San Francisco race puts ranked-choice voting in spotlight

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — In San Francisco, the candidate with the most first-place votes is trailing in a tight race for mayor

London Breed, the president of San Francisco's Board of Supervisors, is some 10 percentage points ahead of former state Sen. Mark Leno in votes for first-place, yet Leno is leading Breed in the overall race by fewer than 1,200 votes.

How does this make any sense? San Francisco uses a ranked-choice voting system in which voters also choose their second and third favorites for mayor.

In this case, Leno has more first-place and second-place votes put together than Breed.


In San Francisco, voters pick up to three candidates in order of preference on one ballot.

If no candidate has more than 50 percent of the vote outright, elimination rounds begin. If a voter's No. 1 pick is eliminated, the voter's No. 2 candidate gets that vote and so on until there's a winner. Ranked-choice voting has been used in San Francisco since 2004 to elect the mayor, city attorney, board of supervisors and other citywide offices.


A dozen city and county governments use this kind of system, according to FairVote, a nonpartisan electoral reforms group based in Maryland. A few San Francisco Bay Area cities use the system, including Oakland; it's also used in Portland, Maine and Minneapolis and St, Paul, Minnesota.

Four other jurisdictions are set to use ranked-choice voting, including the state of Maine in its June 12 primary where there are four federal and state races with at least three candidates. Races include the Democratic and Republican primaries for Maine governor.

Cambridge, Massachusetts has elected slates of city council and school board using an at-large form of ranked-choice voting since 1941.


Advocates say the system promotes the election of a candidate who has a majority of support through first- and second-place votes. On the flip side, it avoids the election of a candidate who has less than 50 percent of the vote. Supporters also say the system avoids the cost of a separate runoff election and encourages collaboration among candidates.

In San Francisco, Leno and Supervisor Jane Kim encouraged their supporters to pick the other for their No. 2. Leno is benefiting from the alliance as he's receiving the bulk of Kim's votes. She is in third place.


Jason McDaniel, associate political science professor at San Francisco State University, says his research shows ranked-choice voting increases the rate of ballot errors and disqualifies ballots, particularly among lower-income residents.

Picking a winner by ranked-choice could also raise the whiff of illegitimacy, he said, noting that Breed scored 36 percent of first-place votes citywide.

"I do think it might have an effect," he said. "Look, only 26 percent of voters chose Mark Leno, and that might hurt his legitimacy going forward, the perception of that" if he becomes mayor.

Jennifer Pae, director of FairVote California, disagreed. She said the group's analysis of initial returns showed voters made more errors in the governor's race than the mayor's race.


AP staff writer David Sharp of Portland, Maine contributed to this report.

See Also:

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting