Mary Anning: how a poor, Victorian woman became one of the world's greatest palaeontologists

Adrian Currie, Lecturer of Philosophy, University of Exeter
Mary Anning painting

Lyme Regis is an almost obnoxiously gorgeous town in Dorset in the west of England, perched atop the cliffs of the world-heritage listed Jurassic Coast. Thanks to a campaign set off by a local 10-year-old girl and her mother, the people of this town is raising funds to erect a statue to their famous citizen Mary Anning. As an expert on paleontology, I think this is a brilliant idea.

Mary Anning was born in 1799. Her family was poor – and somewhat tragic. She was named after an older sister who had died in a fire. Her father died when she was barely a teenager, leaving her family dependent on selling Lyme Regis’ abundant ammonites, belamnites and other fossils to tourists. Fossils became the family business – and Mary was the sharpest fossil spotter.

The work was often dangerous: the Jurassic coast’s cliffs are treacherous (Mary’s dog was killed in a mudslide while prospecting). Still in her early 20s, Anning became a legendary fossil hunter. She found the first complete plesiosaur fossil, the first British pterosaur and figured out that coprolites were fossilised dung. In Lyme Regis, she and her family opened “Anning’s fossil depot”, where her fossils were purchased for collections in the United States and Europe.

Many of the great geological luminaries of the day bought her fossils and went fossil hunting with her. Her knowledge of fossil anatomy was obvious to those “in the know” and she became something of a local celebrity. Lady Harriet Silvester marvelled that “this poor, ignorant girl” could have “arrived to that degree of knowledge as to be in the habit of writing and talking with professors and other clever men on the subject, and they all acknowledge that she understands more of the science than anyone else in this kingdom”.

Landslip near Lyme Regis. Ballista/wikipedia, CC BY-SA

The picture we get of Anning’s personality is of someone who knows what they’re talking about and doesn’t mind letting you know. As the Scottish mineralogist Thomas Allen noted: “Mary Anning’s knowledge of the subject is quite surprising – she is perfectly acquainted with the anatomy of her subjects, and her account of her disputes with Buckland, whose anatomical science she holds in great contempt, was quite amusing”.

The Reverend Buckland was an Oxfordian giant of geology and he and Anning often worked closely together, particularly on coprolites. Gideon Mantell, the discoverer of the Iguanadon described Anning (in rather misogynistic terms) as a “geological lioness … in a little dirty shop, with hundreds of specimens piled around her in the greatest disorder. She, the presiding Deity, [proved] a prim, pedantic vinegar looking, thin female; shrewd, and rather satirical in her conversation.”

Anning, then, was a major contributor to the sciences of geology and paleontology, just as they were gathering steam – becoming established in museums and gaining worldwide interest. Historian Hugh Torrens, in his 1995 presidential address about Anning for the British Society for the History of Science, chose the epithet the “greatest fossilist the world has known” for the title of his talk. So why is Anning only now getting a statue? Why did she not have a more prominent place in the history of science? There are a number of explanations.

Sexism and classism

The most obvious answer is Anning’s gender. In Anning’s time, science was very much a male domain. Even today only 35% of those enrolled in STEM disciplines and only 28% of the world’s researchers are women. Most contemporary descriptions of Anning expressed surprised that a woman could be so knowledgeable, often with the implication that such knowledge in the “fairer sex” is threatening.

Another factor was class. Science wasn’t simply the domain of men, but gentlemen. As the artist and geologist Henry De la Beche wrote in Anning’s death notice, she was “not placed among even the easier classes of society, but who had to earn her daily bread by her labour”. Anning’s research was intimately tied to how she made a living. To the Victorian mind, such reliance was rather distasteful and sullied the pure search for knowledge.

The fact that Anning – despite the fact that she made her living from finding and classifying fossils – was classed as an amateur is a third explanation (she lacked education). Her class and gender denied membership (or even attendance) to the Geological Society. One of the myths about Anning throughout the 19th and 20th centuries was the idea that she was barely literate: a kind of lower-class fossil prodigy who had little real input into the science of paleontology.

Anning was rarely thanked in academic publications – or even credited for her discoveries. Careful work by historians tracking down the many letters between Anning and prominent geologists revealed not only Anning’s knowledge of fossils, but also of the debates around the long-lost worlds those fossils revealed. Considering the prominent role of amateurs as “citizen scientists” in paleontology today, Anning’s example is telling.

