Adobe sued by DOJ and FTC for ‘hidden’ fees that make it ‘absurdly’ hard to cancel Photoshop subscriptions

Josh Marcus
·2-min read
Adobe sued by DOJ and FTC for ‘hidden’ fees that make it ‘absurdly’ hard to cancel Photoshop subscriptions

The Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission sued Adobe, accusing the popular maker of design software like Photoshop and Illustrator of using “hidden” fees and a byzantine customer service process to make it nearly impossible to cancel annual subscriptions.

“Adobe trapped customers into year-long subscriptions through hidden early termination fees and numerous cancellation hurdles,” FTC Bureau of Consumer Protection director Samuel Levine said in a statement. “Americans are tired of companies hiding the ball during subscription signup and then putting up roadblocks when they try to cancel. The FTC will continue working to protect Americans from these illegal business practices.”

According to a civil enforcement action filed against the company and two top executives, Maninder Sawhney and David Wadhwani, in California federal court, Adobe used a number of practices to lock consumers into pricey subscriptions, violating the Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act.

The company allegedly used fine print, optional text boxes, and a maze of hyperlinks to conceal an essentially secret early termination fee that charged users half the value of their remaining annual contracts to cancel, a penalty that could amount to hundreds of dollars, according to the suit.

Those who did want to cancel their plans faced other obstacles, according to officials.

“Some users who tried to cancel by contacting customer service would have their calls drop or disconnect and then have to re-explain everything all over again,” FTC chair Lina Khan said in a statement on Monday on X. “Others would be stuck in an endless loop of transfers across various Adobe representatives.”

The federal official said such policies make it “absurdly” hard to get out of an Adobe subscription.

One customer described in the suit claimed, “Adobe literally will not let me cancel my subscription.

“Subscription services are convenient, flexible and cost effective to allow users to choose the plan that best fits their needs, timeline and budget,” Dana Rao, Adobe’s general counsel and chief trust officer, wrote in a statement. “Our priority is to always ensure our customers have a positive experience. We are transparent with the terms and conditions of our subscription agreements and have a simple cancellation process. We will refute the FTC’s claims in court.”

Before 2012, Adobe typically sold its software with perpetual licenses, allowing users to pay once for lifetime use.

Then, the company shifted to a subscription model, charging users a regular monthly or yearly fee to maintain their access.

The decision yielded huge returns.

Between 2019 and 2023, Adobe’s subscription-based revenue almost doubled, growing from $7.71bn to $14.22bn, according to the suit.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Ex-Fujitsu engineer admits changing court testimony at request of Post Office

    Gareth Jenkins, co-architect of flawed Horizon IT system, was expert witness in wrongful prosecutions of operators

  • Disney Tried To Get Gina Carano's 'Mandalorian' Lawsuit Quickly Dismissed, But The Judge Said Not So Fast

    Whenever a high-profile (and high dollar value) lawsuit is filed, the first thing the side being sued does is try and get the case dismissed. That’s exactly what Disney did after Gina Carano sued the studio following her firing from "The Mandalorian." Disney hoped to get the lawsuit tossed on a First Amendment basis, but the judge has dismissed that claim, and the suit will move forward, at least for now. Disney argued in front of U.S. District Judge Sherilyn Peace Garnett that the studio had the right to sever its relationship with Carano because she did not espouse viewpoints that the company agreed with. According to THR, the judge stated that the First Amendment could not be used as a shield to potentially violate discrimination laws. Carano is arguing that in firing her she was discriminated against and that the studio violated California labor laws in terminating her.

  • NY AG opposes Trump motion for civil fraud judge to recuse himself

    The New York attorney general’s office accused Donald Trump of undertaking yet another effort to “undermine the Court’s legitimacy” by calling for the judge in the former president’s civil fraud trial to recuse himself over communications with a real estate attorney.

  • Colchester pub 'unable to serve walk-ins' amid claims site has now ceased trading

    The future of a Colchester restaurant still appears to be in limbo after fears of its closure were denied by bosses.

  • Post Office Horizon expert admits seeing legal advice on trial obligations and defends Fujitsu's remote access

    A key figure behind the flawed IT system that led to hundreds of sub-postmasters being wrongly jailed has told the Post Office inquiry he had "not remembered" legal advice he was given about his obligations as an expert witness. Former senior Fujitsu engineer Gareth Jenkins was crucial in the prosecutions process because he was one of the architects of the Horizon accounting systems and one of a few people to have extensive knowledge of their workings. The letter, which related to the Post Office prosecution of postmaster Lee Castleton, was written four years before Mr Jenkins was presented as an expert witness in the case of Seema Misra, who was wrongfully sentenced to 15 months in prison while pregnant in 2010.

