Trump finally offers explanation for why he backed out of testifying in hush money trial

James Liddell
·3-min read

Donald Trump has finally offered some sort of explanation as to why he backtracked on plans to take the stand to testify in his hush money trial.

For weeks, Mr Trump flirted with the idea of standing to address his accusers in court, vowing he would “absolutely” take the stand just days before the criminal trial began on 15 April.

When the time came, however, Mr Trump did not take the stand. Instead, the defence rested its case on Tuesday after calling just on two witnesses including attorney Robert Costello.

Now, Mr Trump has claimed that the reason he didn’t take the stand because of the judge – and over fears that his “great”, albeit chequered, past might come back to haunt him.

“He (New York Justice Juan Merchan) made rulings that makes it very difficult to testify,” Mr Trump said in an interview on WABC Radio on Wednesday evening.

“Anything I did, anything I did in the past, they can bring everything up, and you know what, I’ve had a great past – but anything.”

Former President Donald Trump speaks alongside his attorney Todd Blanche outside the courtroom in Manhattan Criminal Court on May 21 (AP)
Former President Donald Trump speaks alongside his attorney Todd Blanche outside the courtroom in Manhattan Criminal Court on May 21 (AP)

He added: “The other reason is because they have no case. In other words, why would – why testify when they have no case?”

Mr Trump is charged with falsifying business records over alleged hush money payments to adult film star Stormy Daniels to silence her over an alleged affair ahead of the 2016 presidential election.

He denies the affair and has pleaded not guilty to all 34 felony counts against him.

Whether he came to the decision not to testify on his own accord or following the advice of his lawyers is not clear.

Back on 12 April, Mr Trump told reporters that he “would testify, absolutely”.

“I mean, all I can do is tell the truth. And the truth is that there’s no case, they have no case,” he added.

Then, after seven days of sitting in Manhattan’s criminal court, Mr Trump elicited a watered-down reponse, saying he would take the stand “if it’s necessary”.

Mr Trump continued to then toy with the idea.

Robert Costello was cross examined by prosecutor Susan Hoffinger before Justice Juan Merchan (REUTERS)
Robert Costello was cross examined by prosecutor Susan Hoffinger before Justice Juan Merchan (REUTERS)

While he has refused to speak about the case under oath, Mr Trump has repeatedly railed against the case in public, lashing out in daily comments to reporters in the hallways of the courthouse.

Mr Trump previously took the stand in his own defense during his civil fraud trial in New York last year.

But rather than answering questions directly, he seized on the opportunity to rant about his personal feelings about the case.

Legal experts told The Independent on Monday that Mr Trump taking the stand in his hush money triral would be an “act of near-insanity”.

“We have all seen Trump in action. We have all seen his inability to stick to a ‘party line’,” criminal defense lawyer Tony Wyatt told The Independent on Monday.

“Donald Trump is a cross-examiner’s dream, and whilst he would never admit that to himself, his lawyers must know it,” he added.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Are you ‘far-Right’? Take our quiz!

    We hear the term “far-Right” a lot these days. Or at least, we do if we get our news from the BBC, The Guardian or prominent Left-wing pundits. But what precisely do they mean by it? Unfortunately, they rarely say. They tend to just call a party, politician or group of voters “far-Right”, and leave it at that.

  • Trump Couldn’t Stop Gibbering in Front of Nation’s Biggest CEOs

    Former President Donald Trump left some of the country’s most powerful CEOs scratching their heads, cringing, or just outright laughing during a private meeting in the nation’s capital on Thursday.On MSNBC’s Morning Joe on Friday, CNBC anchor Andrew Ross Sorkin said he’d spoken to several CEOs who were at the gathering, including many who considered themselves pro-Trump. Among the attendees were Apple’s Tim Cook and JPMorgan Chase’s Jamie Dimon.“They walked away from that meeting, I think, a bit

  • A Russian tank stuck in a large crater became a sitting duck for Ukraine's drones, a video appears to show

    A video released by Ukraine's 68th Jaeger Brigade appears to show a Russian tank falling into a crater and exploding under Ukrainian fire.

  • Trump boasts of cognitive test, then flubs doctor's name

    Donald Trump is so proud of a cognitive assessment he took while president that he boasted about it in a speech Saturday, while attacking what he claims is US President Joe Biden's lack of mental acuity.As part of his attack on what he says is the 81-year-old Biden's declining mental acuity, Trump told the laughing crowd in Detroit that the president had been lost while at the G7 in Italy, turning "to look at trees," while other world leaders were looking at a parachutist who'd just landed in an

  • France is on the brink of all-out civil conflict

    As some 500,000 Left-wingers marched in France’s cities yesterday, shouting anti-Fascist slogans, never had Lenin’s phrase seemed more apposite: “There are decades where nothing happens; and there are weeks where decades happen.”

