There's Now a Birth-Control Gel, but Is It the Right Choice For You? Ob-Gyns Break It Down

Kacie Main
·6-min read
Cropped shot of an affectionate young couple kissing intimately in their bedroom at home
Cropped shot of an affectionate young couple kissing intimately in their bedroom at home

Editor's Note: We at POPSUGAR recognize that people of many genders and identities have vaginas and uteruses, not just those who are women. For this particular story, we interviewed experts who generally referred to people with vaginas and uteruses as women.

There's a new birth control in town. Phexxi is an FDA-approved, nonhormonal birth-control gel - yes, gel - that can be used on demand to help prevent pregnancy. This prescription vaginal gel is unlike any other contraceptive on the market. It isn't taken daily, like the pill. It doesn't use synthetic hormones, like the Depo shot, ring, pill, or certain IUDs. And it doesn't require anything to be implanted into your body. So, is it too good to be true? POPSUGAR asked experts about the pros and cons so you can make a more informed decision on whether it's the right option for you.

How Does Phexxi Work?

Phexxi is a pH modulator and works by maintaining a natural vaginal pH of 3.5 to 4.5. Aparna Sridhar, MD, a board-certified ob-gyn and associate clinical professor in obstetrics and gynecology at the David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA, explained that the natural vaginal pH of people of reproductive age is low, creating an acidic environment where sperm cannot thrive.

Typically, sperm can overcome this hurdle. "When semen enters the vagina, the pH in the vagina increases, which allows sperm to remain mobile and make their way up the reproductive tract and fertilize the egg," Charis Chambers, MD, a board-certified ob-gyn, told POPSUGAR. "Phexxi works by maintaining the natural acidic state in a woman's vagina that reduces sperm mobility and decreases the chance it will get to an egg to fertilize it."

Phexxi is available by prescription only and comes in individually wrapped, single-dose, prefilled applicators that are inserted into the vagina like a tampon. It can be used immediately before intercourse or up to an hour ahead, but it's important to note that Phexxi must be reapplied every time you have sex, and it isn't effective if used after the fact. Phexxi is a viscous, bioadhesive gel designed to adhere to the walls of the vagina - meaning, you don't have to worry about leakage - and it can also be used with other forms of birth control, with the exception of the vaginal ring.

Related: Getting an IUD Helped Ease My Painful Periods, and I'm Never Going Back

How an IUD Helped Ease My Endometriosis Pain
How an IUD Helped Ease My Endometriosis Pain

How Effective Is Phexxi at Preventing Pregnancy?

The clinical trial for Phexxi resulted in 14 pregnancies per 100 users over the course of seven cycles, making it 86 percent effective in preventing pregnancy. This puts it on the same level of effectiveness as condoms (which are 85 percent effective) and makes it less effective than the pill (90 percent), the shot (94 percent), the ring (91 percent), or an IUD (99 percent).

Susan Mitchell, MD, a board-certified ob-gyn at Northwestern Medicine Delnor Hospital, explained that the rate of effectiveness is a direct result of the way Phexxi works. "It doesn't necessarily kill the sperm," Dr. Mitchell told POPSUGAR. "It just decreases their motility, so it's harder for them to reach and fertilize an egg."

Are There Other Advantages of Using Phexxi?

Phexxi has several advantages over other forms of contraceptives. "Phexxi is on demand, fast acting, and works immediately, whereas hormonal birth control must be used consistently in order for it to be effective," Dr. Chambers said. She explained that you also don't have to deal with the side effects that often accompany hormonal birth-control options, like weight gain, acne, mood swings, or more severe events like blood clots and depression.

Phexxi also gives you more control than other contraceptives, in more ways than one. Like other nonhormonal methods, Phexxi is immediately reversible, Dr. Sridhar explained - when you want to conceive, simply stop using it, and it will no longer prevent you from becoming pregnant. Dr. Mitchell added that it also allows you to take the lead: "Some women have a hard time using condoms for contraception because they have to rely on a partner to use the condom correctly."

Related: Exactly What to Do If a Condom Breaks During Sex, According to Experts

What to Do If a Condom Breaks During Sex
What to Do If a Condom Breaks During Sex

Does Phexxi Have Any Side Effects?

Phexxi reports that the most common side effects are vaginal burning, itching, yeast infection, urinary tract infection, vaginal area discomfort, bacterial vaginosis, and vaginal discharge. Some users have also reported genital discomfort, pain while urinating, and vaginal pain. (Notably, about 10 percent of partners in clinical studies also reported experiencing genital discomfort.)

Only you can decide whether the possibility of experiencing side effects is enough to dissuade you. "The vaginal biome is a delicate balance of just the right kinds of bacteria regulating their own environment," Dr. Mitchell told POPSUGAR. "Using a gel that could be toxic to healthy bacteria and irritating to the sensitive vulvar and vaginal tissue in exchange for not-super-reliable contraception might not be an acceptable trade-off for many women."

Additionally, while some people may be drawn to the lack of hormones, others may consider it a negative. Dr. Chambers pointed out that many people choose hormonal birth-control methods because of the benefits beyond preventing pregnancy. The hormones in birth control can help regulate your cycle, clear up acne, and ease menstrual cramps, among other things.

How to Decide If Phexxi Is Right For You

There's a lot to consider when trying to decide if this is the method of birth control for you. First, be aware of the risk of side effects. There were a few cases of urinary bladder infection and kidney infection reported in clinical studies. Because of this, Phexxi is not recommended for people who have had recurrent urinary tract infections or other urinary tract problems.

Beyond that, the decision may come down to how often you're having sex and the stage of life you're in. "For women who may not be having sex every day, it might not make sense to take a hormonal pill every day or have an IUD," Dr. Chambers said. However, it's important to remember that, unlike condoms, Phexxi will not protect against sexually transmitted infections.

You also have to consider Phexxi's failure rate. How comfortable you are with the possibility of getting pregnant will vary depending on your life circumstance, Dr. Sridhar explained. Dr. Mitchell noted that Phexxi could be helpful for people who are coming off hormonal birth control and have plans to try to conceive soon but not quite yet. "Phexxi could help you try to time a pregnancy, as long as you would not be too disappointed if you conceived a cycle or two earlier than you intended," Dr. Mitchell explained.

Ultimately, it's a big decision and an individual one. "Overall, when it comes to choosing a birth control, every woman is unique in their preference," Dr. Chambers told POPSUGAR. "There is no one-size-fits-all birth-control option, so it's important that you educate yourself about the various options available to you and speak with your doctor."