'X Factor': Fans and judges divided over rocker's 'nutty' take on Britney classic
X Factor contestant Giovanni Spano gave an unforgettable rendition of Britney Spears classic debut singe …Baby One More Time on Saturday night’s ‘guilty pleasure’ themed show.
The 33-year-old West End performer added a screeching rock element to the just turned 20-years-old pop tune, which left both the audience at home and the judges somewhat astounded.
A shocked Simon Cowell admitted it was a guilty pleasure for him as ‘it is something you shouldn’t like, but you do like it. And that’s what you did!’
He went on to say it was both ‘mental’ and ‘fantastic.’
Rocking up a Britney classic 🎸
One more time for @GiovanniSpano5!@TheXFactor #XFactor pic.twitter.com/cXmTEAiJ6U
— ITV (@ITV) October 27, 2018
“It was so nutty and so mental it was fantastic! You are so interesting and so crazy…One of the craziest things we’ve ever had on this show!” Cowell said.
However, Louis Tomlinson wasn’t so convinced, and while admitted Giovanni was a ‘lovely guy’ the performance was just all a bit too much for him.
“Gio you definitely embraced the theme and it goes without saying you are a lovely guy and the most polite guy I’ve ever met actually. But it was just one step too intense and too weird for me.
“I understand you wanted to an original version of the song but it was just all a bit too mental for me to be honest,” Tomlinson said.
His words were met with a round of boos from the audience and Robbie Williams followed up with a quip about Britney Spears and Justin Timberlake’s infamous break-up.
“All I can say is if Britney had sung it exactly like that, Justin would never have left!” Williams said.
“Listen Gio! Real men were pink and real rockstars sing Britney!” Williams wife and fellow judge Ayda Field added.
Host Dermot O’Learly joked ‘Tomlinson not reading the room there!’ to which a smiling Tomlinson replied, “I know, I know!”
But it seems that Tomlinson’s remarks were actually indeed what many people were thinking watching at home. As fans flocked to Twitter to slate the bold performance.
I’ll hit you one more time alright if you don’t pipe down Gio x #XFactor
— Sally Ann Matthews (@SallyAnMatthews) October 27, 2018
#XFactor THEY DID ONE OF THE GREATEST HITS OF 2000S SO DIRTY!!!! BRITNEY BABY I'M SORRY!!!
— Anamite Louie ◟̽◞̽ (@VitaminTlwt) October 27, 2018
Britney if she was watching that Gio performance. #XFactor pic.twitter.com/CUbR3iZpIK
— 🔥Justine🔥 (@OwlinFlight) October 27, 2018
He just ruined a Britney Spears song I am FURIOUS. #XFactor
— aimee (@JoeyGraceffc) October 27, 2018
Atleast Gio is singing a real guilty pleasure… Even if he does trigger my anxiety with his shouting #XFactor
— Rebekka-Mary Darling (@RebekkaMary) October 27, 2018
What was Gio just doing?? NO NO NO. #xfactor pic.twitter.com/hP3hImSwuA
— Katie B (@KatieB_WhoME) October 27, 2018
Of course there were many solid Giovanni fans out there, who also took to Twitter to praise his wacky performance.
Ok…I really like Giovannis Britney version?! What’s happened to me?! #Xfactor
— Natasha Atlas (@NatashaAtlas_) October 27, 2018
Not gonna lie, I LOVED Gio’s performance. Please don’t hate me 🙈 #xfactor
— Chelsea Leigh (@chelsealeigh_x) October 27, 2018
Best act of the night. Gio! Yes! #xfactor
— ShitSarahSays (@ShitSarahSays89) October 27, 2018
Hour and half later we actually have a guilty pleasure! Yes Gio!! #XFactor
— Beth (@BethS_5) October 27, 2018
X Factor continues at 8pm on Sunday on ITV.
X Factor Girls deny One Direction split claims
X Factor Overs defend Ayda Field as ‘real deal’
X Factor loses to Strictly in ratings war