Liverpool named better than Manchester, York and more for UK city break

Liverpool has been named the UK’s best large city for a break, beating Manchester, York and Edinburgh, in a new Which? survey

The consumer champion surveyed almost 4,000 members about their experiences of visiting UK cities and towns in the last two years. All were scored out of five stars on a range of criteria including accommodation, food and drink, cultural sights and tourist attractions, ease of getting around, lack of crowds, and value for money.

An overall city score was calculated based on visitors’ overall satisfaction and likeliness to recommend. Liverpool took top spot in the large cities category with a city score of 84% - beating capital cities Belfast (77%), London (76%), Cardiff (72%) and Liverpool’s close neighbour Manchester (71%) by some margin.

READ MORE: One of world's cheapest beach holidays you can fly to from Liverpool

READ MORE: Taylor Swift Liverpool plans in full as city to become 'Taylor Town'

Liverpool scored a full five stars in the cultural sights and tourist attractions category, with respondents noting an impressive range of cultural and historical attractions beyond the Beatles. The city also scored four stars for food and drink, shopping, accommodation, lack of crowds and value for money.

One reviewer said: "It's got everything you could possibly want. Great for eating places, great for sights and famous places and very friendly people." Taking joint second place in the large cities category are Edinburgh and York, with tied city scores of 83%.

Rory Boland, Editor of Which? Travel, said: "Whether you’re after vibrant nightlife, world class museums or a first rate dining experience, our survey shows that the UK has a wealth of fantastic cities just waiting to be explored.

"Liverpool stood out among the UK’s large cities for its fantastic cultural scene and buzzing atmosphere, beating London and the UK’s other capital cities to take first place. For those seeking a more laid-back destination, Somerset is the place to be, with both Bath and Wells scoring highly, and each offering a wealth of historical and cultural sights."

Full results tables for large, medium and small city results can be found here. The Scottish capital, Edinburgh, is “bursting with cultural activities” according to visitors, who scored it a full five stars for cultural sights and tourist attractions.

Edinburgh received four stars for food and drink, shopping, ease of getting around, and overall value for money. While York, known for its Roman and Viking heritage, also took five stars in the cultural sights and tourist attractions category, with some of its most well known attractions including York Minster, the National Railway Museum and the Jorvik Viking Centre. The city also scored four stars for shopping, accommodation, ease of getting around, value for money and food and drink.

Among medium-sized cities, Bath was the top scorer, receiving a city score of 82%. With a five star rating for cultural sights and tourist attractions, one visitor described Bath as “one of the top sites in the UK, indeed Europe,” for its architecture and points of historical interest, which include the well preserved Roman baths and the Georgian houses of the Royal Crescent. The city also scored four stars for food and drink, accommodation and shopping, and three stars for value for money.

Wells, Somerset was the highest scoring location in the survey overall, with an impressive city score of 86% and took first place in the small cities category. It scored four stars for its range of cultural sights and tourist attractions which include the Cathedral, Bishop’s Palace and Vicar’s Close.

At the opposite end of the tables, Derby (56%), Leicester (58%) and Swansea (58%) were the lowest rated large cities. Derby scored just two stars for food and drink, accommodation, cultural sights and tourist attractions, shopping and ease of getting around. One visitor noted that while “there are not a huge number of cultural sights within the city centre, the Museum of Making is worth a visit.”