In the First Presidential Debate, Biden Floundered, While Trump (Let’s Just Say It) Performed With Confidence and Angry Flair

Owen Gleiberman

28 June 2024 at 0:06 am·6-min read

I hate to be the bringer of bad news, but Donald Trump didn’t just give a better performance than Joe Biden during the first 2024 presidential debate. In terms of authority and confidence, quickness and poise, articulation and verve, Trump left Biden in the dust. Relative to his previous debate performances, Trump even came off as (God help us) presidential. I’m sorry, but that’s what happened.

Biden told a lot more truth, but he didn’t tell it well. From the opening moments of his walk toward the podium, he looked almost ghostly; Trump, by contrast, sauntered on stage with an angry bravado. And from his first answer on inflation, Biden launched into a mode of speaking that left one hoping that he’d get to the end of each answer. That is not presidential.

More from Variety

I’d argue that his performance was little short of a disaster. Biden seemed at once glassy and wooden, rushing his words, skimming over the top of them even when the content was solid. His voice was scratchy, at times almost a whisper, and his answers were scattered. His head was talking but it seemed separate from his body. Early on, he had one extended faltering moment that was agonizing, ending with the line “We finally beat Medicare.” Huh? It was Biden shorthand for “We finally beat the issue,” but it played as a gaffe, and it allowed Trump to answer him by presenting himself as the great defender of Social Security.

Call that the first of Trump’s whoppers. He lied through his teeth, of course, most spectacularly about his own presidential record (on immigration, the economy, COVID — you name it, he told tall tales about it). Trump made statements that ranged from the extreme (“China’s going to own us if you keep allowing them to do what they’re doing to our country”) to ultra-extreme (“We are very, very close to World War III”). Yet most of his performance was a master class in how an extreme politician can normalize himself for the purpose of getting elected. Given the ruthless parameters of his personality, Trump plugged into classic conservative mythology and spoke with an I’ve-got-your-back ease that allowed him to present himself in a way that seemed, at times, almost Reagan-esque. He was relaxed, confident, articulate and fast on his feet.

Gone, for the most part, was the gleefully disreputable stand-up-comedian-as-bad-boy-assassin personality — his willingness to say the wrong thing, the incorrect thing, which looks to a lot of people like noble rebellion against an overly controlled age — that was at the center of Trump’s performance during his debates with Hillary Clinton. Trump allowed himself to breathe fire on immigration, but for the most part he presented himself as a classic post-Reagan figure, preaching conservative boilerplate. He defended his economic policies with a classic argument of trickle-down malarkey.

Trump was able to weaponize the age of disinformation — to endow everything he said with the magic aura of “If I say it with enough punch and conviction, enough prowess, enough faith in my own authority, I’ll make it true.” To undo that kind of con-man jauntiness, you need an adversary every bit as wily in his power, who can not just accuse Trump of lying but make the lying sound sinister. But it seemed as if all Joe Biden could do was make Democratic talking points sound like data.

Biden seemed so entrapped in his testy policy-point mind that he had a way of giving almost every answer a bit of the aura that one remembers from Mike Dukakis’ famous 1988 debate non-response about what he would do if Kitty Dukakis were raped and killed. Dukakis gave a woefully dispassionate answer (one that’s commonly thought to have sealed his election defeat), and Biden, too, kept meeting questions about crucial issues as if he were reciting the answers, as if bureaucratic detail could handle human problems. It’s not that the fine points of policy don’t matter. It’s that a presidential candidate in the mega-media age must know how to frame the issues in a potent human way. He has to sweep up his listeners.

And that’s just what Trump has learned to do. No matter how vividly this idea is conveyed, too many Americans fail to grasp its upshot: that Donald Trump is Entertainment, and that he has used politics to perfect his role as a showbiz paragon. He’s a genuine (so-so) wheeler-dealer businessman, but he played an imperious executive deity on TV, and he’s still playing one. Yes, he’s a liar, a huckster, a bully, a racist, a convicted felon and now a potential authoritarian demagogue. But to great swaths of the American people, the reason all this somehow doesn’t matter is that he’s the figure in the presidential race who grips them, who has all the good lines. And that’s the Trump we saw tonight.

Trump learned most of his bullying, postmodern dark-side-of-Warhol media-manipulation techniques from Roy Cohn, who he sucked up to as a kind of father figure and then abandoned (in no small part because of his homophobic disgust over the fact that Cohn had AIDS). But a major part of what Ramin Setoodeh, the co-editor-in-chief of Variety, captures in his new book “Apprentice in Wonderland” is how “The Apprentice,” in effect, became Trump’s second Roy Cohn. The glittering network series taught him how to project himself as an actor, how to tailor Cohn’s backroom methods of reality manipulation to the hyper-(non)reality of reality TV.

He is still, in effect, the president of the National Entertainment State. And if you find yourself saying, “But this is politics. This matters. How can people look past Trump’s immorality as a human being?,” it’s worth noting that his ability to trump the enfeebled bureaucratic shambling of Joe Biden is a degraded version of something that’s long been there in our presidential contests, certainly since JFK vs. Nixon — the Happy Warrior syndrome. Trump, even under attack by the law, is the Happy Warrior because you can feel how much he enjoys destroying the things around him. That’s not a Happy Warrior who should be president, but it’s the one that America is stuck with.

He can only be defeated by another Happy Warrior. Biden, tonight, was so far from being that person that his performance already appears to have set off a fire alarm within the Democratic Party. Can he be replaced? That will now, at least, be the question on the lips of many Democrats. But one reason for that should not be understated: Donald Trump, hewing to a mostly middle-of-the-script, dodging questions like an ace lawyer about whether he’d accept the election results, tonight did the job of making himself seem more viable than reckless. Whoever the Democratic candidate for president is, be it Joe Biden or someone else, he or she will have to undo that.

