• Home
  • Mail
  • News
  • Sport
  • Finance
  • Celebrity
  • Style
  • Weather
  • Answers
  • Flickr
  • Mobile
  • More
Yahoo
    News Home
    Follow us
    • UK
    • Yahoo Originals
    • General Election 17
    • World
    • Finance
    • Celebrity
    • Sport
    • Science & Tech
    • Motoring
    • TV
    • Movies
    • Style
    • Weather
    • News Video
    • Viral

    U.S. free-speech group sues Trump for blocking Twitter users

    By Dustin Volz
    Reuters11 July 2017

    By Dustin Volz

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) - A free-speech group on Tuesday sued U.S. President Donald Trump for blocking Twitter users from his @realDonaldTrump account, arguing the practice violates the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.

    The lawsuit, brought by the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University in New York and joined by seven individual Twitter users, claims Trump blocked a number of accounts whose owners replied to his tweets with comments that criticized, mocked or disagreed with the president.

    Trump's blocking of the accounts amounted to an unconstitutional effort to suppress dissent, according to the lawsuit filed in federal court in the Southern District of New York.

    Because Trump frequently turns to Twitter to make policy statements, his account qualifies as a public forum from which the government cannot exclude people on the basis of their views, according to the lawsuit. Twitter users are unable to see or respond to tweets from accounts that block them.

    The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Last month White House spokesman Sean Spicer said Trump's tweets were considered "official statements by the president of the United States."

    The suit names Spicer and Dan Scavino, the White House director of social media, as defendants in addition to Trump. It asks for the blocking to be deemed unconstitutional and seeks an injunction to require the president to unblock users.

    The complaint follows a letter from the Knight Institute to Trump last month warning it would sue if users were not unblocked.

    "Everyone being able to see the president's tweets feels vital to democracy," Joseph Papp, one of the seven Twitter users involved in the suit, said in a statement.

    Papp, an author, said he had been a registered Republican for 10 years and did not join the suit for political reasons, but that he "felt a deep sense of unease" when he was blocked.

    Trump's Twitter use has drawn intense interest for his unvarnished commentary about his agenda and attacks on critics. His tweets often lead to tens of thousands of retweets and comments and can shape the news.

    The Knight Institute's arguments may have merit, independent free speech and internet law scholars say, in part because Trump's tweets are used to announce policy decisions or can influence legislation. Previous cases involving politicians blocking users on Facebook may bolster its case.

    The federal suit, case number 1:17-cv-05205, was filed in the Southern District of New York.

    Related:

    (Editing by Bill Rigby and Jeffrey Benkoe)

    What to read next

    • Does Citizens United give Donald Jr., Kushner and Manafort an out for their Russia Meeting?

      Newsweek
    • Melania Trump prays at Paris's Notre Dame cathedral

      AFP
    • Women's Tennis Association Asks Fans To Vote For 'Best Dressed' Female Player, Gets Served

      HuffPost UK
    • Trump joins Macron as Bastille Day guest of honour

      euronews Videos
    • CBS News forms partnership with BBC, replacing Sky

      Reuters
    • Mysterious ‘rogue planet’ floating through space may be even stranger than we thought

      Yahoo News UK
    • Facebook Crime: Sexual Assault Live Stream Goes Viral in Latest Teen Violence Post

      Newsweek
    • Trump's Most Awkward Handshakes

      Yahoo UK Originals
    • Pictures of the week: Birthdays, bulls and blue whales

    • Now Eric Trump Is Accused of Stealing From a Cancer Charity

      Newsweek
    • In pictures: Duchess of Cambridge unveils 'Hope' the whale at Natural History Museum

    • Mike Ashley's Sports Direct buys big stake in troubled Game Digital

      Sky News
    • Pride in pictures: The most iconic images

      Yahoo UK Originals
    • Photos: Wild Lion Adopts Leopard Cub, an Unprecedented Sight

      Newsweek
    • My Yorkshire jungle! Plant lover spends £15,000 over 20 years turning garden into rainforest paradise

    • Brexit: Govt accepts it will settle ongoing financial obligations with EU

      Yahoo Finance UK
    • How Long Could Israel Survive Without America?

      Newsweek
    • From New York to London: These are the best cities in the world in 2017

    • Women will be allowed to fight in close combat in the RAF for the first time this year

      International Business Times
    • Huge fire rips through London's Camden Market

      Press Association video
    • Woman dies climbing on fence to get better view of plane landing in the Caribbean

      Yahoo News UK
    • Pride in Pictures: Images from London's Pride Parade

    • Exclusive: Southampton have NOT re-opened talks with Liverpool over Virgil van Dijk

      Yahoo Sport UK
    • ‘Beautiful,’ Trump Says of Brigitte Macron After Eyeballing French First Lady on Paris Trip

      Newsweek
    • Pictures of the week: Paris, protests and Pride

    • 96-year-old widow threatened with deportation from Australia after moving to be with her only family

      Yahoo News UK
    • Video warns Brits of holiday terror attacks

      Press Association video
    • The Philippine container ship that crashed into a US guided-missile destroyer may be liable for almost $2 billion

      Business Insider UK
    • The Royal Navy photographer of the year 2017 - In pictures

    • Who Is Brigitte Macron? France’s First Lady and President Have Reverse Age Gap of Donald, Melania Trump

      Newsweek
    • Wife says 'never go to bed angry' after waking from row to find husband dead on sofa

      Yahoo News UK
    • The best of the concrete jungles: National Geographic's cities photographer of the year

    • Cows on a Plane: 165 Bovines Airlifted to Qatar to Meet Milk Demand, Circumvent Saudi Blockade

      Newsweek
    By using Yahoo you agree that Yahoo and partners may use Cookies for personalisation and other purposes