Prosecutions over St Patrick’s Day disco deaths welcomed by victim’s father
The decision to pursue prosecutions in connection with the deaths of three teenagers outside a St Patrick’s Day disco more than three years ago has been welcomed.
Connor Currie, 16, and 17-year-olds Lauren Bullock and Morgan Barnard lost their lives in a fatal crush as hundreds queued at the doors of the Greenvale Hotel, in Cookstown, Co Tyrone, for a disco on March 17 2019.
Northern Ireland’s Public Prosecution Service (PPS) said two men – aged 43 and 55 – will be charged with three counts of gross negligence manslaughter.
The pair will also be charged with one offence of contravening the Health and Safety at Work (Northern Ireland) Order 1978.
Greenvale Hotel owner Michael McElhatton is one of the men, it is understood.
Meanwhile, the company which runs the hotel, Tobin Limited, will face a charge of contravening the same health and safety legislation.
James Bradley, the father of Morgan Barnard, welcomed the decision to pursue prosecutions but expressed his disappointment that no police officers will be prosecuted.
“We now look forward to engaging in the trial process in the months ahead,” he said.
“It is, however, deeply disappointing that the PPS have taken a decision to keep those police officers involved out of the dock.
“This is a decision we do not intend on accepting. We have instructed our lawyers to immediately engage with the PPS in seeking a review into this decision not to prosecute.
The decisions were announced on Thursday after prosecutors took two years to consider “complex” files compiled by both the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) and the Police Ombudsman for Northern Ireland.
Senior public prosecutor Graham Cardwell said he acknowledges the day will be one of mixed emotions for the families of the three young people who died.
He thanked them for their patience.
“The files received from the PSNI and the Police Ombudsman were voluminous and detailed and there were a considerable number of complex issues that required careful consideration,” he said.
“I am grateful to the families for their patience as the PPS took the time needed to complete the significant task of examining all available evidence before reaching decisions on whether there was a reasonable prospect of conviction in relation to each suspect.
“I have informed the families that whilst the test for prosecution was met in respect of two suspects, it was considered not to be met on evidential grounds in respect of all other individuals reported in connection with events at the Greenvale Hotel that night.
“Detailed reasons for these decisions not to prosecute have been provided in writing to the families and we have also offered to meet in person.
“Whilst some of the no prosecution decisions may be disappointing to them, I can reassure the families, and the wider public, that all decisions were taken independently and only after a most thorough examination of all evidence and information available.
“Criminal proceedings will commence in due course and we will continue to engage directly with the families involved as the prosecution progresses.”
Mr McElhatton said in a statement on Thursday: “I am conscious that this is a highly sensitive time for the families and I feel that it would be inappropriate to comment at this time.”
Police reported 11 individuals as potential suspects.
Of the nine who will not be prosecuted, seven were described as door staff and two as having entertainment and hotel management roles.
The PPS concluded each of the nine could have exercised very little control over the planning for and management of the events which unfolded, or alternatively held a role which carried little responsibility for the safety of hotel patrons.
Following a separate investigation, the Police Ombudsman reported five police officers for the potential offence of misconduct in public office.
A call dispatcher was concluded to have communicated, in good faith and without delay, the key information he received as a result of the 999 call.
The remaining four officers considered were three constables and a temporary sergeant travelling in pairs in separate cars at the time.
It was concluded by the PPS that the available evidence was insufficient to establish that the reported officers recognised the seriousness or exact nature of the situation that was unfolding.
There was difficulty in establishing exactly what they heard over police communication channels and there was some initial confusion as to whether the incident was a public order situation, either inside or outside the hotel.
The approach taken by the sergeant was to immediately seek additional police resources so his officers could safely take any necessary action.
The PPS is to prosecute two individuals and one company in relation to the deaths of three teenagers following an incident at the Greenvale Hotel, Cookstown in March 2019.
You can read a full statement at the link below. https://t.co/Ok9G9TFDPw
— Public Prosecution Service (@thePPSNI) September 1, 2022
Police observations of the queue at the front of the hotel failed to identify any emergency and police also received assurances from inside the hotel that the situation was under control.
Mr Cardwell said the offence of misconduct in a public office is committed where a public officer, without reasonable excuse or justification, wilfully neglects to perform his duty to such a degree as to amount to an abuse of the public’s trust in the office holder.
“The threshold for this offence is high. I have concluded that the test for prosecution is not met against any of the five officers,” he said.
“The evidence was not capable of establishing any bad faith or improper motive in the actions of police at the scene or that they wilfully ignored a high-risk situation of which they were aware.”
Police ombudsman Marie Anderson said she will now consider whether there is evidence of misconduct by any officer.
“My role as an investigator is to assess the evidence and submit files to the PPS to make a decision as to whether an officer should be prosecuted for the potential offence of misconduct in public office,” she said.
“Now that the PPS has directed that no officer should be prosecuted, I will consider whether there is evidence of misconduct by any officer.
“Where there are grounds to do so, I will make appropriate recommendations to the chief constable.
“I thank the families for their ongoing patience during this process.”
Deputy Chief Constable Mark Hamilton said the PSNI acknowledges the decision taken.
“The Police Service of Northern Ireland referred itself to the Police Ombudsman for Northern Ireland in the aftermath of the incident,” he said.
“Following the direction not to prosecute any police officers, the misconduct investigation undertaken by the Police Ombudsman for Northern Ireland is still live and we will await receipt of their report and any recommendations in due course.”