Developing

Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Clarke: Homeowners 'Can Stab Burglars'

    The Justice Secretary has said householders will be able to stab burglars without fear of prosecution under new legislation guaranteeing their right to defend themselves.

    Ken Clarke was speaking ahead of the Justice Bill being debated in the Commons today.

    He said an act of Parliament will be used to "clarify" the existing legal right to use "reasonable force" against intruders.

    Mr Clarke said: "We will make it quite clear you can hit a burglar with a poker if he's in your house and you have a perfect defence when you do so.

    "If an old lady finds she's got an 18-year-old burgling her house and she picks up a kitchen knife and sticks it in him, she has not committed a criminal offence, and we will make that clear."

    Prime Minister David Cameron has promised that the new Justice Bill would "put beyond doubt that homeowners and small shopkeepers who use reasonable force to defend themselves or their properties will not be prosecuted".

    Mr Clarke accepted that the defence of reasonable force already exists, but said: "Given that doubts are expressed, we are going to clarify that.

    "It is quite obvious that people are entitled to use whatever force is necessary to protect themselves and their homes.

    "What they are not entitled to do is go running down the road chasing them or shooting them in the back when they are running away or to get their friends together and go and beat them up.

    "We all know what we mean when we say a person has an absolute right to defend themselves and their home and reasonable force.

    "Nobody should prosecute and nobody should ever convict anybody who takes these steps."

    Mr Cameron's official spokesman said: "The objective is to put beyond doubt the fact that home-owners and small shopkeepers who use reasonable force to protect themselves or their property should be able to do that without being prosecuted."

     

    434 comments

    • Exhausted Vent  •  11 months ago
      oh and reasonable force? That's anything you want to do to sort out the burglar that's in your 'castle'. Just remember to plant a knife on them ;)
      • Elusive jim 11 months ago
        or cut the @#$% up in the bath and dump him in the sea. This csi, police investigation stuff is rubbish, what are they going to do check crab stomachs for dna?
      • STEVE 11 months ago
        remember to get HIS fingerprints and DNA samples onto it. Maybe a small drop of YOUR OWN blood to make it look more convincing.................
        Yeah yeah, we have all seen those police cover up movies.
        Joking aside, it's about time THEY gave US permission to defend ourselves.
        Nice of THEM isn't it???????
      • peter t 11 months ago
        superb lol
    • Terry  •  10 months ago
      It's about time this was sorted out; it should be illegal to enter a property unless you have been invited in by the occupier.
      As the law stands it has to be proven that the intruder is there with intent. That means that they have to be in possession of something to cause harm to you or your home.
      Let���s get rid of human rights, if an immigrant commits an offence they should be sent back as soon as they are released, with no right to appeal.
      Why should we be forced to accept the dregs of society because of their right? How about ours.
      • Cynic1 8 months ago
        illegal to enter a property unless you have been invited in by the occupier.. Hello !!!!!! thats trespass and thats illegal....Intent ???? what the hell is an intruder doing in the house if there is no intent....? Christ man wake up,,,,, this is reality
    • David  •  11 months ago
      Now that we have the right to defend our homes and our loved ones, can our useless politicians also enable the courts to send illegal immigrant murderers back to their homlands even if they have a pet cat. The human rights act must go. We did not need before and we certainly do not need it now !!!
    • Self defence instructor.  •  11 months ago
      Your number one priority should be your own safety. Life isn't like the movies, so forget any macho posturng & stay safe. Buying a burglar alarm is much more effective then buying a shotgun.

      Just remember adding a weapon to a situation increases the risk to you. Attacking someone with a knife brings in the real possibility of him taking it off you & using it.

      The last thing most burglars want is to meet the homeowner & will be desperate to escape. If you get between them & the exit he's gonna fight you & he's probably younger & fitter than you are. If you don't block his way he's gonna run.

      Yes, fight all out if you really have to (and don't make a statement to the police until you have a lawyer present). But if fighting is your first choice you're an idiot.
      • falk 11 months ago
        in your own home, there is NOWHERE left to run. even rats rise to defend their own lairs. & they're the bottom of the food chain. in your own home, the ONLY! two options when facing a burglar/unlawful intruder are kill or die. if i face an intruder in my home, killing the disease is the ONLY reasonable option. NOTHING to do with "macho posturing" as this idiot poster so patronisingly puts it. but rather EVERYTHING to do with protecting my family, protecting my home (& everything in it. & yes, my few meagre possessions ARE worth FAR more than the lives of EVERY thieving parasite vermin on this island AND the lives of their vermin families) & protecting myself. my arrows can reach my front door in about 0.008 secs. my axe is right behind them. & i'm right behind that with a 2lb meat cleaver & a crowbar. can a burglar move faster?
      • william 11 months ago
        can you really value your tv more than life?what if your son or daughter were the thief?...what if?i know that you would be singing a somewhat different song then!....by the way i and no member of my family have any criminal records,or have been arrested at any time!! sounds to me like,too many people watch far too much tv!..pehaps people would be better asking why there is so much crime instead?!
      • Self defence instructor. 10 months ago
        Falk, if they're running for the door, why do you need to shoot them. Aside from anything else, it'll make a mess of the carpet.