Big scientific ideas

Another reason that Anning had little impact during her lifetime and beyond is a bias for grand scientific theories. Scientists who are considered great and heroic – think Charles Darwin or Isaac Newton – all built systematic theories about how the universe worked. Anning, by contrast, collected fossils and prepared them for display (although we now know she influenced the debate as well).

Cast of Plesiosaurus macrocephalus found by Mary Anning in 1830. Muséum national d'histoire naturelle, Paris/wikipedia, CC BY-SA

However, Darwin similarly depended on careful breeding experiments and natural observations, while Newton relied on an enormous network of traders, explorers and astronomers to collect the experimental data underlying his work. Anning was a remarkably skilled, knowledgeable field worker and fossil preparator. The science of field work, fossil preparation and so forth – often invisible – is necessary and important in itself.

Anning died of breast cancer in 1847 after a rough decade. In the late 1830s, fossil hunting became more difficult and her last sale to the British Museum is recorded in 1840. She was not forgotten by the geological community who had so benefited from her discoveries though. They helped grant her a £25 annuity in 1838.

The philosopher Derek Turner has mused about how the history of palaeontology might have been different if Anning was given the recognition and support she deserved: “What theoretical contributions might she have made? And how might our popular images of the fossil hunter have developed differently? Would we think differently about commercial fossil collecting? Would women be better represented and more visible in palaeontology today?”

A statue to Mary Anning doesn’t simply commemorate her remarkable achievements – achievements made despite considerable bias – but what she could have achieved had she lived in a world without that bias.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The Conversation

Adrian Currie does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

  • The numbers are in, and Johnson's government really is world-beating
    Entertainment
    The Guardian

    The numbers are in, and Johnson's government really is world-beating

    The numbers are in, and Johnson's government really is world-beatingIt’s not just Cummings. From laughing Hancock to cheery Sunak, they all want to style out this whole 60,000 dead thing * Coronavirus – latest updates * See all our coronavirus coverage

  • ‘I felt the tears come tonight’: Kate Garraway shares emotional message about husband suffering from coronavirus
    Celebrity
    The Independent

    ‘I felt the tears come tonight’: Kate Garraway shares emotional message about husband suffering from coronavirus

    Kate Garraway has shared an emotional message about her husband Derek Draper, who is in hospital being treated for coronavirus.The Good Morning Britain host has been posting regular news to her followers, after Draper, an author and former lobbyist, was admitted to hospital at the beginning of April.

  • Couple who spent 20 years restoring six-bedroom manor house fight plans for quarry 100m away
    News
    Yahoo News UK

    Couple who spent 20 years restoring six-bedroom manor house fight plans for quarry 100m away

    Barbara and Simon Campbell's lovingly renovated 16th century manor house, which they bought in 1999, could lose value due to a quarry with planning permission from the 1950s.

  • Trump goes to war on multiple fronts as older and women voters flee
    Politics
    The Independent

    Trump goes to war on multiple fronts as older and women voters flee

    Donald Trump is in trouble, trailing former Vice President Joe Biden nationally and in most key swing states. He's lost – for now, at least – older voters and white educated women.The president appears to know his road to a second term is going to be winding and uphill. So he is, once again, following his instincts. And they always tell him one thing: Fight.

  • Britain's double shame: coronavirus deaths and economic collapse
    News
    The Guardian

    Britain's double shame: coronavirus deaths and economic collapse

    Britain's double shame: coronavirus deaths and economic collapse. Lockdown is likely to go down in history as the UK’s most costly policy failure of modern times

  • Coronavirus is 'lurking', WHO expert warns after Boris Johnson announces lockdown easing
    Health
    Evening Standard

    Coronavirus is 'lurking', WHO expert warns after Boris Johnson announces lockdown easing

    Coronavirus has “not gone away” and is “lurking”, a World Health Organisation expert warned today after Boris Johnson announced lockdown restrictions would be eased .Dr David Nabarro, the WHO’s Covid-19 special envoy, said people needed to be prepared against the fast-spreading virus as measures are relaxed.

  • UK chief negotiator: EU request for Brexit extension would be rejected
    News
    PA Media: Video

    UK chief negotiator: EU request for Brexit extension would be rejected

    The UK’s chief negotiator has pledged that any request for an extension to the Brexit transition period from the EU will be rejected. David Frost said that the Government’s position on the issue is “pretty clear”, and that negotiators are working towards an end of year deadline.

  • UK coronavirus death toll passes 38,000 after rise of 324
    News
    Evening Standard

    UK coronavirus death toll passes 38,000 after rise of 324

    The UK coronavirus death toll has passed 38,000 after a rise of 324.Chancellor Rishi Sunak confirmed the toll in hospitals, care homes and the wider community had climbed to 38,161 at this afternoon's Downing Street briefing.

