What Is Confusing?: 'Jeopardy!' Judges Leave Viewers Questioning Game Show
“Jeopardy!” viewers are criticizing the show for its judgment of written answers in recent episodes.
The game show’s viewers called out judges on Monday for what they viewed as an unfair application of rules, Parade reported.
One viewer pointed out that judges didn’t accept contestant Sadie Goldberger’s written answer from a June episode ― an attempt at “Harriet Tubman” ― but on Monday’s episode accepted contestant Erica Weiner-Amachi′s written attempt at “Waiting for Godot.”
Goldberger ended up losing her game to fellow contestant Megan Wachspress.
Weiner-Amachi’s correct answer led to a tiebreaker question with fellow contestant William Chou, but eventually she lost to Chou.
You can see the two answers compared to each other below.
#jeopardy this didn’t count, but then this one did?? pic.twitter.com/xsr2RUBLv3
— Herschel Cuyler (@herschelcuyler_) July 18, 2022
One of the rules of “Jeopardy!,” as its website explains, is that written answers don’t need correct spelling, although they “must be phonetically correct and not add or subtract any extraneous sounds or syllables.”
“If it’s misspelled, it will come down to a judgment call, but the closer you can get it, the better chance for a thumbs-up from the judges,” the game show’s website states.
“Knowing the rules before jumping in is always a good idea. However, the judges get to make the final call in situations like these.”
Viewers weighed in on the comparison, and some claimed they never would have been able to read Weiner-Amachi’s writing.
I replayed to see the spelling again. If I didn’t know what the name was and someone showed me the way she wrote it, I never would have got Godot out of that.
— Darlene Parnell 🇨🇦 🦓 (@darlene865) July 19, 2022
No offense to her, but if you didn’t know they were looking for “Waiting for Godot,” it reads more like “Wainly for… pic.twitter.com/HdblxsH6Jo
— SkeeterBombay (@SkeeterBombay) July 19, 2022
I’m sorry but it has to be said… how is the top answer considered complete and good for a tie breaker, when the one for Sadie (on the bottom) would have had her in the lead… I think that Harriett Tubman is FAR more legible than whatever Erica has written! pic.twitter.com/WdZ24BnHr0
— The Heidt Of Media (@HeidtOfMedia) July 19, 2022
Phonetic spelling. Even if she'd only gotten GODO it would have been good per J rules.
— Terry "Mulligans for $2,000" Wolfisch Cole (@tell_me_another) July 19, 2022
Agree. Sadie was robbed. Like whom did she mean - Harriet Turtlebaum? No, we all read it as Tubman
— WSPage (@WsPagewerks) July 19, 2022
The game show’s spelling rule has led to fan debate in the past.
An episode from September 2020 featured a question about music producer Berry Gordy, UpRoxx reported.
One contestant, as a written response, wrote “Barry Gordy” and judges ruled her response incorrect.
“I have no words. That judges’ ruling in Final Jeopardy tonight is completely inconsistent with past practice. Good luck handling the flames tonight, @Jeopardy, you’re going to need it,” wrote @_thejeopardyfan after the episode.
Other viewers referenced incorrect spellings in prior episodes, as well, to go to bat for the misspelled “Barry” answer.
This is what I’m referencing: if the judges had been as stringent in my game as they were last night, my opponents’ responses would have been found incorrect and I would be a #Jeopardy champion. pic.twitter.com/BpJLxtx8oa
— Emily Brown (@feministpastor) September 16, 2020
Curious why this misspelling of Yul Brynner was accepted but Betsy's misspelling of Berry Gordy wasn't. pic.twitter.com/pVQdjjaYZT
— Libby (@libbyjones715) September 16, 2020
But @Jeopardy, this is not consistent with your own practices. Observe this Jan. 4, 1999 FJ. There is a 1996 book by University of Georgia Press called "Madaline," and yet the contestant who made a similar a/e error was judged as correct. There was no confusion. https://t.co/UKRvu8cjnEpic.twitter.com/UVO9Rnfrfe
— Jennifer Morrow (@jenniferemorrow) September 17, 2020
This article originally appeared on HuffPost and has been updated.