Scotland v England player ratings gallery - 6s aplenty for Scots, Bellingham stars, two 8s for England
John Greechan
·5-min read
Nothing he could do about the England goals – and made one outstanding one-on-one stop from substitute Eberechi Eze.
Call it a timely reminder of where Euro 2024-bound Scotland stand, in the grand order of things. An indicator of the distance still to be covered before they can consider themselves part of Europe’s absolute elite.
If we must imbue a “meaningless” fixture with significance, on a night when Norway’s win over Georgia kicked Scotland’s qualification for next summer’s European Championships a little way down the road, let it be this. That Steve Clarke’s men are still just a little short of the threat and nous needed to take down a team regularly found in the semi-finals and finals of major tournaments.
Teased and tormented by an English front four drawn from the ranks of Real Madrid, Bayern Munich and both halves of the Manchester rivalry, the home side certainly couldn’t be faulted for effort or intent in an entertaining 150th anniversary fixture at Hampden. But two goals 120 seconds apart, Phil Foden and Jude Bellingham doing the damage, saw England cruise into a comfortable lead before 35 minutes had elapsed.
Given a torrid time by Marcus Rashford, who targeted the Watford centre-half all night.
Scotland, still hopeful of achieving seeded Pot 1 status when they complete the near certainty of making it to the Euro finals in Germany, battled back with all the ferocity and ability at their disposal, as captain Andy Robertson – culpable for the Bellingham goal – sent in a cross that forced England sub Harry Maguire to divert the ball into his own net with 67 minutes gone.
But Harry Kane made it 3-1 with ten minutes remaining, as England reasserted their dominance on a night when they rarely looked like losing control. Even before Foden’s opener, a slightly lucky close-range deflection on Kyle Walker’s low ball across goal, the visitors had stretched and tested the home defence to the max.
If there was no shock in England carving Scotland open for the first goal, their movement and ability to fizz the ball around leaving the men in those classic blue anniversary shirts chasing shadows, the second was an absolute sickener for the home side. Quite what captain Robertson was doing when he played the ball directly to Bellingham, no more than eight yards out with the entire goal at his mercy, is a mystery. And it also spelled tragedy for the Scotland skipper.
What a response the Liverpool left back mustered, though. What a way to make amends, as he surged out from defence, bursting onto the right wing – yes, the right wing – and sending in a low cross that forced Maguire into a wildly-celebrated own goal. Suddenly, the blood was up and the mood was electric. But it didn’t take long for England to ease the tension, gradually but surely reasserting their control before Kane repeated a past party trick by silencing the Tartan Army on their own patch.
Must have a sore neck after a night spent with his head on a swivel, wondering where England’s front four were going to attack next.
See below for Scotland and England player ratings in full:
Had to do more defending than he would have liked in his role as an overlapping left centre-back.
Full of running and always comfortable on the ball, the right wing-back had to tuck inside to help out Porteous with Rashford.
A Rolls Royce on the ball, the Brighton midfielder was forced to cover a lot of ground out of possession as Scotland scrambled.
The Celtic captain plugged a lot of gaps in midfield but wasn’t given many opportunities to show his high footballing IQ on the ball.
Scotland’s captain was guilty of an inexplicable howler for England’s second – but showed incredible character and ability to create the home team’s only goal.
The free-scoring midfielder barely got a sniff of a chance in the England box, before being withdrawn into a deeper role.
The Tartan Army talisman was game, full of fight and always looking to get at the opposition. But couldn’t really influence the game.
A solid centre forward who makes decent runs, Adams lacked the movement and touch needed to disrupt England’s back four.
Replaced Adams just before the hour mark and put himself about to half decent effect.
On for Billy Gilmour after 59 minutes. Full of running and not bad on the ball.Rest of subs: Stuart Armstrong N/ANo chance to impress after replacing Kieran Tierney for the last nine minutes.Lewis Ferguson N/AAnother late sub who didn’t get an opportunity to do much.Ryan Jack N/AOnly on the pitch for a couple of minutes.Nathan Patterson N/AUnlikely to do much after being introduced in the 89th minute.
Couldn’t do much about the Scotland goal. And didn’t have much else to do on a comfortable night.
Such an athletic and intelligent player to have at right back, providing an attacking outlet and defensive cover.
Solid and comfortable on the ball, he looks a prospect for England.
Only given until half-time but didn’t do much wrong at centre-half alongside Dunk.
Solid, effective, didn’t make any real mistakes. Not a game winner but looked decent.
Not exactly an eye-catching performance but, alongside Rice, helped provide a platform for England’s front four.
Like Phillips, he didn’t do anything spectacular. But didn’t need to.
A wonderful talent who always carried a threat, his movement is joy to watch. Just not for Scotland fans.
Real Madrid wunderkind is a generational talent. Genuinely one of the best in the world already.
A constant menace to the Scotland defence, his well-timed runs were key to both first-half goals.
The Bayern Munich forward is key to England’s front four, dropping deep and inviting runners to go beyond him. And he’s still scoring.
Harry Maguire 5 Half-time replacement was mercilessly taunted by the Tartan Army. And that was before his own goal. Bukayo Saka 5 On for the last 20, he showed great energy and ability. As usual. Eberechi Eze 5 Squandered a great one-on-one chance but he definitely looked a player in his 20-minute cameo. Conor Gallagher N/A Only on for the closing seven minutes Callum Wilson N/A Did very little after coming in in the 84th minute.
With Haaland on the bench at St James’ Park, City suddenly looked like they lacked goals from elsewhere; is Pep Guardiola now overly reliant on his top scorer?
Strictly Come Dancing star Rose Ayling-Ellis posed in a gorgeous leather oversized shirt as fans commented that they hoped to see her with former dance partner Giovanni Pernice soon.
The 29-year-old has undoubtedly been one of Man City's most important players in the last few years, and Pep Guardiola wants to keep hold of him for as long as possible