  • UK opens door to citizenship bids from 300,000 Hong Kong residents unless China scraps security law
    News
    The Independent

    UK opens door to citizenship bids from 300,000 Hong Kong residents unless China scraps security law

    The government has appeared to invite hundreds of thousands of Hong Kong residents to make UK citizenship bids amid concerns over China’s planned national security law, which critics warn would eviscerate the notion of “one country, two systems”.Foreign secretary Dominic Raab said the UK would allow the roughly 300,000 people in Hong Kong who hold British national overseas (BNO) passports to stay in the country for 12 months, instead of the current six, unless China scraps the proposed law.

  • I've Recently Fallen in Love With Tinted Sunscreen, and Here Are 10 of My Favorites
    Style
    Pop Sugar UK Beauty

    I've Recently Fallen in Love With Tinted Sunscreen, and Here Are 10 of My Favorites

    While I've been staying home and not seeing anyone outside of my immediate family, my skin-care routine has flourished, but my makeup routine has dwindled. I'm mildly concerned that I've forgotten how to apply eyeliner, but that's a discussion for another day. My daily "makeup routine" has consisted of precisely two products that also double as skin care: tinted lip balm and tinted sunscreen. I've become fanatical about applying sunscreen even if I'm on my laptop all day because it can help protect from blue light, and now that it's summer, sunscreen is essential. These 10 sunscreens should definitely be on your radar. Some are fully tinted, while others provide a more subtle glow, but they'll all give your skin a boost while still keeping you protected. It has proven to be the easiest way to literally and figuratively brighten my day, and I think it'll brighten yours, too. Related: 12 Clean Hair-Care Products We're Stocking Up On at Sephora

  • Exclusive: Durham Police face prospect of inquiry after complaints over Dominic Cummings probe
    News
    The Telegraph

    Exclusive: Durham Police face prospect of inquiry after complaints over Dominic Cummings probe

    The police chief who carried out the investigation into Dominic Cummings is now facing the prospect of an inquiry over her force’s handling of the matter, The Telegraph can reveal. Durham Police have received a number of complaints from members of the public angry at the way the investigation was dealt with. The complaints came after the force announced that Mr Cummings might have committed a minor breach of the lockdown rules when he drove to Barnard Castle on Easter Sunday. It is understood some of the complaints are against Durham’s Chief Constable, Jo Farrell, who was appointed to the top job last summer. The complaints have been passed to the Force’s professional standards department and they will now be assessed before a decision is made whether to take the matters further. The Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) will also be informed in line with the usual process, but a spokesman for the watchdog said no referrals had yet been made. It is not clear at this stage whether the complaints are from people angry that the police decided to investigate Mr Cummings in the first place, or whether they are from people upset at the findings of the probe and the decision not to take any further action against him. A number of complaints have also been lodged against the force’s acting police and crime commissioner, Steve White, who last week wrote to Ms Farrell urging her to launch the investigation into Mr Cummings. Durham’s police and crime panel will now assess the validity of the complaints against Mr White, who took over as temporary PCC following the death of his predecessor, Ron Hogg in December. Last week he publicly called for the force to carry out a criminal investigation into Mr Cummings, insisting it was important to maintain public confidence in the police. In a letter to Ms Farrell he said the inquiry was vital to establish the facts concerning any potential breach of the law or regulations by the Prime Minister’s most senior aide. On Monday Durham Constabulary confirmed it was investigating the matter following a series of complaints from members of the public. On Thursday Durham Police said Mr Cummings’ 50-mile round trip to Barnard Castle on Easter Sunday, which he claimed had been in order to test his eyesight, “might have been a minor breach of the Regulations that would have warranted police intervention.”

  • Neighbours casts former Home and Away star Johnny Ruffo in guest role
    Celebrity
    Digital Spy

    Neighbours casts former Home and Away star Johnny Ruffo in guest role

    He has also appeared on Dancing with the Stars and X Factor in Oz.

  • Coronavirus news – live: Rishi Sunak announces changes to furlough scheme as No 10 admits alert level remains ‘high’
    News
    The Independent

    Coronavirus news – live: Rishi Sunak announces changes to furlough scheme as No 10 admits alert level remains ‘high’

    Socially distanced gatherings of up to six people will be allowed in outdoor spaces in England from Monday, Boris Johnson has announced as part of plans to gradually ease the country’s lockdown.The prime minister confirmed all five tests required to move to the next stage had been met, schools to begin reopening and greater contact to be permitted from next week.

