Indian restaurant chef who 'threw chilli powder in customer's face' not guilty of assault

An Indian restaurant owner has been found not guilty of assault occasioning actual bodily harm on a diner by throwing chilli powder in his face after he complained about “rubbery” chicken.

Chef Kamrul Islam, 47, was accused of ABH against David Evans at the Prince of Bengal in Tonypandy, South Wales, on January 21 last year.

Mr Islam admits throwing the chilli powder into Mr Evans’ eyes but insists he was acting in self-defence after the customer behaved aggressively towards him.

Chef Kamrul Islam admitted throwing chilli powder into customer David Evans’ eyes (PA)

Speaking outside court, former restaurant owner Karmul Islam said he was relieved to have been found not guilty of assault occasioning actual bodily harm on David Evans at his restaurant, the Prince of Bengal in Tonypandy, South Wales, on January 21 last year.

Islam, who said he was now working as a certified air conditioning engineer having closed the restaurant down, said: “I was very confident that the British system would find the right answer.”

Merthyr Tydfil Crown Court heard yesterday that Mr Evans and his wife Michelle complained about their tandoori chicken, describing it as “rubbery” and “shiny”.

The couple, who arrived at the restaurant at about 6pm, ordered lager and a bottle of wine before choosing their dishes from the menu.

Nicholas Hewitt, a kitchen assistant at the restaurant, told the jury he was sent to speak to Mr and Mrs Evans following their initial complaint.

“They weren’t happy with food quality, in particular a tandoori dish,” he said.

“They said it was rubbery, with the possibility of it being microwaved. I assured them that it was cooked fresh with traditional herbs and spices.

“I remember telling them that if they weren’t happy with that dish I would be happy to take it off the bill and bring them another dish.”

The Prince of Bengal restaurant in Tonypandy, South Wales (Google Street View)

Mr Hewitt said the couple were initially polite but became “aggressive and loud”, complaining about further dishes they were served.

He said Mr Islam attempted to “defuse the situation” but things “got out of hand” – with both the restaurant owner and the couple swearing.

At one point, Mrs Evans “grabbed” the chef’s arm and he said: “Don’t touch me,” Mr Hewitt told the court.

“I remember the man standing up saying, ‘don’t swear at my wife’,” he said.

“Kam was quickly retreating from the table. The guy was marching across the restaurant, punching his hands into his fists.”

Kamrul Islam (PA)

Mr Islam walked into the restaurant’s kitchen and another worker attempted to block Mr Evans from entering and reaching him, Mr Hewitt said.

“I remember him being very aggressive,” he said. “He used his physical presence and was trying to get into that kitchen. That’s when a mist of powder came out the door and hit the customer in the face.”

Asked what he believed would have happened if Mr Evans had reached the chef, Mr Hewitt replied: “I dread to think.”


Mr Evans immediately doubled up in pain after the chilli was thrown at him and was taken to hospital.

A saline drip was used to clean his eyes and he was found to have suffered burns where the spice landed on him.

The court heard from friends and former employees of Mr Islam, who described him as “polite” and “accommodating”.

Mr Islam, of Llewellyn Street, Pentre, denies assault occasioning actual bodily harm.

The Prince of Bengal closed last year and has since re-opened as Spice Lounge under new ownership.

The trial continues.


By using Yahoo you agree that Yahoo and partners may use Cookies for personalisation and other purposes