Students must be lifted out of net migration targets, say MPs

Lizzy Buchan

​MPs have called for students to be lifted out of the government's net migration target amid warnings of the risk of "economic stagnation" for parts of the UK.

The Scottish Affairs Committee also urged ministers to review the controversial pledge to slash the number of immigrants to the "tens of thousands".

It comes after Sajid Javid, the home secretary, failed to endorse the target when grilled by a parliamentary committee, when he smirked and simply replied, "next question", when asked if he wanted to ditch it.

The Independent has been campaigning to drop the target with the group Open Britain, urging the government to abandon its goal to reduce net migration to under 100,000.

The cross-party committee was looking at how Scotland could increase its share of UK migrants, as it has suffered in the past from population decline and poor economic growth.

SNP committee chairman Pete Wishart said: "The current visa system for non-EU workers is complicated and bureaucratic, and the way the current net migration target is enforced benefits London to the expense of the rest of the country.

"Scotland's future population growth is entirely dependent on continued inward migration and it appears that Scotland's needs are not being fully met under the current system."

"Nobody wants to see a return to the dark days of population decline and economic stagnation," Mr Wishart added.

The report urges ministers to review options for greater regional differentiation in immigration and to probe how the visa cap operates to ensure it does not disproportionately benefit London and the south east.

It calls for the government to consider a Scotland-specific post-study work visa scheme, in the absence of a UK-wide scheme.

MPs also condemned the bureaucracy in the current points-based immigration system, saying it needs "substantial reform and simplification if it is to be able to provide a suitable basis for replacing freedom of movement".

Mr Javid came under fire from the home affairs committee over the eight-year-old Conservative pledge to bring down immigration, which has never been met.

Asked if the target was an objective of the post-Brexit migration system, Mr Javid said: “It will be an objective of the post-Brexit migration system to bring down immigration, in the long term, to sustainable levels”.

UK news in pictures

UK news in pictures

  • 1/5010 July 2018

    Serena Williams celebrates after winning against Camila Giorgi during their women's singles quarter-final match on the eighth day of Wimbledon. Williams won the match 3-6, 6-3, 6-4.

    AFP/Getty Images

  • 2/509 July 2018

    Britain's new Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union Dominic Raab leaves 10 Downing Street after it was announced he was appointed to the job. The former Housing Minister is to take up the post, after UK Brexit Secretary David Davis resigned from the Cabinet and said Monday that he won't seek to challenge Prime Minister Theresa May's leadership.


  • 3/508 July 2018

    Ferrari's Sebastian Vettel celebrates winning the British Grand Prix in front of second place finisher Lewis Hamilton at Silverstone.


  • 4/507 July 2018

    Gareth Southgate, manager of England, celebrates at the final whistle following his side's quarter final victory over Sweden at the World Cup in Russia.


  • 5/506 July 2018

    Forensic investigators wearing protective suits enter the rear of John Baker House, a supported housing scheme for the homeless in Salisbury after it was evacuated the previous day. Police are investigating the scene after a man and woman were exposed to nerve agent novichok and are in critical condition.


  • 6/505 July 2018

    German Chancellor Angela Merkel receives Britain's Prime Minister Theresa May in Berlin.


  • 7/504 July 2018

    British police officers stand facing a residential property in Amesbury. British police have declared a "major incident" after two people were exposed to an unknown substance in the town, and are cordoning off places the people are known to have visited before falling ill.


  • 8/503 July 2018

    England celebrate after beating Colombia on penalties in their round of 16 match at the World Cup in the Spartak Stadium, in Moscow.


  • 9/502 July 2018

    Floral tributes left at Gorleston beach in Norfolk where a girl was fatally thrown from an inflatable on Sunday, as an MP calls for bouncy castles to be temporarily banned in public areas.


  • 10/501 July 2018

    A firefighter carries a water hose past sheep close to scorched moorland as it burns during a fire at Winter Hill, near Rivington.


  • 11/5030 June 2018

    People march in central London to mark the 70th anniversary of the NHS.


  • 12/5029 June 2018

    People look at the damage to the outside of a high-rise block in Wellington Way, Mile End, in east London, after a fire broke-out in a 12th floor flat.


