The Snowman composer accuses BBC of ‘vile desecration’ of his Christmas classic

  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
·5-min read
In this article:
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
  • Howard Blake
A new musical interpretation of Christmas favourite The Snowman has stirred up ill feeling from its original composer
A new musical interpretation of Christmas favourite The Snowman has stirred up ill feeling from its original composer

It's the legendary Christmas film accompanied by one of the most recognised festive scores in history.

But now The Snowman composer Howard Blake is furious with the BBC's "vile desecration" of his acclaimed work after threatening to withdraw his permission for the recreation.

The score for the film about a boy who builds a snowman that comes to life is being broadcast in full – but without any instruments.

Mr Blake told The Telegraph that the BBC have enlisted producer Jonathan Manners to arrange a new version of the classic, where the sound of the instruments is replicated by a choir, a concept known as "vocalise".

While Mr Blake has allowed numerous producers to arrange versions of The Snowman, he has taken exception to the vocalise version, saying: "This lad [Jonathan Manners] is really trying to make a name for himself, but I have told him what you have done to my music is a desecration, it is absolutely vile."

Composer Howard Blake poses before a piano
Composer Howard Blake poses before a piano

A feature-length show is set to air on Radio 3 on Christmas Eve at 7.30pm, and a repeat performance will be scheduled for BBC Radio 4 on Christmas Day at 1.30pm, narrated by Stephen Fry.

When he was approached by the BBC, Mr Blake, 82, who was awarded an OBE in 1994 for services to music, told them that rearranging his Christmas composition in vocalise would be a desecration of his work.

He said: "Last August, BBC's music producer Jonathan Manners asked me if I would give my approval to a new arrangement of the complete soundtrack of The Snowman.

"He wanted to arrange the entire 26 minute composition in vocalise after he heard my acapella choral arrangement of Walking in the Air which I arranged for Peter Auty and the St Albans Cathedral Choir in 2019.

"I told him he was mad to vocalise the whole thing, but he's going ahead with it anyway."

Initially, Mr Blake refused to allow permission to do his composition in vocalise. 

"I said it's impossible to do it in vocalise so if you try and do it without instruments, I refuse", he explained.

‘I've already told Prince Charles’

However, when Mr Manners told him the new arrangement had piqued the interest of royalty he relented.

"When I refused, Jonathan [Manners] told me – it's very difficult, I've already told Prince Charles and the Queen about it – how could I refuse?"

The BAFTA-winning film, which was also nominated for an Oscar, first aired on Channel 4 in 1982, and has been shown every year on Christmas Day since.

The short film was based on the Raymond Briggs book of the same name about a boy who builds a snowman which then magically comes to life.

Watch: Star added to Legoland Christmas tree

The four-minute song Walking In The Air is the only part of the film with words, but is arguably what rocketed the film to its extraordinary success.

The snub has left Mr Blake reeling. "They might be re-imagining my work at Christmas," he said, "but they still aren't actually working with me – it will be producer Jonathan Manners who will be arranging The Snowman in vocalise. He'll be the one who will get the credit for arranging it, not me".

Mr Manners is the BBC's Singers, Chief Producer and Artistic Director with a long history of working with choirs and orchestras having been formally educated at the Royal Birmingham Conservatoire.

Vocalise is a musical style that has no words at all, instead using acapella sounds sung by a choir to replace the strings, woodwinds, brass and percussion.

One notable example of vocalise is the Humming Chorus from Puccini's opera, Madame Butterfly, which features in the scene at the end of Act II as Chio-Chio San (Madame Butterfly) waits for an American naval officer called Pinkerton.

This technique will now be used to professionally recreate the sounds.

‘I would kill him on the podium’

This week, rehearsals for the BBC's version of The Snowman will take place with a full choir at a studio in London's Maida Vale.

Mr Blake said: "They are starting rehearsals tomorrow, but I wouldn't go along because I would kill him on the podium.

"George Bernard Shaw once said: Hell is full of musical amateurs."

The song was born out of a stressful time for Mr Blake who wrote Walking in the Air when he lived in a rented beach hut in Cornwall for two months having left his home in Knightsbridge while suffering from stress.

Blake, who was the son of a postman from Brighton, claims the new Christmas arrangement is the first time the BBC have recognised his work.

"I didn't have an upper class upbringing like most classical composers" he said, adding "they thought I was too commercial because I wrote advertising jingles before I came to international fame after writing Walking in the Air, despite the fact I wrote the score for The Avengers, Flash Gordon with Queen, and I was commissioned by the Philharmonia to compose Princess Diana's 30th birthday concerto at the Royal Festival Hall".

A BBC spokesman told The Telegraph: "The BBC Singers are honoured to work with Howard Blake on a special project as part of our Christmas line-up, details of which will be released to our listeners nearer the festive season."

Watch: London's Christmas lights turned on

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting