Harvard student speaker denounces university over Gaza protest response

Gloria Oladipo
·2-min read
<span>Shruthi Kumar gives the senior English address at Harvard on Thursday.</span><span>Photograph: Mark Stockwell/EPA</span>
Shruthi Kumar gives the senior English address at Harvard on Thursday.Photograph: Mark Stockwell/EPA

A graduating Harvard University student went off script and upbraided Harvard over the university’s treatment of students protesting against what they say is a genocide being carried out by Israel in Gaza.

“As I stand here today, I must take a moment to recognize my peers – the 13 undergraduates in the class of 2024 that will not graduate today,” said student Shruthi Kumar, who was chosen to deliver the English commencement remarks for the undergraduate class.

Kumar’s thoughts were widely supported by other Harvard students. More than 1,000 students walked out of the ceremony as part of a staged protest, many waving Palestinian flags or banners calling for an end to genocide.

The unscripted remarks came as 13 pro-Palestine students were barred from graduating for their involvement in campus protests, the Harvard Crimson reported, even after a majority of the university’s faculty of arts and sciences voted for the students to have their degrees conferred.

The Harvard Corporation, the university’s governing body, voted on Wednesday to halt the students’ graduation.

Kumar’s original speech was previously on The Power of Not Knowing, encouraging students to embrace uncertainty as they transition on from school, according to the Harvard Gazette.

But at Thursday’s morning ceremony, Kumar delivered off-script remarks that largely focused on Harvard’s punishment of protesting students and overall censorship.

“I am deeply disappointed by the intolerance for freedom of speech and the right to civil disobedience on campus,” she said. “The students had spoken. The faculty had spoken.”

Kumar added: “Harvard, do you hear us?” She received widespread applause and a standing ovation.

The headlining commencement speaker also addressed Harvard’s treatment of pro-Palestine student activists.

Maria Ressa, a Noble peace prize laureate and journalist, warned Harvard not to silence student protesters. “Harvard, you are being tested,” Ressa said.

“The campus protests are testing everyone in America. Protests give voice; they shouldn’t be silenced.”

The remarks from Kumar and Ressa underline the tensions at Harvard and other universities after the crackdowns on pro-Palestine student protesters.

A pro-Palestine student demonstration at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor was broken up by police. Police also cracked down on a demonstration at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. At least six student protesters were arrested there.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Teachers Are Revealing The Worst Thing They've Ever Caught A Student Doing, And I Have No Words

    "A little girl walked up to another girl who was sitting on the rug reading a book, grabbed her by the hair, and..."

  • Outcry as university tells staff to teach that whiteness and heterosexuality are a problem

    History lecturers at the University of Liverpool have been advised to “problematise” whiteness and heterosexuality in their seminars.

  • ‘Look my son in the eye and tell him why Labour will ruin his education’

    A military mother told Sir Keir Starmer to look her 10-year-old son in the eye and “explain why Labour is planning to ruin his education” by imposing VAT on private schools.

  • Islamic State prisoners ‘liquidated’ as Russian authorities end jail siege

    Islamic State prisoners who took two guards hostage in a Russian jail have been killed and their captives freed, officials said on Sunday.

  • How England’s top private schools came to own 38,000 acres of land

    Students at top fee-paying institutions benefit from centuries of philanthropy originally intended to help the poor

  • Eight Israeli soldiers killed in Gaza armoured vehicle blast

    Eight Israeli soldiers were killed in Rafah on Saturday when their armoured vehicle was hit by a “major explosion”.

  • Students going home could put 35 Tory seats at risk in election, analysis says

    Higher Education Policy Institute research suggests that holding ballot in summer break may be strategic error

  • Teachers and GPs ‘staggering’ under extra demands caused by poverty in Great Britain

    Schools and health services forced to offer crisis help in the form of food, clothing, money and advice

  • Israel announces 'tactical pauses' in Gaza fighting

    STORY: :: Beit Jann, IsraelMourners on Sunday buried Israeli military officer Wassem Mahmoud, the commander who was killed in the Gaza Strip along with seven of his soldiers on Saturday. At the funeral, an officer said Mahmoud led his soldiers "with bravery, determination and professionalism."Mahmoud was a member of Israel's Druze minority, a sect whose faith draws its roots from Islam. The Israeli military said Mahmoud and his squad were traveling inside an armored personnel carrier in a convoy of vehicles in the southern city of Rafah on Saturday.Here's army spokesperson Daniel Hagari::: June 15, 2024"According to the information we have, at this point a strong explosion occurred in one of the engineering vehicles in the convoy, apparently caused by an explosive device planted in the area or as a result of an anti-tank missile being fired. Inside the armored carrier were the eight fighters who were killed."The armed wing of the Hamas militant group said the vehicle had been trapped in a prepared minefield.Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Sunday called the casualties "another heartbreaking price in our just war for the defense of our homeland."And he pledged again to stick with his military objectives: the destruction of the Hamas militant group and the return of all Israeli hostages held in Gaza.:: Israel Police via XOn Saturday, the Israeli police released this footage purporting to show parts of an operation last weekend that rescued 26-year-old Noa Argamani and three others who were taken captive on October 7. Reuters was not able to independently verify the date or the location the video was filmed.:: Jabalia Refugee Camp, Gaza:: October 14, 2023Despite growing international pressure for a ceasefire, an agreement to halt the fighting still appears distant, more than eight months since the start of the war in the Palestinian enclave.:: Rafah, Gaza:: June 13, 2024But Israel's military on Sunday said it would hold daily tactical pauses in combat operations along a main road in southern Gaza to allow more aid to flow into the area.:: October 7, 2023The war erupted when Hamas fighters rampaged through southern Israel on October 7, killing 1,200 and taking more than 250 captives, according to Israeli tallies.:: Source: Israeli militaryIsrael's retaliatory airstrikes and ground invasion have killed more than 37,000 Palestinians, according to the Gaza health ministry.:: Jabalia, GazaIsraeli forces have been closing in on Rafah, where it claims brigades of Hamas fighters remain entrenched.

  • Security forces 'kill' IS hostage takers in Russian detention centre

    Security forces killed inmates who had taken two members of staff hostage at the centre in Rostov-on-Don, state news agency RIA Novosti reported.

  • Carnage and Contradiction: Examining a Deadly Strike in Rafah

    Fear plagued Saleh Mohammed al-Hila, 37, on that Sunday. “I was lying on the ground of the tent and told my son, ‘May God save us from this night,’” he recalled. Hamas had launched rockets at central Israel hours earlier, setting off air-raid sirens in the Tel Aviv area for the first time in months. Israel’s military said the barrage had been fired from Rafah — the city in the southern Gaza Strip where Israeli forces were advancing and al-Hila was sheltering with his family in a camp for displac

  • US warship destroys two Houthi drone boats in Red Sea

    The United States has unleashed a wave of attacks on Houthi sites, destroying seven radars, one drone and two unmanned bomb boats in Yemen in the past 24 hours, its military said.

  • Top ISIS leader in Somalia was target of US airstrike

    A United States military airstrike in Somalia targeted the top Islamic State leader in late May, but it remains unclear if the leader was killed in the airstrike, according to U.S. officials. Abdulqadir Mumin has been identified by the U.S. as the head of the Islamic State in Somalia, an African affiliate of the terror group once known as ISIS. A statement from U.S. Africa Command disclosed that on May 31 it had conducted an airstrike in a remote area of northeastern Somalia, south of the Gulf of Aden, that killed three militants affiliated with the Islamic State.

  • 'Inspirational' hospital school retains top rating after Ofsted inspection

    An academy in Truro has retained its 'Outstanding' rating by Ofsted after a recent inspection

  • Israel's Netanyahu pledges to stick to war goals

    STORY: :: June 15, 2024:: Tel Aviv, Israel:: Benjamin Netanyahu, Israeli Prime Minister"Israeli citizens, today we paid another heartbreaking price in our just war for the defense of the homeland. In deep sorrow, in heavy mourning, I bow my head together with all the citizens of Israel and mourn the fall of our heroic warriors.""Despite the heavy and staggering cost, we must stick to the goals of the war: the destruction of Hamas' military and governmental capabilities, the return of all our hostages, ensuring that Gaza no longer poses a threat to Israel and the safe return of our residents to their homes - both in the north and in the south."The eight soldiers were killed in the southern Gaza Strip on Saturday, Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari said in a televised news conference, as forces continued to push in and around the southern city of Rafah and strikes hit several areas of Gaza, killing at least 19 Palestinians.The deaths of the soldiers may complicate the political situation facing Netanyahu, a week after centrist former general Benny Gantz quit the government, accusing the PM of having no proper strategy for Gaza.The soldiers, all members of a combat engineering unit, were in an armored carrier that was hit by an explosion that detonated engineering materials being carried on the vehicle, apparently in contravention of standard practice, Hagari said.The armed wing of the Palestinian militant group Hamas said the vehicle had been trapped in a prepared minefield that set off the explosion.

  • Israel rejects Macron’s initiative to defuse Hezbollah conflict

    Israel’s defence minister has rejected Emmanuel Macron’s initiative to work together on defusing an escalating conflict along the northern border with Lebanon.

  • Quarter million protest in France against far right: police

    Some 250,000 people took to the streets across France on Saturday to protest the rise of the far right after their success in European polls prompted President Emmanuel Macron to call legislative elections, police said.In Paris, police estimated 75,000 people had responded to a call from unions, associations and a new left-wing political coalition formed for the parliamentary elections.

  • Palestinian Supporters Descend Upon Downtown Los Angeles Ahead of President Biden Fundraiser

    Hundreds of protesters have descended on Downtown Los Angeles around L.A. Live on late Saturday afternoon, attempting to block entrances and disrupt proceedings ahead of a big-ticket fundraiser for President Joe Biden at Peacock Theater. Shortly after 5 p.m. PT, uniformed officers were seen rushing towards one group of protesters as they attempted to block …

  • 'I live in Greater Manchester, so why does my local council want to send my daughter to London?'

    The despondent mum is wanting her child to get an education and get qualifications

  • Police Allege Man Punched Sixth-Grader in Racist Hate Crime

    A white man in Washington has been arrested and placed on a $500,000 bail after allegedly targeting and attacking a Black sixth-grade student walking with classmates during a field trip.Paul Jonathan Bittner, 42, has been charged with malicious harassment and the assault of a child in the second-degree, according to the Whatcom County Jail.During a walking field trip to a nearby film center Wednesday, students from Whatcom Middle School, part of the Bellingham School District, were near the Bell