  • Russia slams 'dangerous' US foreign policy moves
    News
    AFP

    Russia slams 'dangerous' US foreign policy moves

    Russia said on Thursday the United States was acting in a dngerous and unpredictable way, after Washington withdrew from a key military treaty and moved to ramp up pressure on Iran.

  • Attack on Taiwan an option to stop independence, top China general says
    News
    Reuters

    Attack on Taiwan an option to stop independence, top China general says

    China will attack Taiwan if there is no other way of stopping it from becoming independent, one of the country's most senior generals said on Friday, in a rhetorical escalation from China aimed at the democratic island Beijing claims as its own. Speaking at Beijing's Great Hall of the People on the 15th anniversary of the Anti-Secession Law, Li Zuocheng, chief of the Joint Staff Department and member of the Central Military Commission, left the door open to using force. The 2005 law gives the country the legal basis for military action against Taiwan if it secedes or seems about to, making the narrow Taiwan Strait a potential military flashpoint.

  • Exclusive: Matt Hancock Faces Second Warning Over Coronavirus Test Figures
    News
    HuffPost UK

    Exclusive: Matt Hancock Faces Second Warning Over Coronavirus Test Figures

    Another rare letter of concern being considered by the UK Statistics Authority.

  • UK chief negotiator rules out fish for financial services Brexit deal
    News
    The Telegraph

    UK chief negotiator rules out fish for financial services Brexit deal

    Britain’s chief Brexit negotiator has ruled out any deal giving European boats access to UK waters in return for better conditions for British financial services in the EU’s Single Market. The EU and the UK are deeply divided over fishing in free trade negotiations ahead of the next round of talks, which start on Monday, David Frost told peers in the European Union Select Committee on Thursday. Brussels also rejected British calls for an improved system of regulatory recognition for the City of London than the “equivalence” model currently on offer, during the last round of negotiations. Those talks ended in deadlock and mutual recrimination with both sides urging each other to drop their red lines. Leo Varadkar, the Irish prime minister, and Phil Hogan, the EU’s trade commissioner, have both suggested that a “fish for financial services” compromise could be struck to break the deadlock between the two sides. Mr Hogan, who is Ireland's EU commissioner, said yesterday, "Perhaps the United Kingdom has come to the conclusion that there’s not going to be a deal.” “I don’t think fisheries is something we are going to link to anything,” Boris Johnson’s top Brexit official said. The Political Declaration, a joint document for the trade talks, said that a deal on fishing and financial services should be completed by July, ahead of the end of year deadline for the trade deal to be finalised. Mr Frost said he thought the deadline would be missed and repeated that the UK would not ask for an extension to the transition period to allow time for more trade negotiations beyond December 31. “I'm sure we'll carry on talking after June 30. Obviously, at some point, there will need to be a negotiation on the arrangements for 21, whether there's an agreement or not,” Mr Frost said. “If there isn't an agreement that will reflect the fact that we're in the independent coastal state, and we'll control access, and fishing in our waters at that point.” He added, “So, that is the reality that we have to contend with, if the EU doesn't evolve its position and try and reach an agreement with us.”

  • Man charged with murder of 16-year-old Louise Smith
    News
    PA Media: UK News

    Man charged with murder of 16-year-old Louise Smith

    Shane Lee Mays, 29, is to appear at Portsmouth Magistrates’ Court on Friday

  • Exclusive: Travellers could be asked to take coronavirus test before getting on planes
    News
    The Telegraph

    Exclusive: Travellers could be asked to take coronavirus test before getting on planes

