federation of England and Wales at the International Convention Centre in Birmingham.

    PA

  • 28/50 22 May 2018

    Felix, two,sits next to messages and flowers left in Manchester, ahead of the Manchester Arena National Service of Commemoration at Manchester Cathedral to mark one year since the Manchester attack.

    PA

  • 29/50 21 May 2018

    Marcio and Andreia Gomes, parents of Logan Gomes, arrive for a commemoration hearing at the opening of the inquiry into the Grenfell Tower disaster, in London.

    Reuters

  • 30/50 20 May 2018

    Brackley Town celebrate after winning The Buildbase FA Trophy Final after they beat Bromley on penalties at Wembley Stadium.

    Getty

  • 31/50 19 May 2018

    Actress, Meghan Markle, reaches Prince Harry at the altar in St George's Chapel at Windsor Castle for their wedding service.

    Getty

  • 32/50 18 May 2018

    Workers from the Covent Garden branch of TGI Fridays on a picket line outside the restaurant as they strike in a dispute over pay. Members of Unite are taking action on Friday in a row over tips and payment of the minimum wage.

    PA

  • 33/50 17 May 2018

    A police officer talks to a homeless man in Windsor ahead of the wedding of Prince Harry and Meghan Markle.

    PA

  • 34/50 16 May 2018

    Wing Commander John Butcher, Commanding Officer of 617 Squadron, left, jokes with Britain's last surviving 'Dambuster', Squadron Leader George "Johnny" Johnson, during an event to mark the 75th anniversary of the 'Dambusters' raids, at RAF Coningsby. The Royal Air Force Battle of Britain Memorial Flight was hoping to fly one of the two remaining Avro Lancaster bombers over the Derwent and Ladybower reservoirs, but high winds prevented the aircraft from taking off. 2018 marks the 100th anniversary of the formation of the RAF and the 75th anniversary of the 617 Squadron Dambusters operation. The Dambuster raids, or ''peration Chastise' was an attack on German dams on 16-17 May 1943 by Royal Air Force No. 617 Squadron, using an innovative 'bouncing bomb', which skimmed on the surface of the reservoir before hitting the dam wall and exploding.

    Getty

  • 35/50 15 May 2018

    President of Turkey Recep Tayyip Erdogan speaks as British Prime Minister Theresa May listens during a press conference after their meeting at 10 Downing Street. Erdogan is in the UK for a three-day visit, which includes a closing lecture at the Tatlidil Forum in Oxford, an audience with The Queen and talks with Theresa May.

    Getty

  • 36/50 14 May 2018

    The funeral cortege of Alfie Evans goes past Everton's Goodison Park ground in Liverpool. Doctors at Alder Hey Children's Hospital in Liverpool stopped providing life-support treatment to Alfie last month after his parents, Tom Evans and Kate James, lost two rounds of fights in the High Court, Court of Appeal, Supreme Court and European Court of Human Rights.

    PA

  • 37/50 13 May 2018

    Daisy May Cooper, the winner of the Female in a Comedy award for ‘This Country’, with her Bafta.

    Getty

  • 38/50 12 May 2018

    Thousands of union members march through central London demanding a ‘new deal’ for workers, in an event organised by the Trades Union Congress (TUC).

    Rex

  • 39/50 11 May 2018

    Jeremy Corbyn with shipbuilding apprentices at the Fairfield Ship Building Museum in Govan. During a speech a he called for navy shipbuilding contracts to stay in the UK.

    Getty

  • 40/50 10 May 2018

    Dominick Chilcott, right, British ambassador in Turkey, hands over a letter of apology from the UK government to Libyan dissident Abdel Hakim Belhaj, at the British Consulate, in Istanbul. Abdel Hakim Belhaj and his wife, Fatima Boudchar, allege they were detained in southeast Asia in 2004 and sent to Libya to be interrogated by the regime of late dictator Moammar Gadhafi. Britain acknowledged Thursday that its intelligence agents played a role in the kidnapping and torture of an opponent of the late Libyan leader Moammar Gadhafi, a rare admission of wrongdoing by British spies.

    AP

  • 41/50 9 May 2018

    The coffin of former House of Commons speaker Lord Michael Martin, followed by his widow Mary, is carried from St Aloysius in Glasgow after his funeral. The former Labour MP died on Sunday April 29 after a short illness at the age of 72.

    PA

  • 42/50 8 May 2018

    Mayor of London Sadiq Khan and Labour MP Heidi Alexander. Ms Alexander is standing down from Parliament after being confirmed as London's deputy mayor for transport, replacing current deputy mayor Val Shawcross.

    GLA/PA

  • 43/50 7 May 2018

    Arsene Wenger bids farewell to Arsenal football club and the stadium he helped to build in more ways than one. It was Wenger's final home game of after 22 years in charge. Arsenal sent him off with a 5-0 victory over Burnley.

    AFP/Getty Images

  • 44/50 6 May 2018

    Manchester City celebrate with the trophy after winning the Premier League title.

    Action Images via Reuters

  • 45/50 5 May 2018

    Anti-independence supporters wave Union Jack flags as thousands of demonstrators march in support of Scottish independence through the streets of Glasgow.

    AFP/Getty

  • 46/50 4 May 2018

    Prime Minister Theresa May with her supporters during a visit to Wandsworth Town Hall, where the Conservative Party retained control of Wandsworth Council in the local elections.

    Getty

  • 47/50 3 May 2018

    Jeremy Corbyn outside a polling station in Islington after voting in the local elections.

    Rex

  • 48/50 2 May 2018

    A memorial to George Michael outside his house in Highgate, north London. George Michael's family have since asked fans to remove their tributes from outside the late singer's former homes for the sake of his neighbours.

    PA

  • 49/50 1 May 2018

    Leicester Morrismen during May Day celebrations at Bradgate Park in Newtown Linford, Leicestershire.

    Reuters

  • 50/50 30 April 2018

    Sajid Javid outside the Home Office in Westminster after he was appointed as the new Home Secretary.

    PA

The row centres on prolonged disruption following a change in timetabling. Northern and Govia had not made sufficient preparations for the change, leading to hundreds of trains each day being cancelled. The companies blamed Network Rail, saying they had not been left with enough time to implement the new timetables.

Defending his handling of the crisis, Mr Grayling accused Labour of “political point scoring”

He said: "For years the opposition have demanded that the railways are re-nationalised and run by the government and they've claimed they'd be run much better if they were.

"Now it appears they think the railways are already run by the government and if something goes wrong it's down to us.".

He added: "What doesn't help passengers is political point scoring, we've seen that today. We need to work to deliver the best outcome for passengers, we need to improve services urgently.

"That's what I'm focused on, it's what my department is focused on and it's what the government is focused on."