Report: MLB confirmed whistling after Yankees complained in ALCS, unsure if Astros were source

The New York Yankees accused the Houston Astros of using whistles to convey stolen signs during the recent American League Championship Series, and it turns out they weren’t totally off base.

According to Andy Martino of SNY, MLB investigators did find evidence of whistling in footage of Game 1 of the ALCS, but they weren’t able to identify the source.

The sign-stealing accusations

Back in mid-October, when the Yankees and Astros were playing in the ALCS, Martino reported that the Yankees dugout had noticed distinct whistling noises before certain pitches were thrown during Game 1. Once they figured it out, they started chirping at the Astros dugout. At the end of the game, they asked MLB to look into it.

MLB had an official on site during the game who didn’t report any whistling, and after an investigation the league announced that it hadn’t found evidence of any wrongdoing on Houston’s part. However, there was more to it. According to Martino, MLB had heard whistling during a review of ALCS Game 1 footage, but they were unable to determine whether it had come from a fan at Minute Maid Park or an Astros employee.

Twitter user Jomboy posted several videos from Game 1 of the ALCS last week, and seems to have identified the whistling.

The whistle in that clip sounds clear, and it appears to come just before Yankees closer Aroldis Chapman releases a pitch. However, even with the whistles coming at vital points, it’s impossible to determine who was whistling and for what purpose.

In a subsequent video posted by Jomboy which features more pitches from the same at-bat, the original whistler inspired other people to whistle, which significantly muddies the water. Martino reported that after the Yankees complained, the whistling didn’t occur in Game 2.

The Yankees accused the Astros of communicating stolen signs via whistling, but MLB wasn't able to determine the source. (Thomas B. Shea-USA TODAY Sports)

What happens now?

If the whistling was the only sign-stealing accusation the Astros were dealing with right now, not much would happen. MLB has reportedly reviewed the footage and wasn’t able to determine the source of the whistling, which would put an end to things.

However, the Astros are now dealing with at least three kinds of sign-stealing accusations. There’s the whistling. There’s the trash can lid banging, which dates back to their 2017 playoff run. There’s the accusation that they used video to capture and decode opposing teams’ signs before they were conveyed via whistle or trash can lid. And there’s the brand new accusation that Kevin Goldstein, a special assistant to Astros GM Jeff Luhnow, sent emails to scouts asking for their help stealing signs from opposing teams.

Any one of those accusations would be concerning, but it would still be easy to quickly punish the Astros with little fanfare or explanation (just like MLB swiftly punished the Boston Red Sox in 2018 for using an Apple Watch to steal signs). With multiple allegations of sign stealing against the Astros, along with the accusation that they used electronics to help them do it, there’s no way that MLB can ignore it.

MLB is still investigating the Astros, but as the list of things they need to investigate them for grows larger, one thing is clear: This scandal isn’t going away.

More from Yahoo Sports:

  • Northern rail to be renationalised – and some Beeching closures could reopen
    News
    The Guardian

    Northern rail to be renationalised – and some Beeching closures could reopen

    Northern rail to be renationalised – and some Beeching closures could reopen. Transport secretary due to announce this week decision to terminate Northern’s franchise . Watchdog criticises UK rail passenger survey

  • Oti Mabuse reveals she considered breast reduction surgery
    News
    PA Media: Entertainment

    Oti Mabuse reveals she considered breast reduction surgery

    The Strictly professional said that having 'big boobs' can cause her many problems as a dancer.

  • Freddie Flintoff terrified in ‘horrific’ Top Gear bungee jump car stunt
    News
    PA Media: Entertainment

    Freddie Flintoff terrified in ‘horrific’ Top Gear bungee jump car stunt

    The former cricketer was hoisted up a 400ft dam in Switzerland for one of Top Gear's most terrifying challenges.

  • Trump impeachment: John Bolton says in book draft president wanted to freeze Ukraine aid until it launched Biden probe
    News
    The Independent

    Trump impeachment: John Bolton says in book draft president wanted to freeze Ukraine aid until it launched Biden probe

    John Bolton has said Donald Trump told him last summer that he wanted to continue to freeze military aid to Ukraine until it agreed to launch a probe into Joe Biden and his son.

  • Varadkar warns Johnson that EU will have upper hand in post-Brexit trade talks
    News
    PA Media: UK News

    Varadkar warns Johnson that EU will have upper hand in post-Brexit trade talks

    The Irish Taoiseach said the bloc has a 'stronger team' because of its far larger population and market in comparison.

  • Jo Brand breaks silence on Bake Off hosting role after Sandi Toksvig exit
    News
    PA Media: Entertainment

    Jo Brand breaks silence on Bake Off hosting role after Sandi Toksvig exit

    The comic said "there's a lot more freedom to muck about" in her other Bake Off job.