    Britons could have to take 20-minute coronavirus tests before arriving at the airport under proposals being considered by ministers as part of a bid to enable holidays abroad this summer. An expert committee of scientists, ministers, civil servants and aviation chiefs is considering tests that would enable travellers to sidestep quarantine and could be used to replace travel restrictions. They are also working on “travel corridors” to link the UK to low-risk destinations by air, land and sea as the most immediate way to lift the 14-day quarantines for holidays before the end of the summer. The 14-day quarantine for all international arrivals to the UK - including returning Britons - is due to be introduced on June 8 requiring them to self-isolate for 14 days. It will be reviewed by June 29, which is seen by ministers as a potential first date to open up “air corridors” and trial coronavirus tests, although the aviation industry is pressing for a quicker start. Matt Hancock, the Health Secretary, said he was “a little more optimistic” about reviving foreign travel this summer. Asked if people could now hope for a July holiday abroad, he said: “I absolutely wouldn’t rule it out. We’ve got to proceed cautiously… I definitely wouldn’t say no and I know how important it is for so many people.” Greece and Iceland already offer coronavirus tests to arriving travellers with results returned within 24 hours, enabling them to avoid quarantine. Vienna airport offers a similar service for £166 (€190) with test results back in half an hour. A Department for Transport source said: “What is being mooted is a mutually recognised test where a foreign businessman, say, has a test a day before flying that is accredited. It could enable people to travel but maintain public health.” The other option being considered is to screen at the airport before flights although there are concerns about the practicality and potential delays if passenger numbers increase. Emirates, Dubai’s state-owned carrier, trialled a swab test for passengers on one of its flights to Tunisia last month. Their results were returned within 10 minutes, enabling the coronavirus checks to be completed during check-in. The moves come amid growing criticism of quarantine as nearly 80 leading names in the tourist industry and a cross-party group of 40 MPs, including seven former ministers, urged the Government on Wednesday to ditch the “unworkable” plans. The same day Boris Johnson told MPs he wanted to have "as sensible a quarantine scheme as possible and to keep flows as generous as we can". The Prime Minister indicated "air bridges" could be implemented by the end of June, providing the UK reached agreements with countries deemed to be low-risk. “There is certainly a willingness in Government to try to do as much for this summer as is safe,” said a Department for Transport (DfT) source. Greece, Spain, Italy, Portugal and Germany are expected to have lifted border and quarantine restrictions for tourists by mid-June so that most holiday travel could open up in July. A new internationally agreed set of standards for “safe” post-coronavirus travel is being drawn up by the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) which would cover the conditions for “travel corridors” or “air bridges” between countries. This would include the transmission rates expected of participating countries, the defences each country would have to have in place to combat coronavirus infections and the health measures expected during travel to minimise the risk of catching the disease. Karen Dee, chief Executive of the Airport Operators’ Association, said the guidelines offered the chance for the Government to introduce air and travel corridors at the same time as it imposed quarantine on June 8. “Our neighbours and key trading partners are taking steps to lift their blanket travel restrictions such as quarantine requirements towards a science-led, risk-based approach. The UK now needs to do the same as soon as possible, or risk being left behind,” she told The Daily Telegraph. “With European guidelines ensuring there is a common standard for health measures to protect air passengers and staff, the right conditions are in place to open up air corridors to many of our European neighbours as soon as quarantine restrictions come in place on June 8. “This would benefit not just aviation but also the thousands of businesses and millions of jobs that depend on air connectivity, such as in tourism, manufacturing and the UK food industry.” Henry Smith, chair of the 40-strong group of MPs, said quarantine was “well-intentioned” but “unworkable” and was being implemented at the wrong time when the rest of Europe was opening up. He said air and travel corridors offered the best “short-term” solution with testing a potential component. “One of the biggest answers to this is getting an international consensus,” he said. “We need to revive aviation before the bulk of the summer travel season, ideally by July 1 but as soon as possible.”

  • Dominic Cummings and Boris Johnson have wrecked something precious
    News
    The Guardian

    Dominic Cummings and Boris Johnson have wrecked something precious

    Dominic Cummings and Boris Johnson have wrecked something precious. Their actions may damage the Tories’ political prospects, but the real victim is the British people’s trust in those in charge

  • Trump news: President threatens to 'shut down' Twitter as Pelosi calls social media order a 'distraction' amid coronavirus 'failure'
    Politics
    The Independent

    Trump news: President threatens to 'shut down' Twitter as Pelosi calls social media order a 'distraction' amid coronavirus 'failure'

    Donald Trump has signed an executive order on Thursday targeting social media companies following his threats to “strongly regulate” or “close down” platforms after Twitter fact-checked a pair of his tweets making false statements about the extent of voter fraud in the US.The president was incandescent with fury on Wednesday after Twitter moved to cast doubt on his spurious claims by directing readers to a topic page where they could “get the facts” on the issue, wildly accusing the company of “stifling FREE SPEECH” in a tweet whose very existence undermined his argument, despite social media platforms making similar efforts to combat campaign misinformation ahead of US elections.

  • Sir Keir Starmer joins final 'Clap for Carers' event
    News
    ITN

    Sir Keir Starmer joins final 'Clap for Carers' event

    Labour Party Leader Sir Keir Starmer has joined a national round of applause in the final 'Clap for Carers' event outside his London home.