NFL stands apart from NBA, MLB on sports betting reaction

Daniel Roberts
Senior Writer

Two weeks after the US Supreme Court struck down the federal ban on states legalizing sports betting, attention is turning to how the four major pro sports leagues are going to handle what comes next.

The NBA, NHL, and MLB appear united in their approach. But the NFL, as is often the case on many issues, is reacting differently.

The NBA, MLB, NFL, NHL, and NCAA all opposed New Jersey’s case from the beginning (the case was originally called Chris Christie vs. NCAA et al.), not because they opposed legalized sports betting, but because they didn’t want to deal with a messy, state-by-state legal landscape. Too bad: New Jersey won its case, which means that New Jersey and other states can now move to legalize sports betting in their state.

The ruling does not mean that sports betting is now legal at the federal level, which is what the leagues would prefer: a uniform federal framework. And the leagues (led by the NBA) are still pushing forward with that separate lobbying effort. But that will likely take years to play out.

The NBA was quick to reiterate its stance in a statement after the May 14 SCOTUS ruling (bolding ours): “Today’s decision by the Supreme Court opens the door for states to pass laws legalizing sports betting. We remain in favor of a federal framework that would provide a uniform approach to sports gambling in states that choose to permit it, but we will remain active in ongoing discussions with state legislatures. Regardless of the particulars of any future sports betting law, the integrity of our game remains our highest priority.”

NBA, MLB want integrity fees

Speaking of “integrity,” the NBA and MLB have both said they will seek a 1% “integrity fee” on all legal bets placed on their games.

The concept (in particular the name choice) has been mocked by some, but others see it as an inevitable step, and a positive one because it means the players get a cut of the betting.

NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman has not specifically voiced support for integrity fees, but did tell CNBC last week that he now believes legal betting will be good for hockey. (And in light of the SCOTUS ruling, the NHL looks ahead of the curve with the Golden Knights expansion team in Las Vegas; the NFL aims to follow with the Las Vegas Raiders in 2020.) On the issue of fees, Bettman is likely to fall in line with whatever NBA Commissioner Adam Silver and MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred do. “The NHL won’t be driving the car,” says Dustin Gouker, managing editor of the website Legal Sports Report. “They’ll sit on the passenger side and generally be amenable to what the others want.”

The NFL, on the other hand, will not seek integrity fees.

According to ESPN’s Don Van Natta, speaking this week on Outside The Lines: “The NFL just doesn’t think an integrity fee, a one percent fee, is in anyone’s interest.”

A fan displays a sign welcoming the Oakland Raiders, who plan to relocate to Las Vegas (AAP)

NFL takes a different tack

Rather than demand a direct cut of the betting, the NFL appears to be focusing on getting paid for selling rights to its own data and video footage—intellectual property that legal betting operators will want to pay for in order to help them set lines and prop bets.

In fact, the NFL already began quietly making deals and partnerships three years ago with data firms that monitor betting trends, in anticipation of the likelihood of legalized betting. Now it’s focusing on such data and video in its response to the SCOTUS ruling.

NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell confirmed this approach when he broke his silence on the issue this week in a statement: “We have spent considerable time planning for the potential of broadly legalized sports gambling and are prepared to address these changes in a thoughtful and comprehensive way.” He also voiced support for “Congress to enact uniform standards for states that choose to legalize sports betting,” like the other leagues want.

“The NFL is sort of aligned with the NBA and Major League Baseball, in that they think regulation is the best way to go,” says Gouker. “The difference is in how they are going about it. The NFL doesn’t seem to be interested in getting a cut of all wagers like its counterparts are. They may see those ‘integrity fees’ as problematic both legally and from an optics standpoint.”

Indeed, no league is typically more concerned with “optics” than the NFL. Just this week, in a move that shocked many, NFL owners decided on a new policy that the league will fine teams whose players do not stand during the national anthem. It was seen by many as a capitulation to President Donald Trump, who has railed for the past year against the NFL player protests.

How the NFL approaches sports betting will also surely be scrutinized.

The sports betting ruling, and how the pro leagues are reacting, was the subject of a recent episode of the Yahoo Finance Sportsbook podcast with guest Dustin Gouker; listen below.

Daniel Roberts is the sports business writer at Yahoo Finance. He hosts the podcast Sportsbook and the video series Business + Coffee. Follow him on Twitter at @readDanwrite.