        Please remember that as a re-enactor you have no idea how to actually use weapons & you'll get turned over by the average teenage burgler.
    • Gillian  •  11 months ago
      my son lives in USA where they have few breakins in private homes because purpetrators know they could be shot,never mind hit with a baseball bat!
      • Cynic1 8 months ago
        I lived in The Philippines in the 80's and shot an intruder who broke in late at night...when Police arrived they said " he knew the risk" and it was less hassle than a parking violation... what closed the issue was I had 'OCCUPANTS ARE ARMED" on my gates...now thats a good deterrent normally but maybe he thought it was a bluff WRONG !!!!
    • STEVE  •  11 months ago
      what about a COMPLETE pardon, PLUS an appology, PLUS compensation for Mr. Tony Martin then?
      I think he deserves it poor bloke.
      • Self defence instructor. 11 months ago
        Poor bloke who shot a fleeing man in the back.
      • GAZZA.T.TOMPKINSON 11 months ago
        Here here Steve... only protecting what was his, against a gypsy.
      • falk 11 months ago
        he shot vermin. this so-called "fleeing man" (or some parasite thieving pikey disease just like it) had been stalking, victimising, threatening & terrorising mr martin regularly for months if not years. ever hear the saying "the straw that breaks the camel's back"? we ALL have breaking points. we ALL have lines that MAY NOT be crossed. we ALL have the right to ensure the safety & security of ourselves & our homes PERMANAENTLY! NOT! merely until some sub-human comes back the next night, or the one after etc etc etc. tony martin did NOTHING wrong. our shame as a nation is that we left him to rot in jail. that should have been the spark that lit the tinder-box to rise & burn every thug-loving judge & lawyer to be found until the rights of the INNOCENT VICTIM were enshrined in law over the supposed "rights" of some vermin crim.
    • Necropink  •  11 months ago
      Somebody pinch me i must be dreaming!
    • Mike P  •  11 months ago
      Please note: No change to the law. The right to self-defence has ALWAYS existed. What the government is doing, sensibly, is clarifying what constitutes "reasonable force". The problem has always been that the authorities have gone for prosecution, and then left it up to the courts to decide whether in any given circumstance, the force used was reasonable. (Most such cases end in acquittal, mine did.) By clarifying the situation, people are no longer having to go through the stress and anxiety of awaiting a courts decision, this can only be a very good thing indeed.
    • Ana  •  11 months ago
      This is excellent news at last. The right to defend yourself when threatened in your own home is what Human Rights should be about and not for the those who commit the crimes.
    • Exhausted Vent  •  11 months ago
      Holy shiznit! Actual sense and decent laws for once!!!
    • DAVID  •  11 months ago
      Can I believe my eye's, is this really true? At last someone has had the bottle to speak out against the namby pambys that want to protect the arseholes that commit these crimes.
    • 2cv  •  11 months ago
      At @#$% last! Previously, a burglar could break into your house, trip on a loose floorboard and break his ankle, then sue you under the occupier's liability act.
    • Wraithneon  •  11 months ago
      About bloody time.
    • C  •  11 months ago
      about time
    • Father Stack  •  11 months ago
      About time.Lets go one better and say you can nail their thieving hands to the floor until the police arrive.
    • Stevonymo  •  11 months ago
      Well peel my spuds! At last a minister with some balls. Now where the hell did I put that samurai sword!
    • cynic  •  11 months ago
      Dont get over excited - he's a politician making promises. We all know how reliable they are.
    • Samy S  •  11 months ago
      I hope this becomes a reality and the bill is passed ,seems like a very good news to tackle these kind of crimes
    • Rodney  •  11 months ago
      At least companies selling pokers will be onto a good thing. I see a huge increase in their sales. Must go out and buy one.
    • Conservative and Unionist  •  11 months ago
      Well it's a start anyway.If burglar is armed and stabs the householder that should be grievous bodily or murder by hanging.Because he had entered with intent.