Outcry in India as Modi's ruling party offers 'free vaccines' in election manifesto
India’s ruling party has sparked an outcry by including a pledge to offer “free vaccines” in its election manifesto for a crucial upcoming state election.
Senior figures from Narendra Modi’s BJP are campaigning hard in the populous eastern state of Bihar, where voting will begin in less than a week, and where a loss for the party would be seen as a damning indictment on its handling of the Covid-19 crisis.
National finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman released the party’s manifesto for the state polls on Thursday in Patna, Bihar’s largest city, but was accused of politicising the central government’s response to the pandemic by making the vaccine pledge.
India is involved in the production of several vaccine candidates, but has yet to announce the mechanism through which any successful protection against Covid-19 would be distributed to its 1.3 billion people. Health is usually a devolved matter in India’s federal system, though Delhi has taken the lead in national action to contain the coronavirus.
The issue of coronavirus has played a big role in the Bihar campaign, with the country having had more than 7.7 million Covid-19 cases, the second highest in the world behind the US, and 117,000 deaths. And Bihar was particularly severely impacted by the mass exodus of migrant workers out of big cities at the start of India’s lockdown in March.
Speaking at the manifesto launch event, Ms Sitharaman said: “As and when the vaccine candidates that are currently under various levels of trials in the country get scientific clearances and a go-ahead for production, the people of Bihar will get vaccination for free once the production in India is on a large scale. This is our first poll promise as mentioned in the manifesto."
Opposition leaders, journalists and activists immediately questioned such a pledge, accusing the government of misusing a time of national medical need for electoral gains with a selective approach.
The ruling party of the capital city Delhi, AAP, tweeted: “What about non-BJP ruled states? Indians who didn't vote BJP will not get free Covid vaccine?”
What about non-BJP ruled states?
Indians who didn't vote BJP will not get free Covid vaccine? https://t.co/kjid5IC5aH— AAP (@AamAadmiParty) October 22, 2020
Rahul Gandhi, a prominent leader of the Congress opposition party, suggested that under the Modi administration Indians will probably have to wait for elections in their own states to get access to any vaccine.
GOI just announced India’s Covid access strategy.
Kindly refer to the state-wise election schedule to know when will you get it, along with a hoard of false promises.— Rahul Gandhi (@RahulGandhi) October 22, 2020
The former Jammu and Kashmir chief minister and National Conference leader Omar Abdullah asked whether the BJP will be paying for the vaccines from its own party treasury.
Will @BJP4India be paying for these vaccines from the party treasury? If it’s coming from the government treasury then how can Bihar get free vaccines while the rest of the country has to pay? There is so much wrong with this blatant populism that shamefully exploits COVID fears. https://t.co/ek796weG84
— Omar Abdullah (@OmarAbdullah) October 22, 2020
And calling it “vaccine electionism”, Chattisgarh state’s chief minister Bhupesh Baghel said that the BJP is implying that the citizens of other non-election states will have to pay for their vaccines when the time comes.
With this poll promise @bjp4india has implied that the citizens of other non election states will have to pay for the vaccine.
2/2— Bhupesh Baghel (@bhupeshbaghel) October 22, 2020
Amid the flurry of criticism, the national head of the BJP’s information and social media wing tweeted that the party can make the promise of the free vaccine because health is a state subject in India, and the central government will be providing a vaccine to all states at “nominal” rates. He suggested it was up to each state’s government whether they then waived that fee for citizens, or passed it on.
No statement to this effect has so far been released by the upper echelons of the central government, however.
BJP’s manifesto promises free Covid vaccine. Like all programs, center will provide vaccines to states at a nominal rate. It is for the state Govts to decide if they want to give it free or otherwise. Health being a state subject, Bihar BJP has decided to give it free. Simple.
— Amit Malviya (@amitmalviya) October 22, 2020
Activist Saket Gokhale said he would be raising the issue with the election commission, stating that this is a “discriminatory and false” promise.
Filed an urgent complaint with ECI regarding BJP's announcement of free Covid-19 vaccine for Bihar by Union Finance Minister @nsitharaman.
This is not only discriminatory but also a false promise & blatant misuse of Central Govt. powers during elections.
cc: @SpokespersonECI pic.twitter.com/yti8vR9i2E— Saket Gokhale (@SaketGokhale) October 22, 2020
Filed an urgent complaint with ECI regarding BJP's announcement of free Covid-19 vaccine for Bihar by Union Finance Minister @nsitharaman.
This is not only discriminatory but also a false promise & blatant misuse of Central Govt. powers during elections.
cc: @SpokespersonECI pic.twitter.com/yti8vR9i2E— Saket Gokhale (@SaketGokhale) October 22, 2020
BJP must not be feeling too good about their electoral prospects in Bihar that they feel the need to play such dirty and crass politics over a Covid19 vaccine. Not even Trump has resorted to something this shameful. Reeks of desperation. #BiharElections2020 https://t.co/W61Gb407Xe
— Rupa Subramanya (@rupasubramanya) October 22, 2020
This is so indefensibly outrageous that fairly sure the BJP/Govt will walk back from this - "we will give it to all" etc. Except as the FM has said, the free vaccine for Bihar promise is in their manifesto. As the first point. https://t.co/PEr2FFOFwS
— Sreenivasan Jain (@SreenivasanJain) October 22, 2020
Vaccines for free. Only for Bihar. Rest of us can drop dead. Also, only if voted to power. Otherwise, Biharis can also find a nice ditch to jump into. https://t.co/p4mTm8IhqX
— visvak (@visvak) October 22, 2020
Bihar’s vote begins on Wednesday 28 October, and will conclude on 7 November.