Read more:

Supreme Court strikes down sports betting ban: What happens next

NBA will push for federal legalization of sports betting

NFL lawyer hints at league’s stance on gambling

MLB commissioner: ‘We are reexamining our stance on gambling’

A ‘perfect storm’ is brewing for legalized sports gambling

Trump presidency could legalize sports betting

  • Ant McPartlin spends time with mum in Newcastle following Lisa Armstrong divorce – see exclusive photo
    News
    Hello!

    Ant McPartlin spends time with mum in Newcastle following Lisa Armstrong divorce – see exclusive photo

    Ant McPartlin has been pictured out and about for the first time since his divorce from ex-wife Lisa Armstrong was finalised on Tuesday. The TV star was in high spirits as he enjoyed a spot of shopping with his mum Christine in Newcastle city centre, with a fellow shopper exclusively telling HELLO!: "He was really lovely with people and took his time saying hello to everyone that walked past, letting them take pictures with him. Ant has been in the spotlight this week after he and his ex-wife Lisa were granted a decree nisi.

  • Prince Harry shares his and Meghan's 'personal joy' over soon becoming parents at the Invictus Games opening ceremony in Sydney
    News
    Evening Standard

    Prince Harry shares his and Meghan's 'personal joy' over soon becoming parents at the Invictus Games opening ceremony in Sydney

    The Duke of Sussex today shared his "personal joy" at soon becoming a father as he declared “Game on” for the opening ceremony of the Invictus Games in Sydney. Prince Harry and his wife Meghan, the Duchess of Sussex, who was wearing a Stella McCartney dress and coat by X-Files actress Gillian Anderson for Winser London, watched as artists and dancers took to the stage for the dazzling opening event at Sydney Opera House on Saturday.

  • Dana White just gave a big hint as to Khabib Nurmagomedov's next opponent, and it could be a fight that's been years in the making
    News
    Business Insider UK

    Dana White just gave a big hint as to Khabib Nurmagomedov's next opponent, and it could be a fight that's been years in the making

    Dana White is already thinking about Khabib Nurmagomedov's next opponent, and it sounds like Conor McGregor will have to wait for his rematch. Speaking with ESPN, White hinted that he'd like to see former lightweight champion Tony Ferguson get the next shot and Nurmagomedov and his belt. While White didn't commit to the fight, it's no surprise that Ferguson is at the top of the list of potential challengers, as it's a fight UFC has been trying to set up for some time.

  • Joint Europe-Japan Mission to Mercury Blasts Off
    Storyful

    Joint Europe-Japan Mission to Mercury Blasts Off

    Europe’s first mission to Mercury, built in cooperation with the Japanese space agency JAXA, was launched on board an Ariane 5 rocket from the Kourou spaceport in French Guiana on October 19. The BepiColombo mission includes two spacecraft, a planetary orbiter and a magnetospheric orbiter, which, according to the European Space Agency, will need to deal with temperatures above 350°C during their year-long mission around the closest planet to the sun. Credit: European Space Agency via Storyful

  • I want the hardline Brextremists out. That's why I'm marching
    News
    The Independent

    I want the hardline Brextremists out. That's why I'm marching

    The face Britain has been presenting to the world of late is nasty, narrow minded, inward looking and small, with the news agenda dominated by the likes of bigoted Boris Johnson, jabbering Jacob Rees-Mogg, dunderheaded David Davis, and, um, Iain Duncan Smith, the hammer of the disabled.

  • The Observer view on the urgent need for a fresh vote on Europe
    News
    The Guardian

    The Observer view on the urgent need for a fresh vote on Europe

    Theresa May’s plea for help was met with embarrassment and pity by the other 27 leaders in Brussels. The way the hard Tory Brexiters told it, Europe’s leaders should have been begging for mercy by now. Instead, Germany’s Angela Merkel and France’s Emmanuel Macron popped out for a convivial beer or two in a Brussels brasserie after last week’s supposedly make-or-break EU summit.

  • The thing about Jeremy Corbyn is that he really is a Eurosceptic
    News
    The Independent

    The thing about Jeremy Corbyn is that he really is a Eurosceptic

    One of the most interesting things said this week was in one of Jeremy Corbyn’s questions to the prime minister. He asked Theresa May if she would confirm the “legal advice given to cabinet that, in the event of no deal, the government would still have to pay the EU a divorce bill of £30bn”. The best ministers, in my view, are those who refuse to accept legal advice as holy writ and are prepared to challenge advice that could be wrong.