Best of Variety

People
Taylor Swift’s Backup Dancer Gives NSFW Shoutout in Irish During Dublin Eras Tour Show: Watch
The singer's backup dancer, Kameron Saunders, gave the fun nod during a performance of "We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together"
The Telegraph
Labour vote share falls to lowest in more than two years
Labour’s vote share has fallen to its lowest level in more than two years ahead of the general election, new polling shows.
The Telegraph
Old, rich and living on benefits: welcome to the state pension capital of Britain
East Preston feels an unlikely stronghold of benefits dependency. The genteel village on the West Sussex coast might be the closest thing that Britain has to a moneyed pensioner utopia.
The Telegraph
Donald Trump is going to turn Starmer’s Britain into an international laughing stock
Grandfather Robert Blackstock, a retired engineer from Nottinghamshire, became the “Brenda from Bristol” of this election campaign when he asked Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer during Wednesday night’s TV debate: “Are you two really the best we’ve got to be the next prime minister of our great country?”
The Independent
Led by Donkeys interrupt Nigel Farage speech by lowering huge Putin banner
Nigel Farage was initially unaware that the Russian president was on the poster, with the words ‘I heart Nigel’ written below
The Telegraph
Did Nigel Farage blow himself up in the BBC Question Time election special? Our writers react
It was finally Nigel Farage’s time to appear before a BBC Question Time audience this evening, more than a week after Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer had theirs. The Reform UK leader took the podium in the same hour as a Green Party representative, Adrian Ramsay. Yet only one of these men has excited reaction from our writers.
Manchester Evening News
'My mortgage has doubled... the country's gone to pot': The Greater Manchester neighbourhood where people want change
'I was born and bred here... I've never known the place be as big of a dump as it is'
HuffPost
Critics Clown Trump's 'IDIOTIC' Electric Planes Remarks: 'Dumb As A Box Of Rocks'
"What happens if the sun isn’t shining while you’re up in the air?” the former president asked at a rally in Virginia.
Associated Press
A private call of top Democrats fuels more insider anger about Biden's debate performance
A sense of concern is growing inside the top ranks of the Democratic Party that leaders of Joe Biden’s campaign and the Democratic National Committee are not taking seriously enough the impact of the president’s troubling debate performance earlier in the week. DNC Chairman Jaime Harrison and Biden campaign manager Julie Chavez Rodriguez held a Saturday afternoon call with dozens of committee members across the country, a group of some of the most influential members of the party.
PA Media: UK News
Rishi Sunak: I’ll still be Prime Minister on Friday
The Conservative leader defended his party’s record in government against what he described as a ‘declinist narrative’.
Business Insider
A grinding Russian assault appears telling about Putin's plan to defeat Ukraine
ISW's conflict experts warned that the West must "challenge Putin's belief that he can gradually subsume Ukraine."
The Telegraph
How Biden’s disastrous debate could end up benefiting the Democrats
Donald Trump’s allies were like Cheshire cats as they celebrated in the spin room backstage at the TV debate in Atlanta on Thursday night.
The Telegraph
A Labour landslide would leave the UK unrecognisable
Until now, Sir Keir Starmer has carefully hidden the Labour Party’s radical, hard-Left agenda from the public. But on the brink of the largest majority in nearly a century, his mask has slipped.
CNN
A year ago, she drank battery acid to escape life under the Taliban. Today, she has a message for other Afghan girls
Arzo survived a suicide attempt but now faces a new threat that could send her family – and millions like them – back to Afghanistan and a life that has become so intolerable for women and girls that some would rather die.
The Guardian
Who could replace Rishi Sunak as Tory leader if he loses the election?
Likely contenders for party’s sixth leader in eight years could depend partly on who survives a big defeat
The Telegraph
Jill Biden has the fate of the world in her hands
Now might be a good time for Dr Jill Biden, the First Lady, to have a rummage around in the back of the wardrobe for one particular item of clothing. When Joe Biden opted against running for president in 2004, his decision was underlined by his wife’s decision to wear a halter top with the word “NO” scrawled on her stomach.
The Telegraph
‘Trillion dollar trainwreck’: US super stealth fighter is eating the next generation
All of a sudden, the US Air Force is considering cancelling a multibillion-dollar effort to develop a new stealth fighter. Citing the high cost of the so-called “Next-Generation Air Dominance” programme and the competing demands of other projects, USAF leaders have warned they may have no choice but to cancel NGAD – and find other ways of winning control of the air in future wars.
The Telegraph
How do you get rid of a dictator? Here are some tips
In an age when dictators and authoritarian regimes are all the rage, it becomes all the more imperative for peace-loving democrats to consider ways of getting rid of them. Yet on some happy – albeit rare – occasions, the more repellent members of the dictatorial species, by dint of incompetence or arrogance, manage to do the job themselves.
Sky video
France election: Marine Le Pen on the brink of power, as Emmanuel Macron's big gamble looks set to fail
In France, politics is happening at a ferocious pace.
The Telegraph
Tory Remainers are the authors of their party’s defeat
The oddity of European politics is that Britain is moving sharply to the Left while most of the Continent is moving even further to the Right. In Britain, young people and even the middle aged are abandoning Conservatism. Elsewhere in Europe, the young are the pillars of a radical Right-wing upsurge. On the Continent, the cause is largely frustration with the consequences of being in the EU. In Britain, it is largely a backlash against being out of it.

Latest stories