  • Droitwich accounting firm celebrates impressive employee advancement

    A Droitwich company is celebrating one of its most high-achieving employees.

  • Airbus Slashes Its Guidance. What It Means for Boeing, GE.

    The jet manufacturer expects to earn about $5.9 billion in 2024 operating profit. Wall Street was looking for more.

  • With just a few years until retirement, 55-year-olds haven't saved nearly enough, study finds

    For Gen Xers, retirement isn’t far off, and millions of them haven't saved enough.

  • This stock is seen as Nvidia's 'little brother'

    Jefferies analysts started research coverage on electronics manufacturing services provider Fabrinet (NYSE:FN) with a Hold rating and a price target of $230.

  • Volkswagen to invest $5bn in Tesla electric car rival

    Volkswagen has announced plans to invest up to $5bn (£3.9bn) in US electric carmaker Rivian, as manufacturers rethink their strategies amid uncertain demand.

  • A mechanic for a Boeing subcontractor says he was fired after complaining about poor repair work

    A mechanic for a Boeing subcontractor claims he was fired after complaining about poor repair work on planes in a Boeing factory near Seattle. Boeing says the man’s concerns did not raise safety issues. Lawyers for the mechanic said Wednesday that the man saw “substandard manufacturing and maintenance processes” during work on several Boeing 787 Dreamliners.

  • Judge puts $30 billion Visa, Mastercard settlement on hold, in signal of likely rejection

    A federal judge said she's not likely to approve the $30 billion settlement between the payment processing giants Visa and Mastercard and the merchants who say they've overpaid on swipe fees. Visa and Mastercard reached a settlement with a group of small businesses and merchants back in March. The deal would lower and cap the fees charged by Visa and Mastercard and allow small businesses to collectively bargain for rates with the payment processors in a similar way that the large merchants do on their own now.

  • What Does It Take to Bring Stability to a Renewable-Focused Grid?

    As coal, gas, and nuclear plants are retired, and wind and solar resources are added to the power grid, stability can become a problem. Understanding the solutions that are available […]

  • Has the Rolls-Royce share price risen too far, too soon?

    The Rolls-Royce share price has soared spectacularly over the last year. Is this justified, or has the stock got a bit ahead of itself? The post Has the Rolls-Royce share price risen too far, too soon? appeared first on The Motley Fool UK.

  • China’s Glut of Coal Delivers Early Success in Dodging Summer Shortages

    (Bloomberg) -- China has a glut of coal heading into the hotter summer months, a successful start to Beijing’s campaign to ensure there’s enough of its mainstay fuel to keep cool and power factories during the season when consumption typically peaks.Most Read from BloombergYouTuber Dr Disrespect Was Allegedly Kicked Off Twitch for Messaging MinorVolkswagen Invests $5 Billion in EV Startup Rivian to Form Joint VentureTrump Could Actually Lose Florida. Here’s Why.Nvidia Rout Takes Breather as Trad

  • How to pivot your career when you’re sick of the rat race – but not ready to retire

    “Where do you see yourself in five years?” is a standard job interview question for young people, but rarely asked of more senior workers.

  • Who can countersign a passport application (plus the rules explained)

    Having your passport countersigned is an important step if you are looking to replace one that is damaged or lost

  • Bid for alcohol sales at Punjabi restaurant at busy shopping area

    Bosses servingPunjabi food want to sell alcohol to diners at an eatery and takeaway at a busy and ever-changing shopping area in Reading.

  • Dave Ramsey Calls Out The 'Bad Life Plan' Many Americans Consider As Retirement Nowadays — 'Save Enough Money So I Can Quit The Job I Hate.'

    Celebrated personal finance guru Dave Ramsey calls out Americans who consider saving enough money to quit their jobs because they hate them as a bad life plan. Here's what Ramsey had to say about this flawed approach. Don't Miss: The average American couple has saved this much money for retirement — How do you compare? Many are surprised by Mark Cuban’s advice for lotto winners: Cash or annuity? Recently, Ramsey wrote on X, formerly known as Twitter, to express his concerns about this latest ret

  • A co-founder of the embattled venture capital firm Fearless Fund has stepped down as operating chief

    One of the co-founders of an Atlanta-based venture capital firm that supports women of color has stepped down as chief operating officer as the company battles a lawsuit that has become emblematic of a conservative backlash against corporate diversity programs. Ayana Parsons confirmed in a statement that she has stepped down as general partner and chief operating officer of the Fearless Fund, which she co-founded in 2019 with Arian Simone to address the wide racial disparity in funding for businesses owned by women of color. Parsons said her decision was unrelated to a conservative group's lawsuit targeting a grant program for Black women entrepreneurs run by the Fearless Fund's foundation arm.