Millions will be doomed to a difficult retirement if this tax is not scrapped

Paul Diggle
·2-min read
Stamp Duty Tax
Stamp Duty Tax

Successive governments have provided stimulus after stimulus to encourage property buying. It’s easy to understand why – housing affordability is a major challenge, especially for the young.

But by encouraging house price inflation, tax breaks could well be making the problem worse in the long run.

Just as more people face renting for longer or even paying off a mortgage into retirement, pension planning looks equally precarious, as “defined benefit” pensions have withered on the vine.

Despite this, much-needed support to encourage a culture of saving and investing has been left by the wayside.

Yes, some savings tax allowances are generous, but only for those able to fully utilise them.

The Conservative manifesto is the latest example of this trend to prioritise property over pensions. It includes several property-focused policies – among them stamp duty cuts for first-time buyers, a new version of Help to Buy, and a target to build 1.6 million homes.

Where are the policies to encourage a healthy culture of saving and investing outside of property?

There was a fleeting mention of the proposed NatWest share sale, but no detail on how this could be broadened into a wider movement.

The majority of Britons are not saving enough for a comfortable retirement. According to the Pensions Policy Institute, 63pc of individuals in Britain are not on track for an adequate pension to live off in later life.

Our research has found that the average person’s property is worth six times more than the value of their pension – £250,000 compared with £37,500 (excluding those with defined benefit pensions).

Owning a home is an important aspiration for most of us. But it cannot be the be-all and end-all of personal financial planning, particularly as a property cannot always be easily sold to raise cash when needed.

We think that abolishing stamp duty on shares could be a fair and impactful policy, with wider economic benefits.

It would benefit all of us wanting to invest in UK companies and UK-domiciled investment trusts and help to encourage a much-needed national culture of share ownership.

It could also help with the UK’s dismal productivity performance, by directing savings to productive uses in the real economy.

And it’s fair because it helps those even with modest means – you can invest with most investment platforms from £250, or £25 per month, rather than the tens of thousands needed for a deposit on a home.

It’s a step towards democratising finance.

It is in policymakers’ best interests to address our property-pensions imbalance – because ultimately it will be their job to figure out how we support the millions who are heading for a difficult retirement.

Paul Diggle is chief economist at Abrdn.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • This is the EU ancien regime’s last, contemptible hurrah

    Growth has ground to a halt. The economy is falling further behind North America and Asia, and populist parties campaigning to overthrow the system are gathering strength all the time.

  • Labour will come to regret its war on wealth

    Non-doms are an easy target. Both Labour and the Tories have pledged to crack down on them – but there will be unintended consequences they will come to regret.

  • How the Bank of England could hand Starmer an £11bn windfall

    Changes to the Bank of England’s bond-selling process could hand Sir Keir Starmer up to £11.6bn a year, economists have predicted.

  • July 2024 dates for benefits and pensions after cost of living payments

    The UK’s cost of living will be a major talking point in the run up to July’s general election

  • Who owns France's debt and why it matters

    President Emmanuel Macron's shock snap election has rocked France's bond market, the largest in the euro zone, as a strong showing for the far right and left wing parties in opinion polls exacerbates concerns about fiscal sustainability. Earlier in June, the risk premium France pays for its debt on top of Germany's neared levels last seen in 2012, during the euro zone debt crisis. The question is how much more turmoil the two-round elections on June 30 and July 7 could sow in bond markets.

  • India Plans ‘Historic Steps’ in Budget Under New Government

    (Bloomberg) -- Sign up for the India Edition newsletter by Menaka Doshi – an insider's guide to the emerging economic powerhouse, and the billionaires and businesses behind its rise, delivered weekly.Most Read from BloombergSupreme Court Poised to Allow Emergency Abortions in IdahoSpaceX Tender Offer Said to Value Company at Record $210 BillionSupreme Court Ends OxyContin Settlement, Cracking Sackler ShieldChina’s Finance Elite Face $400,000 Pay Cap, Bonus ClawbacksBolivia’s President Arce Swear