  • Mount Etna spews lava again after spectacular explosions
    ITN

    Mount Etna spews lava again after spectacular explosions

    Europe’s largest volcano, Mount Etna, is spewing lava again after a number of explosions signalled an increase in volcanic activity.

  • Home and Away spoiler pictures show Dean fear a split from Ziggy
    Digital Spy

    Home and Away spoiler pictures show Dean fear a split from Ziggy

    Is their relationship in trouble?From Digital Spy

  • Reynhard Sinaga: Victim of serial rapist reveals how he fought off attacker and brought him to justice
    News
    Evening Standard

    Reynhard Sinaga: Victim of serial rapist reveals how he fought off attacker and brought him to justice

    A young rugby player has revealed how he wrestled prolific rapist Reynhard Sinaga to the ground as he was assaulted.The man, who has chosen not to be named, was drugged into unconsciousness by Reynhard Sinaga, who was jailed for life earlier this month for raping up to 195 men.

  • UK weather forecast: Frost to cover Britain and snow on its way as temperatures plummet
    News
    Evening Standard

    UK weather forecast: Frost to cover Britain and snow on its way as temperatures plummet

    Commuters will wake up to frost on Monday morning as temperatures plummet across the country.The Met Office has issued four snow and ice warnings as a cold snap hits the UK at the start of the week.

  • Saudi Arabia’s crown prince urgently needs an adult in the room
    News
    The Guardian

    Saudi Arabia’s crown prince urgently needs an adult in the room

    Saudi Arabia’s crown prince urgently needs an adult in the room. Mohammed bin Salman’s antics are making it hard for western allies to paint his country as a competent regional partner

  • Anthony Joshua: For legacy and history, Deontay Wilder fight to unify the heavyweight division will happen
    News
    Evening Standard

    Anthony Joshua: For legacy and history, Deontay Wilder fight to unify the heavyweight division will happen

    Anthony Joshua says he and Deontay Wilder must meet for ‘legacy and history’ – but insists he views the American as ‘just another fighter’.Having reclaimed the IBF, WBA and WBO world titles with victory over Andy Ruiz Jr in Saudi Arabia, Joshua is eager for a unification bout with the undefeated WBC champion Wilder.

  • Brexit: What happens next?
    News
    Evening Standard

    Brexit: What happens next?

    The UK leaves the European Union on January 31, but that will not mean the end of the Brexit saga.Boris Johnson unveiled plans to celebrate the fruition of his "get Brexit done" pledge as Britain departs the EU.

  • Doctor Who review, Fugitive of the Judoon: Latest episode echoes vintage Moffat, but surely fans are exhausted of plot twists by now?
    News
    The Independent

    Doctor Who review, Fugitive of the Judoon: Latest episode echoes vintage Moffat, but surely fans are exhausted of plot twists by now?

    Doctor Who has morphed into a cheery and easily-digested dollop of Sunday night escapism under its latest show runner, Chris Chibnall. He created Broadchurch, which wasn’t always easy to follow and certainly not cheery. So kudos to him for broadening his range.The inevitable criticism, however, is that this straightforwardness comes at a price – that New Who lacks the devilish complexity that was a hallmark when Sherlock’s Steven Moffat was steering the Tardis. Some fans prefer Chibnall’s vision. Others do not. One or two – and you’re going to have to trust me on this – have even taken to the internet to discreetly share their concerns.

  • Angela Rayner Calls For Labour Leader To Be Stripped Of Power To Appoint Lords
    News
    HuffPost UK

    Angela Rayner Calls For Labour Leader To Be Stripped Of Power To Appoint Lords

    Labour deputy leadership candidate says party members must have a say in choosing peers.

  • Priti Patel vows tough immigration rules ahead of government commissioned review
    News
    The Independent

    Priti Patel vows tough immigration rules ahead of government commissioned review

    Priti Patel has reiterated her plans for an overhaul of the immigration system after Brexit, vowing to clamp down on low-skilled migration.The home secretary said UK businesses would have to change their approach to building their workforce when free movement ends, saying they had become “far too reliant” on “cheap” labour from the EU.

  • Tears filled my eyes as I was shown where my relative slept in Auschwitz
    News
    The Telegraph

    Tears filled my eyes as I was shown where my relative slept in Auschwitz

    The poignancy of my trip to Auschwitz hit me before I even left for Poland when my stepmother Bernice asked: “Do you think you will be able to light five candles for my mother, my aunts and my grandparents?”

