No.10 U-Turns And Admits Minister Used Private Email For Government Business

·3-min read

Downing Street has U-turned and admitted that a key health minister used a private email account for government business during the Covid pandemic.

Boris Johnson’s official spokesperson insisted Lord Bethell’s use of a private account was in line with government guidance.

But it is a significant climbdown from Monday’s claim that Bethell and disgraced former health secretary Matt Hancock “only ever conducted government business through their departmental email addresses”.

The row has sparked concerns that key decisions and their reasoning were not recorded or could be difficult to access for any future inquiry into the handling of coronavirus.

Labour deputy leader Angela Rayner has demanded an inquiry, saying ministers’ use of private accounts has “resulted in taxpayers’ money being handed out to Tory donors and their friends”.

It comes after the Sunday Times obtained minutes of meetings which revealed senior officials’ concerns about the pair using personal inboxes.

To view this content, you'll need to update your privacy settings.
Please click here to do so.

The minutes said Bethell “routinely uses his personal inbox” and that the “majority” of approvals for government contracts during the Covid crisis “would have been initiated from this [inbox]”.

The minutes were from a meeting about a Good Law Project legal challenge over Hancock’s decision to award a contract worth up to £75m for tests to a firm linked to Sir John Bell, a government adviser.

Following No.10’s initial claim on Monday that Hancock and Bethell conducted government business only through official accounts, the Good Law Project then published an email from Lord Feldman to Bethell’s private address as well as other government contacts, promoting a Canadian company Bio Basic as a potential provider of Covid tests.

Asked about the emails on Tuesday and whether they now accepted that Bethell used a private email address, the PM’s spokesperson said: “Yes.

“We’ve been clear that ministers are able to communicate in a variety of different ways as long as they adhere to the government guidance as set out.”

They added: “Ministers are able to use various forms of communication as long as they take heed of the guidance that is published.

“The guidance itself says those receiving communications should consider if the information contained in it is substantive discussions, or decisions generated in the course of conducting government business and if so take steps to ensure the relevant information is acceptable, for example by copying it to a government email address.

“All ministers are aware of this guidance around personal email usage, and government business is conducted in line with that guidance.”

Asked if Bethell had copied in his government account, the spokesperson replied: “What I’m saying is that ministers are aware of the guidance and that government business is conducted in line with that guidance.”

They added: “The important point is that when there have been substantive discussions or decisions generated in the course of those communications they then ensure relevant information is passed on and is accessible.”

In the Commons, Speaker Hoyle let slip his frustration as Cabinet Office minister Michael Gove again failed to turn up to answer an urgent question [UQ] about a lack of transparency over emergency contracts granted during the pandemic.

“I’m sorry the minister Gove wasn’t here to take some of the questions because most of them are named for him,” he said.

“This House won’t be taken for granted when statements are made outside here [ie by No.10 or in press conferences], continue to be made, that’s why I’m going to continue to grant UQs.

“So let’s get used to it. The government doesn’t want to come here, I’m going to make sure it is heard here.”

This article originally appeared on HuffPost UK and has been updated.


Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting