Woman wanted in triple killing investigation in Virginia taken into custody in upstate New York

Associated Press

Updated 7 June 2024 at 4:09 pm·1-min read

AVOCA, N.Y. (AP) — A 23-year-old woman wanted in the deaths of her three roommates in Virginia was taken into custody after a chase on an upstate New York highway, police said Friday.

Police began searching for Alyssa Jane Venable after the bodies of her roommates, all in their 60s or 70s, were discovered Tuesday during a welfare check in Fredericksburg, Virginia. Police said she was wanted on three counts of second-degree murder and a firearms charge.

Venable was taken into custody by New York State Police troopers Thursday evening, more than 260 miles (418 kilometers) north of Fredericksburg. She was driving a sedan on Interstate 86 when troopers tried to pull her over, but she refused. The car crashed after running over a tire deflation device, according to state police.

Venable was taken to a hospital for injuries that were not life-threatening and was being held in the Steuben County jail on Friday. Troopers said they will proceed with extradition arrangements.

A phone message was left Friday at the Steuben County Public Defender’s office in New York.

It was not immediately clear why Venable was in New York. Troopers were trying to piece together a timeline of the last several days and were seeking information from the public.

The Spotsylvania Sheriff’s Office in Virginia identified the victims as Robert John McGuire, 77; Gregory Scott Powell, 60; and Carol Anne Reese, 65. A spokesperson for the sheriff's office did not respond to two phone messages seeking more information on Venable. Venable's grandmother, Jane Venable, declined to comment Friday.

The Independent
Seven people - including four kids - shot by neighbor who once told them to ‘go back to where they came from’
Motive still being investigated, but shooting ‘could’ have racial element, police say
Manchester Evening News
Spanish police could solve Jay Slater mystery by doing two key things says missing persons expert
The apprentice bricklayer had travelled to a Masca village Airbnb, roughly a 40-minute drive away from his tourist residence, alongside two British acquaintances
Manchester Evening News
Jet skis, a Russian SIM card and a lot of 'no comment' answers... The 'top of the tree' drug trafficker known as 'Piggy Wilson' who lived a luxury lifestyle
He lived a lavish life funded by crime - with jet skis, watches and a static caravan - but is now being bars
Evening Standard
Prison guard accused of having sex with inmate at HMP Wandsworth freed on bail
Linda De Sousa Abreu, 30, has been charged with misconduct in public office
The Independent
Prostitute is fatally strangled then sexually assaulted inside Las Vegas casino by man who said he ‘snapped’
Jason Kendall, 35, is being held without bond in connection to the murder of Larissa Garcia at a Las Vegas casino
The Independent
Ted Bundy was a prime suspect in her 51-year-old murder. Now cops know who really did it
A box of DNA evidence collected in the 1970s helped lead investigators to Ann Woodward’s killer
The Telegraph
Jay Slater disappearance not being treated as a crime, say Spanish authorities
The disappearance of Jay Slater is not being treated as a crime at this stage, Spanish authorities have said.
Associated Press
Trump seeks to set aside New York hush money verdict hours after Supreme Court ruling
Donald Trump’s lawyers on Monday asked the New York judge who presided over his hush money trial to set aside his conviction and delay his sentencing, scheduled for next week. The letter to Judge Juan M. Merchan cited the U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling earlier Monday and asked the judge to delay Trump’s sentencing while he weighs the high court’s decision and how it could influence the New York case, according to the letter obtained by The Associated Press. The lawyers argue that the Supreme Court’s decision confirmed a position the defense raised earlier in the case that prosecutors should have been precluded from introducing some evidence they said constituted official presidential acts, according to the letter.
Manchester Evening News
British climber who flew to Tenerife to help find missing Jay Slater accuses Spanish police of 'PR stunt'
The climber and social media personality has railed against Spanish authorities, continuing the search today despite Tenerife police calling off their official search on the ground
The Independent
Marjorie Taylor Greene rages outside Bannon’s prison - but is interrupted by a ‘Bleach Blonde Bad Built Butch Body’ sign
The sign made reference to a name Rep Jasmine Crockett gave to Majorie Taylor Greene during a heated argument
Colchester Evening Gazette
Man who filmed himself sexually abusing woman has been jailed for 12 years
Bradley Smith from Chelmsford has been jailed for 12 years after filming himself sexually abusing a woman.
The Telegraph
Paedophile head teacher jailed for 17 years for abuse of four girls
A former high school head teacher who abused school girls for years and was “determined” to satisfy his “perverted desires” has been jailed for 17 years.
Evening Standard
Jay Slater's father 'disappointed' at number of volunteers searching in Tenerife for missing teenager
Father hits out at trolls criticising his family as low numbers of expert volunteers join search effort after plea for mass turnout
Associated Press
Young Thug's trial on hold as defense tries to get judge removed from case
The judge overseeing the racketeering and gang prosecution against Young Thug and others on Monday put the long-running trial on hold until another judge rules on requests by several defendants that he step aside from the case. Lawyers for the rapper and several other defendants had filed motions seeking the recusal of Fulton County Superior Court Chief Judge Ural Glanville after he held a meeting with prosecutors and a prosecution witness at which defendants and defense attorneys were not present.
Warrington Guardian
Police hunt for wanted trio who failed to attend class A drugs supply sentencing
Police hunt for wanted trio who failed to attend class A drugs supply sentencing
The Independent
North Carolina mom charged with murdering two of her adopted children
Avantae Deven faces multiple charges relating to the disappearance and death of Blake and London Deven
The Telegraph
Bus company ‘refused’ to move asylum seekers to Bibby Stockholm during protest
A bus company refused to move asylum seekers to the Bibby Stockholm barge during a protest over fears about the negative publicity it could cause, a court has heard.
CNN
Man who confessed to killing 4 people in Maine, including his parents, sentenced to life in prison
A man who confessed to killing his parents and two of their friends and wounding three people on a highway pleaded guilty and was sentenced to life in prison.
The Telegraph
‘Best kept village’ smells so bad it has had to pull out of the competition
The six-times winner of England’s best kept village has pulled out of the competition because the smell of raw sewage coming from the river has become unbearable.
The Telegraph
Starmer: Trans women don’t have the right to use women-only toilets
Sir Keir Starmer has said transgender women do not have a right to access female-only spaces, amid confusion over Labour’s stance on which lavatories trans people should use.

Latest stories