Why you shouldn’t take pebbles from the beach – here’s the science

Suzana Ilic, Senior Lecturer, Lancaster Environment Centre, Lancaster University and Joseph Earl, PhD Candidate, Lancaster Environment Centre, Lancaster University
·3-min read
<span class="attribution"><span class="source">Mr.Teerapong Kunkaeo / shutterstock</span></span>
Mr.Teerapong Kunkaeo / shutterstock

Cumberland Council in the north of England has announced that people taking pebbles from beaches will now face fines of up to £1,000. Many people found the announcement frustrating, but preventing erosion is critical, as research shows.

For many people, visiting the beach brings back joyful childhood memories. It is easy to forget that the sand and pebbles provide an important habitat for many creatures. It also provides natural protection for homes and infrastructure from the power of the sea.

Many people will have collected the odd souvenir stone, or perhaps even taken bags of pebbles for their garden rockeries. More avid enthusiasts are fascinated by the diversity of pebble types, colours, shapes and even fossils found on beaches, transported there from past glaciers or eroded cliffs nearby.

Yet it is a little-known fact that it is unlawful to remove any materials from the beach in the UK. It is a law enshrined in the 1949 Coastal Protection Act, curbing historic losses of hundreds of thousands of tonnes of sediment from beaches by people extracting “free” sediment for building materials.

Bird sat in pebbles
Bird sat in pebbles

Lengths of pebble beaches in England are also legally protected for their environmental qualities, designated by Natural England for the habitats they provide and species that rely on them. But for people who live near these beaches, one of the main values of pebbles comes through reducing coastal erosion and flooding.

The volume of the beach is critical to how effective it is at reducing both risks. In effect, the more pebbles and sediment on the beach, the more able the beach is to absorb wave energy. Removing lots of pebbles, sand or other sediment makes the beach less able to act as a natural barrier to flooding and erosion.

This volume changes naturally over the year, as the beach adjusts to changes in waves over the seasons. Pebbles are transported on and off the beach by waves, sorting different sediment sizes into distinct regions of the beach. More energetic waves during winter storms can transport larger sediment to the upper beach and form a steep ridge of pebbles known as a berm.

Pebble beach
Pebble beach

The berm at the top of the beach is often the first form of natural defence from storms, absorbing and dissipating wave energy and reducing the risk of waves carrying beyond the beach or undercutting and eroding sea walls or cliffs at their rear.

It all adds up

While one person taking a few pebbles from the beach may not significantly affect the berm or the overall beach volume, the cumulative effect of many people removing numerous pebbles may be more significant. Removing pebbles can disturb the beach’s natural sorting processes and interrupt its overall dynamic balance.

Given the importance of retaining sediment in the system for flood and erosion protection, there is ongoing research to better understand how pebble beaches respond to waves and storms. This research is particularly important for assessing the effectiveness of artificially created cobble beaches at providing protection from coastal flooding and erosion risks.

Monitoring sediment transport is key to advancing this research, with emerging low-cost and citizen science techniques being used to track sediment after it has been eroded from the beach.

In a changing climate, where these risks are predicted to be more intense and frequent, there is a pressing need to retain sediment on beaches and allow the natural coastal protection and habitat benefits to thrive.

Asking people not to take pebbles from the beach may appear trivial and insignificant, but it can help beaches play an effective role in protecting our coasts.

Imagine weekly climate newsletter
Imagine weekly climate newsletter

Don’t have time to read about climate change as much as you’d like?
Get a weekly roundup in your inbox instead. Every Wednesday, The Conversation’s environment editor writes Imagine, a short email that goes a little deeper into just one climate issue. Join the 30,000+ readers who’ve subscribed so far.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The Conversation
The Conversation

Joseph Earl is affiliated with Morecambe Bay Partnership.

Suzana Ilic was a coastal advisor to the North West Regional Flood and Coastal Committee between 2019 and 2023.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • 'Mysterious' carnivorous sharks found lurking in the depths of British waters

    As shark season approaches in the UK, are you aware of the giant 400-year-old sharks that can be found in our waters?

  • At last, a Just Stop Oil protest I can get on board with

    This week Just Stop Oil conducted its best and worst protests to date. By spraying Stonehenge with orange powder, the protesters once again united the country in a collective groan of tired disdain. But then, less than 24 hours later, they pulled off their most relevant stunt to date.

  • Bear Floating in Pond Is the Picture of Summer Bliss

    Sonya the bear was “truly delightful to behold” as she floated with her paws up in a pond at the Orphaned Wildlife Center, according to those running the New York sanctuary.“Notice how she effortlessly floats with her toes adorably protruding,” the center wrote on YouTube.Founded by Jim Kowalczik, Susan Kowalczik, and Kerry Clair in 2015, the OrphanedWildlife Center, in Otisville nurtures its animal residents in the hope they can be returned to the wild.The center often shares videos and updates about the animals in its care to its YouTube channel and Facebook page. Credit: Orphaned Wildlife Center via Storyful

  • Future of new oil and gas projects in UK thrown into doubt after landmark Supreme Court decision

    The future of new oil and gas projects in the UK has been thrown into doubt following a landmark decision by the Supreme Court. The court concluded the environmental impact of emissions from burning fossil fuels must be considered in planning applications for new extraction projects - not just the impacts of the emissions produced in extracting them. The case hinged around an oil drilling project at Horse Hill in Surrey, granted planning permission by Surrey County Council in 2019.