  • The Trial of Christine Keeler episode 6, review: Sophie Cookson has shone in this richly drawn portrait of a woman in a world of wicked men
    News
    The Independent

    The Trial of Christine Keeler episode 6, review: Sophie Cookson has shone in this richly drawn portrait of a woman in a world of wicked men

    Knowing what’s coming in the final episode of The Trial of Christine Keeler adds to its dramatic power rather than diminishing it. Stephen Ward’s (James Norton) overdose proves fatal. The court verdict, which clears him of prostitution but finds him guilty of living off the “immoral earnings” of Mandy Rice-Davies (Ellie Bamber) and Christine Keeler (Sophie Cookson), is read out to an empty chair.The series has let events breathe throughout, and Ward’s early dispatch gives the final episode room to examine what followed. Keeler is arrested for perjury and put on trial. Her silver-tongued barrister, Jeremy Hutchinson (Paul Ritter), the inspiration for Rumpole, can’t stop her from being sentenced to nine months in prison. Her father Colin (Neil Morrissey) turns up out of the blue, promising to be there for her before promptly selling his story to the papers. Disgraced and alienated from high society, John Profumo (Ben Miles) presents himself at Toynbee Hall in Whitechapel, to work as a social reformer. Their parallel falls from grace are signposted with a floor-scrubbing scene of limited subtlety.

  • Hundreds protest India’s treatment of Kashmir in London
    News
    The Independent

    Hundreds protest India’s treatment of Kashmir in London

    Hundreds have gathered at the Indian High Commission office in London to protest the nation’s treatment of Kashmir following a similar event last year which led to the arrests of four people.Crowds waving the green and yellow striped flags of Kashmir and raising signs with “end Indian occupation” amassed across the street from the nation’s London embassy in a march that coincides with India’s Republic day – a national holiday marking the establishment of Delhi’s constitution.

  • Post divorce, actors Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt to open rosé champagne house together
    News
    RFI

    Post divorce, actors Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt to open rosé champagne house together

    A wine estate owned by actors and former spouses Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt are reportedly teaming up with the Perrin winemaker family and another champagne house in Mesnil-sur-Oger in the Marne to create a specialty rosé champagne, according to reports from Wine Spectator magazine."It will be the only house in Champagne to produce only rosé," Rodolphe Peters, the manager of the Champagne house, told AFP newswire, confirming the magazine’s report. "The volumes will be very reasonable. About 10,000 bottles to start with and we do not plan to produce more than 25,000 bottles in the long term. The ambition is really to develop a benchmark rosé champagne," said Peters.The new venture with the actors is aiming to create a high-quality rosé champagne, utilising the expertise of the Perrin family and the Miraval company, according to Peters. * Champagne harvest starts early, 'very good' vintage predicted * 'Organic' slips slowly into the French champagne industry"It is a family project between Angelina Jolie, Brad Pitt and their children with the families of winemakers Perrin and Peters, the latter two have known each other for a long time," said Guillaume Jourdan, spokesman for Vitabella PR agency, which handles Varois Miraval.Jolie and Pitt first joined up with the Perrins in 2011 to create the ‘Miraval Côtes de Provence’ rosé wine, taking the name of their shared property in Correns, in the Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur region in southeastern France. The property includes 500 hectares, including 50 hectares of vines, which they bought in 2008 for 40 million euros.Jourdan said that the group has been working on the project for about three to four years. Additional time would be necessary to create the release date and packaging of the specialty champagne.

  • Remainers planning to take Brexit 50p coins out of circulation
    News
    Yahoo News UK

    Remainers planning to take Brexit 50p coins out of circulation

    Chancellor Sajid Javid unveiled the commemorative coin over the weekend.

  • Another celebrity skates off Dancing On Ice
    News
    PA Media: Entertainment

    Another celebrity skates off Dancing On Ice

    Radzi Chinyanganya was third person to be cut from the competition.

  • Thomas Markle says Prince Harry should 'man up'
    Yahoo News UK

    Thomas Markle says Prince Harry should 'man up'

    In his first live TV interview since his daughter Meghan Markle and Prince Harry stepped down from senior royal life, Thomas Markle told Good Morning Britain their decision is “never going to work”. During the exclusive interview, Mr Markle was asked whether he had a message for Prince Harry, to which he replied: "man up and fly down and see me and we will talk." Credit: ITV’s Good Morning Britain

  • Qassim Soleimani's 'holy war' will engulf Syria in Sunni-Shia conflict for years to come
    News
    The Telegraph

    Qassim Soleimani's 'holy war' will engulf Syria in Sunni-Shia conflict for years to come

    In a moment of uncharacteristic candour, Syria's defence minister last week admitted he had been working with Qassim Soleimani since the start of the country's devastating civil war.