  • 13/5028 June 2018

    Prime Minister Theresa May holds up a Belgium football shirt given to her by Belgian Prime Minister Charles Michel, center left, during a round table meeting at an EU summit in Brussels. European Union leaders meet for a two-day summit to address the political crisis over migration and discuss how to proceed on the Brexit negotiations.


  • 14/5027 June 2018

    The full moon rises behind burning moorland as a large wildfire sweeps across the moors between Dovestones and Buckton Vale in Stalybridge, Greater Manchester on June 26. Firefighters fought the blaze throughout the night and into the 27.


  • 15/5026 June 2018

    Prince William pays his respects during a ceremony commemorating the six million Jews killed by the Nazis in the Holocaust, in the Hall of Remembrance at Yad Vashem World Holocaust Remembrance Center in Jerusalem.


  • 16/5025 June 2018

    Planes land at Heathrow airport ahead of the vote in parliament which decided Heathrow airport should have a third runway.


  • 17/5024 June 2018

    Harry Kane celebrates scoring his second goal and England's fifth with teammates during their World Cup group game against Panama. England won 6-1.


  • 18/5023 June 2018

    Demonstrators at the People's March demanding a People's Vote on the final Brexit deal, in London, on the second anniversary of the 2016 referendum.

    AFP/Getty Images

  • 19/5022 June 2018

    Andria Marsh, 63, holds up photographs of her parents and her original British passport, following a Windrush service at Westminster Abbey in London. A service was held at the Abbey to commemorate the arrival to Britain of Caribbean migrants on the ship, Empire Windrush, 70 years ago. The migrants were recruited to rebuild post-war Britain.


  • 20/5021 June 2018

    Revellers watch the sunrise as they celebrate the pagan festival of Summer Solstice at Stonehenge in Wiltshire. The festival, which dates back thousands of years, celebrates the longest day of the year when the sun is at its maximum elevation. Modern druids and people gather at the landmark Stonehenge every year to see the sun rise on the first morning of summer.


  • 21/5020 June 2018

    Family members of those who died in Gosport War Memorial Hospital gather today after a public inquiry found that up to 650 patients died between 1989 and 2000 from lethal doses of opiate medication that was delivered “without medical justification”


  • 22/5019 June 2018

    Former TV presenter John Leslie leaves Edinburgh Sheriff Court, he is accused of putting his hand down a woman's trousers as they danced at her hen night.


  • 23/5018 June 2018

    Prime Minister Theresa May finishes speaking following visiting patients at the Royal Free Hospital in London. Ms May announced a new package of £20 Billion worth of funding for the NHS.


  • 24/5017 June 2018

    Competitors begin the race after a rolling start during round two of the 2018 Championship, the F1H2O UIM Powerboat World Championship Grand Prix of London, at the Royal Victoria Docks.


  • 25/5016 June 2018

    Fire fighters attend the scene of a second fire at Glasgow's School of Art four years after part of the Charles Rennie Mackintosh designed building was destroyed by fire. The blaze spread to nearby buildings including the Campus nightclub and O2 ABC music venue

    Christopher Flyvbjerg /

  • 26/5015 June 2018

    Dean of Westminster, John Hall, accompanied by first wife Jane Hawking, watches as daughter Lucy Hawking, places flowers at the site of the internment of the ashes of Stephen Hawking in the nave Westminster Abbey. The world renowned physicist and author of A Brief History of Time, died early in the morning of 14 March 2018, at the age of 76. Professor Hawking's ashes will be laid to rest close to Sir Isaac Newton and Charles Darwin.

    Getty Images

  • 27/5014 June 2018

    British singer Robbie Williams performs during the opening ceremony of the 2018 World Cup at the Luzhniki Stadium in Moscow.


  • 28/5013 June 2018

    Prince Charles uses a power drill during a visit to the Owenkillew Community Centre in Gortin, as part of his tour of Northern Ireland.


  • 29/5012 June 2018

    England manager Gareth Southgate, his players and coaching staff pose for the official England squad photo ahead of traveling to the World Cup in Russia.

    The FA

  • 30/5011 June 2018

    Play was suspended during the match between Lancashire and Essex as an Air Ambulance landed on the pitch after one of the spectators was taken ill on day three of the Specsavers County Championship, Division One match at Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester.