  • People might actually like you more than you think, and it's to do with the 'liking gap' – here's what that is
    News
    Evening Standard

    People might actually like you more than you think, and it's to do with the 'liking gap' – here's what that is

    "It's basically our finding that after a conversation with someone new, your conversation partner might like you more than you realise," Boothby explains. Subjects were harsher on themselves about their own first impression, suggesting they may have higher standards for themselves than for others, possibly, Boothby points out, because they know they could have done better.

  • Electric cars are set for explosive growth, but it's not all smooth runway ahead
    News
    The Independent

    Electric cars are set for explosive growth, but it's not all smooth runway ahead

    The switch to electric cars is speeding up. One is legal or regulatory controls, the other the falling cost of batteries. The spate of legal moves against petrol and diesel vehicles has become an avalanche.

  • Sports Direct to close landmark House of Fraser store in Manchester
    News
    The Independent

    Sports Direct to close landmark House of Fraser store in Manchester

    The landmark House of Fraser store in Manchester is to be closed after talks between its new owner, Sports Direct, and the building’s landlord failed to negotiate a new rent deal. The closure of the 182-year-old store, known by locals as “Kendal’s” from the days when the shop was owned by Kendal, Milne & Faulkner, will result in the loss of more than 160 jobs. The move comes after Sports Direct owner Mike Ashley took over House of Fraser earlier this year in a £90m deal that saved the department store from going into administration.

  • Cate Blanchett defends straight actors who play gay characters on screen
    News
    The Independent

    Cate Blanchett defends straight actors who play gay characters on screen

    Cate Blanchett has defended straight actors who play gay characters on screen. Hollywood has been increasingly criticised over the past few months for giving LGBT+ roles to straight actors, with Scarlett Johansson recently dropping out of playing a transgender character in Rub and Tug following a backlash. Blanchett, who played a lesbian character in 2015’s Carol, said she would “fight to the death” for the right to suspend disbelief and play characters beyond her own experience.

  • Late presenter wins award one month after passing away
    News
    Digital Spy

    Late presenter wins award one month after passing away

    Rachael Bland's co-hosts paid tribute to her.

  • While China may be closer to a trade deal with the UK, we should not forget their mixed record on human rights
    News
    The Independent

    While China may be closer to a trade deal with the UK, we should not forget their mixed record on human rights

    Premier Li Keqiang of China, second only to President Xi, told the prime minister at the EU-Asia summit: “We are also happy to meet you, Madame Prime Minister, in Brussels. Indeed, your visit to China in January was a big success. You may recall that during the now-forgotten premiership of David Cameron, an era that so feels so distant it may as well be that of Gladstone and Disraeli, the British liked to think of themselves building a “golden” age of Sino-British relations.

  • Manchester City vs Burnley LIVE: Premier League 2018-19 latest score, goal updates, team news and line-ups
    News
    Evening Standard

    Manchester City vs Burnley LIVE: Premier League 2018-19 latest score, goal updates, team news and line-ups

    Champions Manchester City return to Premier League action this afternoon against Sean Dyche’s Burnley. Kevin De Bruyne is in line to make just his second appearance of the season after recovering from a knee ligament injury. Fabian Delph is unlikely to return however with Ilkay Gundogan another midfield doubt after missing the goalless draw with Liverpool.

  • 8 years ago William proposed to Kate - and this is exactly how it happened
    News
    Hello!

    8 years ago William proposed to Kate - and this is exactly how it happened

    Princess Eugenie's wedding, Meghan's pregnancy announcement and the arrival of the Duchess of Cambridge's new nephew - Prince William and Kate are celebrating eight years since their engagement! Although the pair didn't officially make the announcement until 16 November 2010, William revealed he proposed to his girlfriend of nine years while on a trip to Kenya with friends a few weeks earlier in October. In their first interview after announcing the engagement, William explained he'd planned it for a while and carried his mother's sapphire and diamond engagement ring in his rucksack for three weeks before proposing and was terrified of losing it. Kate called the moment "very romantic," before admitting it was a "total shock," but the couple admitted they'd discussed marriage with each other a lot in the previous year.

  • A People's Vote is our final chance to get it right for generations to come
    News
    The Independent

    A People's Vote is our final chance to get it right for generations to come

    In 2016 Britain Stronger in Europe, an umbrella campaign led by the then Conservative prime minister David Cameron, made the argument for Britain’s continued membership of the European Union. In spite of this, the Remain campaign was not a complete failure. If it had been such a failure, it would not have been such a close result with 52 per cent for and 48 per cent voting against Brexit.