  • Culling wolves alters the survivors and that could be 'bad news' for caribou, study finds

    When wolves are killed by bullets fired from helicopters during Alberta government culls, surviving members of the pack quickly learn to evade the threat, a new study has found. For nearly two decades, Alberta has killed off hundreds of grey wolves each year in an attempt to bolster dwindling caribou populations, a practice critics have described as a misguided measure to help herds on the brink recover from habitat loss.New research sheds light on how the practice alters the surviving wolves an

  • Sir Jim Ratcliffe attacks Labour plans days after backing Starmer

    Labour’s green energy plans will tax the North Sea “out of existence”, Sir Jim Ratcliffe has warned, days after he publicly backed Sir Keir Starmer.

  • Hunter mistakenly kills grizzly bear, but it wasn’t hunter’s mistake

    After an investigation that left the Idaho Fish and Game in an embarrassing position, the hunter was not issued a citation.

  • Tiger Tinder! Amur tigers meet for first date at Woburn Safari Park

    Five-year-old male tiger Dmitri and 12-year-old female tiger Minerva have been on their first date at Woburn Safari Park this month. The stunning Amur tigers, which are listed as 'Endangered' in the wild by the International Union for Conservation of Nature, could be seen fondly greeting each other and relaxing together shortly after their initial introduction, just metres away from excited visitors' cars. Keepers are delighted that Dmitri and Minerva (known as Vera) have taken such a shine to e

  • A German town's referendum on culling pigeons has led to an uproar by animal rights activists

    An ongoing fight between residents and animal rights activists over whether to cull pigeons in a small German town has led to an uproar — even though a majority of the residents voted in favor of culling the birds in a referendum earlier this month. On Thursday, officials in the central German town of Limburg were still considering whether to proceed with the referendum results. “There is no timetable for implementation,” town spokesman Johannes Laubach told The Associated Press.

  • Hawaii promises to curb pollution from transport after young activists win climate lawsuit

    Youth activists are forcing Hawaii to clean up its transport sector.

  • Don't dismiss concerns of residents over Palmers Farm quarry proposal

    This letter to the editor is about concerns over a proposed gravel extraction site in Wootton on the Isle of Wight

  • Nature's best-kept secrets: the most incredible plant finds of recent times

    Scientists continue to unearth new botanical discoveries regularly, with hundreds of new plant species found and identified in recent years alone. Here's a round-up of the latest discoveries in the world of plants, fungi and flora.

  • Huge mako shark leaps out of water while chasing bait

    This is the amazing moment a huge mako shark leapt several feet out of the water while chasing a fisherman's bait off the coast of Catalina Island, California on May 3. Mako sharks are the fastest sharks in the world and are capable of launching themselves into the air when they break the surface at full speed.

  • Restore Nature Now: thousands to march in London calling for urgent action

    Mainstream groups including National Trust and RSPB will join hunt saboteurs and direct action activists for first time

  • Millions of mosquitoes released in Hawaii to save rare bird from extinction

    Conservationists hope insects carrying ‘birth control’ bacteria can save honeycreeper being wiped out by malaria

  • Ex-BlackRock Executive Seeks Unity to Fight Climate Change

    (Bloomberg) -- Paul Bodnar, BlackRock Inc.’s former chief of sustainable investing, said climate activists need to stop “demonizing” the fossil-fuel industry for advances to be made on the environmental front.Most Read from BloombergCar Dealerships Across US Halt Services After CyberattackCDK Tells Car Dealers Their Systems Likely Offline Several DaysPutin’s Hybrid War Opens a Second Front on NATO’s Eastern BorderUnited Airlines Jet Turns Back After Engine Piece Falls OffHedge Fund Talent School

  • Member states' water pollutant wish list sees green backlash

    Negotiating mandate for the Water Framework Directive’s adoption will be the basis for discussions to start between EU co-legislators, sparking green fears that EU rules protecting water are being dismantled.

  • Schwarzenegger: ‘Climate change dialogue’ not going to work

    Actor and former California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger (R) said the traditional “climate change dialogue” is not going to work anymore, particularly when it comes to high-polluting countries. Schwarzenegger joined MSNBC’s Jonathan Lemire on Thursday to discuss clean energy and climate solutions. Lemire asked the “Terminator” star how he would try to reach bigger polluters such…

  • What are electrolysers? How is hydrogen produced and how do fuel cells use the energy?

    Electrolysers and fuel cell systems are the key equipment for the production and use of hydrogen. More than 95 per cent of hydrogen is currently made using fossil fuels, mainly coal and natural gas, because of their low costs. However, governments' climate policies and incentives will make the production of green hydrogen, which uses renewable energy, economically viable, presenting big business opportunities. Here is what you need to know about electrolysers and fuel cell systems. Do you have q

  • Environmental activists win landmark ruling over UK oil well plan

    LONDON (Reuters) -Planning authorities should have considered the impact of climate-warming emissions in approving an oil well near Gatwick Airport, the UK's highest court said on Thursday, a ruling activists say could profoundly impact new fossil fuel projects in Britain. Environmental campaigners had argued that planning permission to retain and expand the oil well site near London's Gatwick was flawed because it had not considered the impact of greenhouse gas emissions from the use of the oil.