Why you shouldn’t take pebbles from the beach – here’s the science

Suzana Ilic, Senior Lecturer, Lancaster Environment Centre, Lancaster University and Joseph Earl, PhD Candidate, Lancaster Environment Centre, Lancaster University
·3-min read
<span class="attribution"><span class="source">Mr.Teerapong Kunkaeo / shutterstock</span></span>
Mr.Teerapong Kunkaeo / shutterstock

Cumberland Council in the north of England has announced that people taking pebbles from beaches will now face fines of up to £1,000. Many people found the announcement frustrating, but preventing erosion is critical, as research shows.

For many people, visiting the beach brings back joyful childhood memories. It is easy to forget that the sand and pebbles provide an important habitat for many creatures. It also provides natural protection for homes and infrastructure from the power of the sea.

Many people will have collected the odd souvenir stone, or perhaps even taken bags of pebbles for their garden rockeries. More avid enthusiasts are fascinated by the diversity of pebble types, colours, shapes and even fossils found on beaches, transported there from past glaciers or eroded cliffs nearby.

Yet it is a little-known fact that it is unlawful to remove any materials from the beach in the UK. It is a law enshrined in the 1949 Coastal Protection Act, curbing historic losses of hundreds of thousands of tonnes of sediment from beaches by people extracting “free” sediment for building materials.

Bird sat in pebbles
Bird sat in pebbles

Lengths of pebble beaches in England are also legally protected for their environmental qualities, designated by Natural England for the habitats they provide and species that rely on them. But for people who live near these beaches, one of the main values of pebbles comes through reducing coastal erosion and flooding.

The volume of the beach is critical to how effective it is at reducing both risks. In effect, the more pebbles and sediment on the beach, the more able the beach is to absorb wave energy. Removing lots of pebbles, sand or other sediment makes the beach less able to act as a natural barrier to flooding and erosion.

This volume changes naturally over the year, as the beach adjusts to changes in waves over the seasons. Pebbles are transported on and off the beach by waves, sorting different sediment sizes into distinct regions of the beach. More energetic waves during winter storms can transport larger sediment to the upper beach and form a steep ridge of pebbles known as a berm.

Pebble beach
Pebble beach

The berm at the top of the beach is often the first form of natural defence from storms, absorbing and dissipating wave energy and reducing the risk of waves carrying beyond the beach or undercutting and eroding sea walls or cliffs at their rear.

It all adds up

While one person taking a few pebbles from the beach may not significantly affect the berm or the overall beach volume, the cumulative effect of many people removing numerous pebbles may be more significant. Removing pebbles can disturb the beach’s natural sorting processes and interrupt its overall dynamic balance.

Given the importance of retaining sediment in the system for flood and erosion protection, there is ongoing research to better understand how pebble beaches respond to waves and storms. This research is particularly important for assessing the effectiveness of artificially created cobble beaches at providing protection from coastal flooding and erosion risks.

Monitoring sediment transport is key to advancing this research, with emerging low-cost and citizen science techniques being used to track sediment after it has been eroded from the beach.

In a changing climate, where these risks are predicted to be more intense and frequent, there is a pressing need to retain sediment on beaches and allow the natural coastal protection and habitat benefits to thrive.

Asking people not to take pebbles from the beach may appear trivial and insignificant, but it can help beaches play an effective role in protecting our coasts.

Imagine weekly climate newsletter
Imagine weekly climate newsletter

Don’t have time to read about climate change as much as you’d like?
Get a weekly roundup in your inbox instead. Every Wednesday, The Conversation’s environment editor writes Imagine, a short email that goes a little deeper into just one climate issue. Join the 30,000+ readers who’ve subscribed so far.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The Conversation
The Conversation

Joseph Earl is affiliated with Morecambe Bay Partnership.

Suzana Ilic was a coastal advisor to the North West Regional Flood and Coastal Committee between 2019 and 2023.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Five problem plants to avoid when buying a property – and what to do if you spot them

    Buying a property can be a complicated business, but there may be problems lurking in the garden which threaten to derail a purchase altogether.

  • Newly discovered Amazon fish species is named after ‘The Lord of the Rings’ villain for its odd pattern

    A new species of fish has been discovered in the Amazon: a piranha relative with humanlike teeth. The eye-catcher was named after a “Lord of the Rings” villain.

  • Energy prices in France turn negative as surging renewable output takes nuclear plants offline

    Some nuclear plants in France were shut down after renewable output surged, Bloomberg reported.

  • Drivers face 20 weeks of diversions for work on historic County Durham bridge

    A County Durham bridge dating back to 1894 is to close temporarily for essential maintenance work on Causeway Bridge.

  • Adorable Little Bear Clambers Onto Porch Near Rocky Mountain National Park

    A small black bear was spotted scaling the porch of an Estes Park, Colorado, home on Tuesday, June 11.Gianni Iandimarino owns the Ring camera that captured this video, which shows the small bear climbing the fence and walking across the porch.According to Colorado Parks and Wildlife (CPW), black bears are known to the region, and are continually trying to share space with an “ever-growing human population.”CPW encourages anyone living in the area to avoid feeding the bears, and to “bear-proof” their homes by being responsible about trash and keeping all bear-accessible windows and doors closed and locked. Credit: Gianni Iandimarino via Storyful

  • Archive photos of Brazil mountain do not disprove sea level rise

    Despite evidence of sea levels rising over the last century, skeptics are sharing archive photos of Sugarloaf Mountain in Brazil in an effort to disprove the impact of climate change on ecosystems. But regional and global data confirm the increase, with considerable evidence linking higher sea levels across the globe to human activity, scientists say.

  • Illinois is hit with cicada chaos. This is what it's like to see, hear and feel billions of bugs

    Crawling cicada nymphs, striving to get higher after 17 years underground, marched en masse toward and up trees, pausing to shed their skin and emerge as adults. Trillions of once-hidden baby bugs are in the air, on the trees and perching upon people's shirts, hats and even faces. “What you saw was biblical,” said biologist Gene Kritsky, who has been chasing periodical cicadas for 50 years, yet was still amazed by the 3 to 5 million cicadas crowding a small patch of Ryerson Conservation Area north of Chicago.

  • Move over grizzlies and wolves: Yellowstone visitors hope to catch a glimpse of rare white buffalo

    Standing at the edge of a bluff overlooking the Lamar River in Yellowstone National Park, TJ Ammond stared through binoculars at hundreds of buffalo dotting the verdant valley below. Grizzly bears and wolves are usually the star attractions for wildlife watchers in Yellowstone but this spring, a tiny and exceedingly rare white buffalo calf has stolen the show. White buffalo — also known as bison — are held sacred by many Native Americans who greeted news of the birth of one in Yellowstone as an auspicious sign.

  • Converting cow manure to fuel is growing climate solution, but critics say communities put at risk

    The stench of cow feces, urine and ammonia forces residents to keep windows and doors closed in parts of California's farming country. "We have a lot of health problems going around in this community and most of them are respiratory problems,” said Beverly Whitfield amid dairies in Pixley, a small town in Tulare County.

  • Shocking footage shows moments after a gator ate a 41-year-old woman in Florida

    Family had last seen woman the day before fatal encounter in Largo, Florida

  • Kate Forbes pledges SNP will protect Scottish salmon industry

    The Deputy First Minister will visit the largest haulage company for the Scottish salmon and seafood industry.

  • Water companies accused of ‘illegally’ releasing sewage during record heatwave

    Water companies released sewage during the record heatwave of 2022, despite rules that spills should only happen in extreme wet weather, according to data.

  • High orange juice prices may be on the table for a while due to disease and extreme weather

    Orange juice prices have always been volatile, falling when bumper harvests create an oversupply of oranges and rising when frost or a hurricane knocks out fruit trees. This year’s harvest in Brazil, the world’s largest exporter of orange juice, is likely to be the worst in 36 years due to flooding and drought, according to a forecast by Fundecitrus, a citrus growers’ organization in Sao Paulo state. In the U.S., Florida's already diminished orange production fell 62% in the 2022-2023 season after Hurricane Ian further battered a crop that was struggling due to an invasive pest.

  • Newport shines in the UK's sunniest locations list

    Newport has been named as one of the ten sunniest places in the UK.

  • New Forest Tours to celebrate 'special' year after 500,000 passengers

    CELEBRATIONS are planned this summer as Morebus and the New Forest National Park Authority mark the 20th anniversary of the New Forest Tour.