  • News
    Reuters

    Saudi crown prince had no knowledge of 'specific' Khashoggi operation - official

    Saudi Arabia's crown prince had no knowledge of the specific operation that resulted in the death of journalist Jamal Khashoggi in the kingdom's consulate in Istanbul this month, a Saudi official familiar with the investigation said on Friday. "MbS had no knowledge of this specific operation and certainly did not order a kidnapping or murder of anybody.

  • Aldi is bringing out mince pie flavoured ice cream for Christmas 
    News
    Hello!

    Aldi is bringing out mince pie flavoured ice cream for Christmas 

    For its 2018 Christmas offering, the budget store is giving customers three new flavoured ice creams - and one of those is Mince Pie & Brandy Butter flavoured. For the classy guys and gals, you’ll be excited to know that another flavour ice cream is coming to an Aldi freezer near you.

  • Four earthquakes detected in Blackpool just days after fracking restarts
    News
    Yahoo News UK

    Four earthquakes detected in Blackpool just days after fracking restarts

    The British Geological Survey has recorded four 'microseismic' events in Blackpool since Cuadrilla restarted fracking at its Preston New Road site.

  • Kate Hudson shares intimate moment with newborn - see beautiful photo
    News
    Hello!

    Kate Hudson shares intimate moment with newborn - see beautiful photo

    Hollywood actress Kate Hudson welcomed her baby daughter into the world in early October, and new mums will be able to relate to the photographs she has shared since. In her latest post, the 39-year-old daughter of Goldie Hawn shared a black and white photograph of herself hugging her two-week old daughter Rani in bed and gently kissing her on the head. Mum-of-three Kate previously shared a very moving video of her boyfriend Danny Fujikawa cradling their newborn in his lap while emotional music played in the background, along with the description: "Kind beautiful man, your pure love is such a gift #daddysgirl." She also shared another adorable photo not long after the birth, showing Rani snugly wrapped up with a little bow tied around her head, and referred to her as 'our little rosebud'.

  • Beyond the march, The Independent presses MPs to keep our options open on the most important decision in generations
    News
    The Independent

    Beyond the march, The Independent presses MPs to keep our options open on the most important decision in generations

    It means that, more than ever before, another referendum is part of the realistic range of options – especially if the Brexit talks fail. Finally, there is the option of remaining in the EU, and continuing to try to reform it from within.

  • BepiColombo spacecraft starts seven-year journey to Mercury
    News
    Business Insider UK

    BepiColombo spacecraft starts seven-year journey to Mercury

    A European-Japanese spacecraft set off on a treacherous seven-year journey to Mercury to probe the solar system's smallest and least-explored planet. The BepiColombo mission, only the third ever to visit Mercury, blasted off from Europe's spaceport in French Guiana aboard an Ariane 5 rocket at 10:45 p.m. local time on Friday (0145 GMT on Saturday), according to the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA). "Launching BepiColombo is a huge milestone for ESA (the European Space Agency) and JAXA, and there will be many great successes to come," ESA Director General Jan Woerner said in a statement.

  • Bosh! How two Londoners made veganism mainstream with viral recipe channel from their Hammersmith flat
    News
    Evening Standard

    Bosh! How two Londoners made veganism mainstream with viral recipe channel from their Hammersmith flat

    The success of Bosh co-founders Ian Theasby and Henry Firth is all the more astonishing considering they were unapologetic meat-eaters as recently as 2015. Ian and Henry are not even professional chefs, but now boast 1.7 million Facebook followers and have been hailed the “vegan Ant and Dec”. This year, they also released a Bosh recipe book, which became the best-selling vegan cookbook of all time.

  • Thousands turn out for People's Vote march in London
    ITN

    Thousands turn out for People's Vote march in London

    Thousands of people have filled the streets of London calling for a referendum on the final Brexit deal. People's Vote organisers say will be the "biggest, loudest and most important" demonstration of its kind.

  • Cyclist single mum recalls terrifying moment she thought she was going to die during crash with Tesco lorry in Clapham
    News
    Evening Standard

    Cyclist single mum recalls terrifying moment she thought she was going to die during crash with Tesco lorry in Clapham

    A 38-year-old single mum who was left with horrific injuries after being struck by a Tesco lorry in south-west London has spoken about the moment she thought she was going to die. Magdalena Tym was cycling home from work to her 13-year-old son Syzmon in Colliers Wood when she was struck by a lorry during a horror collision in Clapham South earlier this month. The 38-year-old designer and architect was left with horrific injuries to her arm and hand, which doctors said could be life-changing and left her needing three operations.