  • 31/5010 June 2018

    Marchers hold up banners as they gather to mark 100 years since women won the right to vote in the UK.


  • 32/509 June 2018

    The parade makes its way up The Mall from Horse Guards Parade to Buckingham Palace, central London, following the Trooping the Colour ceremony, as the Queen celebrates her official birthday.


  • 33/508 June 2018

    Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau meets with British Prime Minister Theresa May at the G7 Leaders Summit in La Malbaie, Quebec.

    Rex Features

  • 34/507 June 2018

    Brexit Secretary David Davis, right, and International Trade Secretary Liam Fox leave 10 Downing Street. Prime Minister Theresa May held an emergency Brexit cabinet meeting in an attempt to resolve tensions over the UK's Irish border plan.


  • 35/506 June 2018

    Britain's Prime Minister Theresa May welcomes Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to Downing Street.


  • 36/505 June 2018

    British fashion designer and environmental campaigner, Dame Vivienne Westwood delivers an anti-fracking letter to 10 Downing Street in London.


  • 37/504 June 2018

    New images issued by the Grenfell Tower Inquiry of the kitchen in flat 16 where the fire started on June 14 last year. Seventy-one people were killed after the fire tore through the housing block in Kensington.

    Grenfell Tower Inquiry/PA

  • 38/503 June 2018

    Bishop of Southwark Christopher Chessun and members of the public attend a commemoration service on the first anniversary of the London Bridge terror attack. Britain held a national minute of silence on June 3, one year on from the London Bridge terror attack that killed eight people and injured dozens more.


  • 39/502 June 2018

    William Buick ridding Masar celebrates crossing the line and winning the Investec Derby race on Derby Day at Epsom Downs.


  • 40/501 June 2018

    Traffic passes anti-Brexit signs on the County Derry/Londonderry Northern Ireland and County Donegal in the Irish Republic. Northern Ireland could be given joint EU and UK status and a 'buffer zone' on its border with the Republic, under new plans being drawn up by David Davis, according to reports.


  • 41/5031 May 2018

    Eleanor Crossey Malone displays an abortion pill packet after taking a pill as abortion rights campaign group ROSA, Reproductive Rights Against Oppression, Sexism and Austerity distribute abortion pills from a touring bus in Belfast, Northern Ireland. Flouting Northern Irish governmental laws which forbid the use of abortion pills the group are also protesting outside offices belonging to the main political parties in the province. Women in Northern Ireland have been prosecuted for buying abortion pills over the internet and it is illegal for a woman to have an abortion unless in special circumstances unlike the rest of the United Kingdom. The Republic of Ireland voted in favour of pro-choice last week in a referendum.


  • 42/5030 May 2018

    West Midlands Police officers carrying out scene searches near to where a 15-year-old boy was fatally stabbed in Wolverhampton.


  • 43/5029 May 2018

    A view at Westminster Abbey from the medieval Triforium that is hosting an exhibition in London. The Queen's Diamond Jubilee Galleries, set more than 16 meters, (52 feet) above the Abbey floor in the medieval Triforium, will open to the public for the first time on June 11, displaying over 300 treasures from the Abbey's collection which will tell the rich thousand-year history of the institution at Westminster Abbey.


  • 44/5028 May 2018

    People enjoy the hot weather on Bournemouth Beach during bank holiday Monday in Dorset.


  • 45/5027 May 2018

    Chris Ashton of the Barbarians scores against England at Twickenham.


  • 46/5026 May 2018

    Lightning strikes over the city of London.


  • 47/5025 May 2018

    Rory Mcilroy took the clubhouse lead in to round three of the BMW PGA championship at Wentworth.

    Action Images via Reuters

  • 48/5024 May 2018

    Alastair Cook batting against Pakistan during the first test match of the summer at Lord’s cricket ground, London.


  • 49/5023 May 2018

    Home Secretary Sajid Javid speaking at the annual conference of the Police Federation of England and Wales at the International Convention Centre in Birmingham.


  • 50/5022 May 2018

    Felix, two,sits next to messages and flowers left in Manchester, ahead of the Manchester Arena National Service of Commemoration at Manchester Cathedral to mark one year since the Manchester attack.


The 2017 Tory manifesto made it an “objective” to meet the target but during the general election campaign Ms May said she “would be working” to achieve the target by 2022.