Does earning £70k a year make you rich? Piers Morgan joins debate started by Labour
The debate has been raging on social media and in the pages of our broadsheets for a week: does earning £70,000 a year make one rich?
The Labour Party started the argument, by pledging to raise taxes for "rich people", a class they defined as those earning more than £70,000-£80,000 a year.
However, many said that this is a bad definition of wealth, and argued that earning that much in London doesn't make a person rich, especially if they have a family to support.
12 million people live in London, one fifth of our entire population. https://t.co/plsSCV4xHZ
— Piers Morgan (@piersmorgan) April 26, 2017
Piers Morgan brought the whole country in on the debate as he said on Wednesday morning that he did not agree earning that much makes you rich in London.
He claimed that "70k in London would only buy you a bag of carrots".
Many disagreed, as that wage would put someone in the top percentage of earners, and tweeted that the television presenter was out-of-touch.
@piersmorgan Try being a nurse living in London £70k would be a dream, how much do you earn?
— Davd Thomas (@DavidRN3) April 26, 2017
Not sure where @piersmorgan gets his carrots. 70k? @susannareid100 looked equally stunned. pic.twitter.com/SDYcWtZOW6
— Matthew Hill (@mat_hil) April 26, 2017
@piersmorgan £70k for a bag of carrots!!@susannareid100 your face was worth so much more than £70k ����
— Juan Cornetto (@whyjuan) April 26, 2017
The argument began when Shadow Chancellor John McDonnell said last week on BBC Radio 4 that: “We believe … the rich will be above £70,000 to £80,000 a year and that’s roughly defined as what people feel is an earning whereby people feel they can pay more.”
Many online argued that this wage isn't unimaginable wealth, and is indeed an aspirational figure for people in many professions.
Earning £70k a year does not make you "rich" lol... That's not even a spectacular salary when applying for a mortgage in London...
— political hipster ™ (@escofree) April 20, 2017
John McDonnell says rich is earning above £70,000 a year. It's like he wants to kill Labour in London.
— Josh Spero (@joshspero) April 19, 2017
Dear John McDonnell,
The election is about #Brexit.
£70k/pa is nice but not 'rich'.
Pl step down & take Corbyn with you.— Janet Pirrie (@JanetLPirrie) April 19, 2017
.@johnmcdonnellMP confirms on @BBCr4today if you earn more than £70k you're rich & @LabourParty will make you pay more tax. Got that? #GE17
— Jeet Bains (@CllrJeetBains) April 19, 2017
However, others pointed out that just over 5% of taxpayers earned at least this amount in 2014-15.
And Emily Thornberry disagreed with her colleague, saying “I think there are many people on £70,000 who may well feel that their circumstances are such that they are not rich".