  • Huge poll predicts every seat in Scotland in General Election

    A FRESH poll has predicted the result of every seat in the General Election, with the Tories set to retain just one seat in Scotland.

  • Labour to slap higher council tax on homes with big gardens, say Tories

    Home owners with gardens will pay higher council tax under plans being considered by Labour, it is claimed.

  • Britain still doesn’t have a clue about the scale of the disaster heading its way

    Reform overtaking the Tories according to one poll is undoubtedly a watershed moment in British politics. But Nigel Farage’s suggestion that “a vote for the Conservatives is now a vote for Labour” isn’t quite right. Because Reform simply doesn’t have the numbers to replace the Tories; only to destroy them, with no clear idea of what would follow. When the red mist clears, what we’re going to be left with is a future far worse than even the wettest of Conservatives could muster.

  • Shunned by West, Russian army deserters live in fear

    Russian officer Farkhad Ziganshin had prepared himself for a life of military service since a young age.- 'Live with dignity' -  Ziganshin went to a military boarding school at the age of 10 and graduated from a military academy that prepares Russian tank commanders. 

  • Sorry, Sunak – what Britain needs is a leader who’s a bit nuts

    Guess who’s to blame for our nation’s woes? According to a Gallup report it’s the “quiet quitters” who are costing the economy £257 billion in lost output. They’re the reason our country has plunged down the league table of the wealthiest nations. And the people at Gallup have figured out that this lack of productivity stems from a growing sense of sadness, stress and anger; all of which cause that loss of motivation. The polling company supposes that only 10 per cent of the workforce puts extra

  • Ukraine proves it can target the Russian air force's weakest link

    Ukraine appears to have hit on a strategy to strike back at the Russian jets lobbing glide bombs at its defenses.

  • Her middle school security guard held her captive for 10 years. Now Tanya Kach is revealing how she survived a decade locked upstairs

    Tanya Kach was 14 years old when she vanished in 1996. A decade later, she was found at her middle school security guard’s home, where she was being kept captive. Now, with the help of fellow kidnapping survivor Elizabeth Smart, she’s telling her story. Andrea Cavallier reports

  • Brian Cox rails against Brexit and Nigel Farage on BBC politics programme

    ‘Succession’ star argued that politicians are not sufficiently acknowledging the effects of leaving the EU

  • If the Right can’t unite, Starmer will change Britain beyond recognition

    If the polls are accurate, our great country is sleepwalking into a very dangerous future. In just 19 days’ time, the UK could be run by more than 500 Left-wing MPs. We are on the brink of a one-party state that will change our country for the worse.

  • How Ukraine’s surplus Western missiles humbled Putin’s billion dollar Crimea defences

    The night sky over Crimea flashed with explosions and tracer fire as the barrage of American-made missiles arrived and found their targets.

  • Swiss right-wing leader calls Ukraine summit an 'embarrassment'

    A leading Swiss right-wing nationalist panned a summit his country was hosting in a bid to pressure Russia to end its war on Ukraine as an "embarrassment", reflecting the view that the talks are damaging for Switzerland's traditional neutrality. The right-wing Swiss Peoples' Party (SVP), the biggest group in the lower house of parliament, says neutrality is an integral part of Switzerland's prosperity, and it has initiated a referendum to embed the principle in the constitution. Leading figures in the party have argued Switzerland should not have hosted this weekend's summit without Russia, and Nils Fiechter, chief of the SVP's youth wing, delivered a damning verdict on the talks to Russian broadcaster RT.

  • Fresh poll predicts Tories will win just 72 seats in next parliament

    Two polls published today spell bad news for Rishi Sunak, with one showing a drop of four points and the other that his party is on course to pick up just 72 seats. A poll by Savanta for The Sunday Telegraph showed the Tories down four points to just 21% of the vote - the lowest by that pollster since the dying days of Theresa May's premiership in early 2019. In a boost for Nigel Farage, the poll showed Reform UK up three points with 13% of the vote.

  • The toxic legacy of lockdown is destroying our political system

    I have never known a general election like this one. I cannot remember a national campaign in my lifetime in which the only question for voters was who they hated less.

  • Letters: Once-loyal Tories wish to see Conservatism reborn after years of Blairite betrayal

    SIR – As a long-term member of the Conservative Party, I cannot wait to see the back of this totally incompetent Government. These Blairites must never be allowed to return. There are a few good MPs, like Penny Mordaunt, and I can only hope that they will join together with Nigel Farage to form a new, invigorated and competent Conservative Party. Meanwhile, I’ll vote for Reform UK. David Bowen Lyme Regis, Dorset

  • ‘Look my son in the eye and tell him why Labour will ruin his education’

    A military mother told Sir Keir Starmer to look her 10-year-old son in the eye and “explain why Labour is planning to ruin his education” by imposing VAT on private schools.