  • Wildlife experts urge action on pesticides as UK insect populations plummet

    Campaigners say next government must reduce use and toxicity of pesticides before it is too late

  • Factbox-The Russian attacks that have pounded Ukraine's power facilities

    Russia renewed a campaign of aerial attacks on Ukrainian energy facilities in March, which Kyiv says has knocked out half of its power generating capacity and forced Ukraine to introduce rolling blackouts in the capital and across the country. Russia says energy infrastructure is a legitimate military target and denies targeting civilians or civilian infrastructure. The attacks have spurred concerns about the resilience of the ailing power system this winter.

  • North Macedonia's beekeepers face climate change challenge

    Every day, Magda Miloseska dons a white, protective suit and enters the domain of the honeybees in the backyard of her small weekend house in North Macedonia.She has been producing honey in this picturesque corner of the country for more than 20 years. But climate change and disease have made what used to be a simple pleasure much harder work, she says.Stence is a hillside village in the west of the country, surrounded by mountains and at a level of 650 metres (2,130 feet). Temperatures in June already exceed 30 degrees Celsius (86 Fahrenheit), three-degrees higher than usual, according to the state meteorological office."In the past, beekeeping was much easier," said 63-year-old Miloseska. "Beekeeping was a treat."Now, we simply have to fight both the climate conditions and the diseases that have entered the beekeeping."Just a hobby for some, but a source of income for others, beekeeping has surged in recent years in all regions of the country.There were 6,900 beekeepers with 306,000 beehives registered across the country in 2023, according to the Food and Veterinary Agency.But according to a European Commission study issued in July 2023, 10 percent of bees and butterflies are threatened with extinction in Europe -- largely due to human activities.- Honey production down -Miloseska may not have the data at her fingertips, but her everyday experience has made it clear to her something is wrong."Older beekeepers say that in the past they could get 30-50 kilograms (44-66 pounds) of honey from one beehive," she said."In this period, with these climate conditions, that is substantially decreased."Today, in ideal conditions, the most you could hope for would be around 30 kilograms over one season, she added -- with average production between 10 and 20 kilos.That relative scarcity has pushed prices up from to between 15 and 20 euros ($16-22) compared to 10 euros just two or three years ago.Vladimir Petroski, who for the past 13 years has spent his free time caring for 120 beehives, has noted the same problem.Whereas in the past they could expect 30-40 kilograms, he said, these days they had to be satisfied with 15 kilos per season.And he agreed that climate change had fuelled the rise of the parasites and viruses that threaten wild and honey bees."Beekeepers need to educate themselves and adapt according to the conditions and the micro-climate where they work."- Educate and adapt -In fact, the beekeepers are already trying to find solutions themselves.Their hive mind is made up of the regional beekeepers' associations, which promote good practice and organise honey festivals.They agree the main challenges are the warm winters, swift changes of the temperature in spring -- and the long, dry periods that come with summer now stretching into September and October.Environmental groups have called for government ministries and agencies to coordinate to tackle the problems that climate change pose for bees.So far however, they say their warnings have gone largely unheeded.The agriculture ministry is just as concerned about intensive agriculture, pesticides, loss of diversity and pollution.&nbsp;While acknowledging the threat climate change poses, it has simply recommended closer monitoring of the bees' behaviour.More data is certainly needed, says Frosina Pandurska Dramikjanin of the Macedonian Ecological Society, part of a project trying to understand the effect of climate change on bees.But it also needs to be share between the relevant state institutions, she argued.Without that, she told AFP, "it is harder to issue measures and recommendations".A recent report from the United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP) underlined the stakes, highlighting the key role bees play in food production and biodiversity.Out of the 100 crop species that provide 90 percent of all food consumed worldwide, 71 are pollinated by bees, it reported.dd/jj

  • How do you put pigeons on the pill? Scientists test contraceptives to curb pest numbers

    Birth control is being trialled as a humane way to limit growing numbers of grey squirrels, pigeons and wild boar

  • Is there anybody out there? NATO hones Arctic subs' sonar skills

    In the icy waters of the Arctic, NATO scientists are dissecting sound waves to improve the West's ability to track Russian submarines, as global warming alters acoustics underwater.The aim of the scientific mission is to understand how climate change, which is warming the Arctic faster than the rest of the planet, is affecting the movement of underwater soundwaves.