  • Analysis-France may be next test of the euro's foundations

    FRANKFURT/PARIS (Reuters) - "Because it's France" was how Jean-Claude Juncker, European Commission president at the time, explained Brussels' decision in 2016 to give leeway to the large, founder member of the European Union on the bloc's budget rules. That patience continued even as the EU endured a sovereign debt crisis that almost sunk the euro and forced smaller, more indebted nations such as Greece and Portugal to adopt swingeing austerity measures. But any indulgence for French exceptionalism may come to an end if France's snap election produces a eurosceptic, far-right government in Paris that could strain ties with other European capitals and test the very foundations of the euro project.

  • Labour frontbencher refuses to put price on net zero plan after audio leak

    A Labour frontbencher has refused to put a price on the party’s net zero plan after an audio leak revealed that it may be “hundreds of billions.”

  • True cost of Labour’s net zero target revealed in audio leak

    Reaching Labour’s target for decarbonising the economy will cost “hundreds of billions” of pounds, a shadow minister has disclosed in a recording obtained by The Telegraph.

  • Number of UK income tax payers leaps by 4.4m in three years due to threshold freeze

    HMRC data shows 26% more people over state pension age paying tax on earnings than in 2021-22

  • Kenyan president withdraws controversial tax bill amid deadly protests

    In a major turn of events, Kenyan President William Ruto announced Wednesday afternoon from the State House in Nairobi, Kenya, that he is withdrawing the contentious 2024 finance bill. "I will decline to assent to the bill," Ruto said. "I have agreed with MP's that it becomes our collective decision," said Ruto.

  • $3.4 trillion in individual tax cuts are expiring next year. Biden and Trump would handle it very differently

    Whoever wins the presidency in November will have some especially tough financial choices to make next year.

  • Even wealthy Americans are struggling to make ends meet

    About one in three Americans making six-figure salaries are worried about paying their bills, according to a new survey from the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia.

  • Ferrari to offer €7,000 subscription fee to replace electric car batteries

    Ferrari is to charge customers a €7,000 (£5,900) annual subscription fee in exchange for free battery replacements amid fears of burnout in its supercars.

  • Explainer-You Need to Calm Down: Why the Taylor Swift economy isn't real

    Taylor Swift is taking Europe by storm, prompting some pundits to envisage an economic windfall as fans flock to dozens of sold-out shows from Dublin to Vienna and beyond. It is hoped Swift, along with the Olympics Games in France and the Euro 2024 soccer championship in Germany will provide a shot in the arm for a continent that has just skirted recession for most of the past two years and badly lagged the United States. She may be a megastar revolutionising the music industry, but once the excitement wears off, you will need a magnifying glass to spot the economic benefit.

  • Fed Officials See 3 Possible Paths for Rates

    Faced with uncertainty, Fed officials are offering various scenarios for the economy and interest rates.

  • Sunak’s tourist tax ‘means Rolex shoppers have given up on Britain’

    Wealthy foreign shoppers seeking a Rolex have given up on Britain in favour of European cities such as Paris and Milan, the boss of the UK’s biggest luxury watch retailer has said.

  • Bulgaria can’t join the eurozone due to high inflation, ECB says

    Sofia had expressed hopes it could join the EU currency zone in the middle of next year, but must meet tough economic criteria.

  • Medicare Cutting Price of 64 Drugs That Outpaced Inflation

    (Bloomberg) -- Some of America’s seniors will see their out of pocket costs fall for more than five dozen drugs — including treatments for osteoporosis and cancer — as part of the White House’s crackdown on rising pharmaceutical prices. Most Read from BloombergSupreme Court Poised to Allow Emergency Abortions in IdahoBolivia’s President Arce Swears in New Army Chief After Coup BidChina’s Finance Elite Face $400,000 Pay Cap, Bonus ClawbacksFedEx Stokes Investors With Hint of a Freight DealYouTube

  • Don’t count on any more Trump tax cuts

    Tax hikes, not cuts, may be needed during the next presidential administration to deal with massive amounts of debt neither party can control.